CA Democratic Congressional Candidates Speak Out Against Afghanistan Escalation

While President Obama seems to think an escalation in Afghanistan is the right move, some California Democrats running for Congress don’t agree. In CA-44, Bill Hedrick (who came surprisingly close to beating Ken Calvert in 2008) has been speaking out against the escalation, and sent this statement out via email:

While President Obama is setting clear benchmarks and urging other nations to participate in Afghanistan, I continue to oppose the decision to send troops.  It places more American lives at risk for the corrupt Karzai government.  Any escalation will cost tens of billions of dollars that would be better spent on creating and keeping jobs in America.

Meanwhile Marcy Winograd, who is again challenging Jane Harman from the left in CA-36, explains her opposition over at Daily Kos:

I voted for Barack Obama. In fact, I volunteered for his campaign.  

But I am not afraid to speak out when the President makes a mistake.

It is wrong to send 30,000 additional troops to Afghanistan….

Like my good friend, Afghanistan veteran Rick Reyes, says, “There is no military solution in Afghanistan.”

When we escalate an indefinite occupation of Afghanistan… when we send unmanned bombers into nuclear-armed Pakistan… when we construct cement fortresses in Iraq… we only engender hatred, create new enemies, and propel a dangerous narrative that we are at war with the entire Muslim world.

We are better than that.

Winograd led the successful effort to get the California Democratic Party to approve a resolution calling for an end to the military occupation in Afghanistan and for more civilian charitable work to address the problems in that country.

It’s just two candidates, but they reflect the growing consensus among California Democrats that the current strategy in Afghanistan, which Obama has now doubled down on, is neither good policy nor good politics.

UPDATE by Robert: Newly elected member of Congress John Garamendi also disagrees with the escalation:

I thank President Obama for his careful and thoughtful deliberation on this matter. He faces a difficult decision on a war he inherited, and I know his heart is in the right place. However, I remain convinced that increased diplomatic, economic, social, and educational assistance in the region will result in a lasting solution in Afghanistan. American national security, our dedicated soldiers already serving, and the people of Afghanistan will be better served if we focus our efforts on improving the socioeconomic conditions of the region instead of sending more of our brave soldiers to fight in this war.

I won’t post all the statements that come out on this, but it is interesting to see this opposition coming together in California. On MSNBC just now Maxine Waters said she wasn’t convinced by the speech and will vote against funding more troops, a position she said Barbara Lee shares.

3 thoughts on “CA Democratic Congressional Candidates Speak Out Against Afghanistan Escalation”

  1. ….CARE how ‘careful and thoughtful…’ Obama’s decision is or was. Listen carefully to a guy who was in ROTC at Berkeley in 1968 and went from that to being a CO and refusing the draft in 1971.

    Yes, that’s me.

    This is an utterly stupid decision. We cannot ‘win’ anything militarily in the ‘Stans and we are hopelessly inept at ‘nation building’ as witness what’s happening here at home. Further, get ready for a bout of inflation such as you newbies to the struggle for a progressive America have never seen.

    And for you whiners who are stuck on the ‘we broke it we gotta fix it…’ canard?

    Set up mechanisms to loan the ‘Stan governments some inflated ca$h and…

    GET THE HELL OUT!

    The folks who live there don’t want us there; they will continue to resist the unlawful takeover of their nation by ours. It’s that simple and no amount of Hubris by President ‘Dopey’ and the other dwarves of the DOD will change that.

    This President has no more cattle under his empty hat than the last one folks.

    He needs to go.

  2. says she opposes sending more troops to Afghanistan, but supports the President’s mission and exit strategy.  

Comments are closed.