Former Assembly Speaker hopes to mediate with California Teachers
by Brian Leubitz
If you are planning to come to the CDP convention in Sacramento in a couple of weeks, it will be no secret that the teachers are an important constituency within the party. And they are critical for elected officials due to their willingness to fight, and spend, for the causes they consider important. Fabian Nunez knew this as Speaker, and he still knows it. But now he might get a chance to see the other side of labor, as he has agreed to represent Michelle Rhee’s “StudentsFirst” organization, a group that focuses on school reform, the extensive use of metrics for teachers, and being something of an opponent to teachers’ unions.
In an interview, Nunez, a Democrat who cut his political teeth as a union operative, said he hopes to play the role of mediator for StudentsFirst and labor leaders, though he made it clear that he thought the CTA had abused its clout with lawmakers. He cited the union’s successful efforts last year to kill legislation that would have sped the dismissal process for teachers who abused students.
Teachers unions said the bill was an attack on teachers’ due-process rights, giving school boards, rather than an administrative judge and two educators, final authority over dismissals.
“When that bill died, I think it gave a lot of people heartache,” Nunez said. “I think there are a lot of labor Democrats who are coming to the conclusion that we can’t read from the CTA script anymore.”(LA Times)
Of course, that bill has become a flashpoint for a lot of so-called reformers, but when it comes down to it, both major teachers unions have worked on negotiating a bill that can work to move potentially abusive teachers out of the classroom quickly while still maintaining a fair process. And just last week, Sen. Alex Padilla, the author of that original controversial bill, signed on to work with Asm. Joan Buchanan on the subject. Padilla is now the principal coauthor of AB 375 – Teacher Discipline and Dismissal and AB 1338 – Mandatory Reporting of Sexual and Child Abuse. (Press release here or over the flip)
But the ills of California education can be plainly spotted by anybody who understands simple arithmetic. We are chronically underfunding our schools. There are only 4 states that spend less per pupil than us, all of which are lower cost states. We are 43rd in educational results, perhaps higher than where we should be given our spending.
Our schools need additional resources, so teachers aren’t forced to spend their own money buying supplies for their students and that all students have the tools to be successful. I don’t doubt that the former Speaker has the best of intentions for our students, but maybe he can help push for some additional resources while he’s at the work of reforming. Our students, and their teachers, deserve better.
Photo credit: Former Speaker Fabian Nunez with Michael Moore, courtesy Randy Bayne
PRESS RELEASE Padilla and Buchanan Join Forces to Protect Children
Lawyers frame an argument; scientists establish facts. Here we have a leap to a conclusion…. “we need more spending”. I wish it were that simple. Here are some facts from the very same sources above:
1) “The per-pupil spending, also sourced from the Casey Foundation, was derived from the National Center for Education Statistics based on the fiscal year 2009. The averages have been adjusted for regional cost differences, including teacher salaries in urban areas versus more remote regions.” – so the standard-of-living statement may be inappropriate.
2) 7 of the 10 worst-performing states have children-living-in-poverty rates at least 13% above the national average (which is a stunningly depressing 23%). This is a better indicator that per-student spending.
3) the report analysts found a “moderately positive” correlation between educational performance and per-student spending. First, correlation is not causation (Stats 101) and “moderately positive” forces the writers to use the verb “tends to” rather than “is”. R-squared values under .6 indicate there is something to this but it is far from complete or simple.
Look, one could throw out many stats but that does not equal cause. Try these on:
1) 8 of the top 10 performing states are at least 14% “whiter” than the nation as a whole
2) the most African-American states (MS and LA) are both in the bottom 10% of educational performance
Are whites smarter? Don’t be ridiculous, of course not. That’s a disgusting thought. So is thinking that spending is the cure-all.
The SacBee reports that in 2006, California was 23rd (above the average) in per-student spending… and California was ranked 46th in the Best Educated Index.
Let me suggest that there is no easy answer as much as the CTA would like there to be one.
California is 23rd or 35th in per pupil spending.
http://www.sacbee.com/2012/06/…
No correlation between spending and performance. d.c has most money, and does poorest.