Over the weekend word of a truly stunning statement from Mike Genest, Arnold’s right-wing ideologue Finance Director, circulated around the internets. We’ll quote the report from our friends at Calbuzz:
Calbuzz sat in on a conference call with state Finance Director Mike Genest on Friday, in which he detailed the latest $3 billion of cuts Governor Arnold is proposing to close the Deficit That Ate Sacramento…
The most salient, big picture point, however, came in Genest’s clear and direct response to a great question by Judy Lin of the AP, who asked why it was that all the pain of budget cuts seems to fall on the poor. Said Genest:
“If you look at what the government does, the government doesn’t provide services to rich people. We don’t provide many services even to the middle class…”
This is one of the biggest lies that has ever been told in American politics. The notion that government services only go to the poor is complete bullshit, as is the implicit notion that the rich derive no benefits, direct or indirect, from state fiscal policy. Genest is arguing against the very concept of a safety net – to him, a recession is a time to take away supports for the jobless, a time to instead force them to fend for themselves by spending more money they don’t have.
Let us count the ways Mike Genest is a liar:
The Middle Class receives:
• Unemployment insurance
• Public education – including subsidized higher ed and Cal Grants (I wouldn’t have gone to UC Berkeley without it!)
• State-provided health care assistance (yeah, many middle-class folks are themselves on, or have family members who depend upon, things like dialysis, AIDS drugs, IHSS, etc)
• Food stamps and Cal-WORKS (yeah, the recession is so severe that many formerly middle-class households are using these services to get by)
• Cal Fire, the Highway Patrol, etc
• California State Parks – not just for recreation, but for income. Many middle-class families derive income from tourists visiting nearby parks, as many employees and small business owners in my Monterey neighborhood can attest
• Freeways, commuter trains, buses (although the state isn’t supporting them any more!), which subsidize a middle-class suburban lifestyle
I’m sure there are others. But let’s move on to the highest incomes.
The wealthy receive:
• All of the above
• Income based on the economic activity enabled by the above (without the safety net, folks won’t spend, and the incomes of the rich will plummet)
• Over $12 billion in tax giveaways since 1993
• The benefits of Prop 13, ensuring that their property taxes are artificially low, especially if they own or derive income from commercial property.
That’s just a very brief listing; we could spend hours tallying the ways the middle- and upper-classes derive major benefits from state programs. It’s stunning that we even have to explain that obvious point to Genest or to Calitics readers. But then it’s par for the course from a right-wing that is convinced Hoover was right, and that the New Deal was both unnecessary and harmful to the country, all evidence to the contrary be damned.
Combined with Susan Kennedy’s explicit call for a regressive tax system, Genest’s misleading interpretation of the role of the state in economic growth and prosperity is part of a rather surprisingly explicit move to use the budget crisis as a shock doctrine moment to destroy the middle-class, further immiserate the poor, and turn California into a paradise for the rich that would make Ayn Rand envious.
It’s worth briefly reminding ourselves of how Naomi Klein defined the shock doctrine:
The shock doctrine, like all doctrines, is a philosophy of power. It’s a philosophy about how to achieve your political and economic goals. And this is a philosophy that holds that the best way, the best time, to push through radical free-market ideas is in the aftermath of a major shock. Now, that shock could be an economic meltdown. It could be a natural disaster.
And we are seeing that emerge here in California. Arnold has created a budget crisis that gives him the opportunity to demand implementation of a right-wing economic agenda. He makes it seem as if there is no alternative – “well of course we have to cut social services!” and has the opposition party on board as Democratic leaders still refuse to propose tax increases on the wealthy to preserve these vital programs.
The Schwarzenegger Administration is planning to use this crisis to destroy the middle class and the poor and further enrich the wealthy. The California Dream, the archetype of the postwar American economic model, is about to become a California Nightmare, as those who are not lucky enough to possess wealth will find they have no ability to achieve economic security, educational advancement, or enjoy the kind of safety net that for nearly 80 years Americans have known is necessary to the functioning of a modern economy.
It is time for California’s Democratic legislators to loudly and consistently reject this. They must vow to oppose Arnold’s plans, and refuse to be shock doctrined into carrying out an insane right-wing agenda that will destroy our state.
excellent post.
that will close the deficit (and which can actually be adopted), then is the only solution a new special election to authorize bonds to cover the deficit? No one wants to vote again, but if that’s the only way, then it’s the only way.
“Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth.” (Conan Doyle)
While running errands this weekend I heard radio ads more than once for Windemere, an upscale planned community in the East Bay. If you’ve heard them, please correct me if I have some of the details wrong. A couple is talking about Windemere – the wife notes that the homes have solar panels and are eligible for tax credits. At that point the husband replies enthusiastically: “It’s like the State of California is subsidizing our lifestyle!” Then there is a mention of the excellent local schools and services
From the developer’s website (TOP TEN SCHOOL DISTRICT ADDS VALUE TO LENNAR COMMUNITIES IN SAN RAMON VALLEY): Lennar recognizes the value of a good education. That’s why Lennar builds homes where schools are nationally recognized for their academic distinction. That’s the logic of Lennar.
Consistently ranked in the top five percent of all California school districts according to the California State Board of Education, the San Ramon Valley Unified School District (SRVUSD) received more “Distinguished School” honors- an annual award that recognizes some of the state’s most exemplary public schools-than any other school district in Northern California in 2009.
According to the district’s web site, more than 95 percent of 2008 SRVUSD graduating seniors attended college, with many students attending University of California and California State University schools, as well as Harvard, MIT, Brown, Boston University, Columbia, Georgetown, Northwestern, Notre Dame, Princeton, Vanderbilt, Wellesley and Yale.
In addition to an excellent education, the San Ramon Valley Unified School District offers students state-of-the-art facilities, strong athletic programs and a 20 to 1 student-teacher ratio in all kindergarten through third-grade classrooms. With many of these highly-rated schools conveniently located only a short distance from Lennar’s communities in Windemere, many families opt to walk and bike to school, creating a unique community-centered environment.
Mike Genest needs to remind real estate developers and the real estate industry in general how government doesn’t provide many services to the middle class.
Here’s my nomination for which part of state government provides services to rich people: the whole frickin thing.
To Robert’s starter list, I was going to add a few things like the civil and criminal justice systems that enforce contracts, keep the order, and allow business to be conducted here.
But more generally, how about all the infectious diseases rich people haven’t been catching from the rest of us, since we’ve had some state-supported health care programs? How about the people who use their state-provided education to effectively run the gatehouses of their gated communities? How about the state air quality regulations that keep them from getting poisoned just from breathing that same air they share with the rest of us?
Government programs that work benefit the residents of California. As residents of California, that includes rich people. The whole premise of this guy’s framing is BS. Show me where our pitiable superrich have been falling behind because all the programs are too focused on poor people.
courts to defend their interests.
potable water, edible food, breathable air, an unspoiled coast they can plunk their vacation homes on, public health to deal with disease pandemics…
but perhaps the biggest one is that the state services work to keep the working and middle classes above water so that they do not become desperate and do to the rich what has historically happened in other societies that broke down.
if the social contract is broken, it tends to have consequences for those who still have bread to eat and a roof over their heads.
A less risk adverse progressive politics can use the current crisis to change the conversation.
I personally feel frustrated at the lack of real outlets for this populist anger. Even this site is insufficiently focused on grassroots organizing.
Next time, you may even see a few more of us in Fresno if you give us a reason that relates to economic problems of the state.