I’ve made a few remarks about Arnold’s “assimilation” comments, but Ruben Navarette says it a lot better than me. The column is simply brilliant. He says that Arnold’s comments are:
• Inaccurate because Mexicans do assimilate. A recent study found that, by the second generation, English is dominant for children of Mexican immigrants. By the third generation, only 17 percent still speak fluent Spanish. In the fourth generation, it’s 5 percent.
• Impolite because it’s never a good idea to compare one group to another. Schwarzenegger contrasted Mexicans to Asians, whom he called a “hardworking people … making great contributions.” Imagine if the governor used an event for Jews to criticize African Americans.
• Inconsistent because the governor was, after all, in Chinatown to attend a celebration of something called the Moon Festival, a fall holiday in Asian culture, and promote a new law to study the effects of relaxing health standards for ethnic foods. And he touts assimilation?
• Imprudent because issues of language and assimilation represent delicate territory where it’s best not to charge in without reflection and restraint. Schwarzenegger’s comments showed little of neither.
• Insincere because Mr. Assimilation’s own campaign Web site, www.joinarnold.com, has a feature where you can hit a button to read the site en español. Que pasa, Arnold? I thought you wanted folks to learn English. Why cater to them in Spanish?
• And incomplete because this line about how Americans will “embrace” Mexicans if they do X, Y and Z only perpetuates the notion that — to the degree that Mexicans aren’t embraced now — it’s their own fault. Never mind racism, discrimination or fear.
Schwarzenegger’s mistake was assuming that this was some revolutionary idea that Mexicans and Mexican Americans need to be sold on. They don’t. They’ve already bought in. And one would like to think the immigrant governor of the most diverse state in the country would know that. (SacBee 10/11/06)
Why this story hasn’t received more traction is really beyond me. This is the Governor of our state telling a very large voting bloc that they don’t speak English well enough. Does anybody understand that? That a sitting governor is completely stereotyping an entire people! That he ignores racial factors and brag that he is better than Mexicans. That he ignores the fact that he was being paid from the moment he landed on American soil that enabled him to succeed. Is anybody doing that with all those “Mexicans” that he is challenging?
Do you think Jay Leno will be asking him about this?
In case you haven’t seen the video, I’ve posted it at Tracking Arnold and the YouTube video is over the flip.