Tag Archives: 2005 Laguna landslides

The OC Register Likes “Property Rights”, But Not Freedom

Remember when I told you about Brea’s plan to set limits on how much development can occur at Carbon Canyon? Well, the Brea City Council now looks to be agreeing upon a compromise measure that will make it more “flexible”. However, The Register’s editorial page is still not happy about it:

The city of Brea continues to set the stage for a massive theft of property, a “taking,” but is trying to craft its action in such a way that the city won’t have to pay for what it takes. The City Council agreed Tuesday to postpone a decision on changing the zoning in a hillside portion of the city, as staff develops more “flexibility” for owners. But a very troubling process is moving forward.

The city attorney, council members and members of a no-growth group closely allied with city officials are all touting their commitment these days to “compromise.” But don’t think that after five years of depriving owners of their lawful right to develop their land that officials have suddenly gained any newfound understanding of the concept of individual freedom.

So does Brea hate “invidual freedom”…
Or are they really respecting freedom? Follow me after the flip for more…

OK, so setting some reasonable standards to prevent tragedies like the Laguna Landslides of 2005 from happening in Brea means that the City of Brea does not understand the “concept of individual freedom”? What, the freedom to put yourselves and your neighbors at risk of losing the entire neighborhood? But wait, it gets better!

We can see it now. Owners would lose their valuable property rights, then be allowed to petition the city for a few additional units. They would have to spend money developing new plans. There would be no guarantees that the flexibility would mean anything more than further delays and runarounds by officials dedicated to stopping growth on privately owned hillsides. This is the opposite of freedom. It would be approval by government whim.

Some supporters of the city have said to us words to this effect: “All property is subject to government regulations and zoning, so why is it any big deal if the city decides to change the zoning on this acreage?”

The price of property is determined by the bundle of rights and entitlements that comes with it.

True. The price of property is determined by such entitlements as being able to build alongside a lovely, bucolic canyon. However, what would happen if that canyon weren’t so lovely and bucolic anymore? And oh yes, what would happen if all those new homes built were to fall in that canyon? Would these developers still be beating their chests about “property rights” when their precious property slides down into ruin?

But I guess that does not matter to The Register’s editorial page, so long as Brea “takes away people’s land” to “create de facto park land”. How dare they!

Other supporters of the city argue that the land is too hilly to build 1,600 units. That might be true, but it should be up to the builder, his engineers and the insurers to determine the right number of units that can be built. It seems clear the city is using the safety issue as an excuse to create de facto park land. […]

Brea officials are acting at the behest of many residents who do not want additional houses near them. But to take away some people’s land to satisfy others is a form of rank majoritarianism. What would you say if a government voted to eliminate your free-speech rights simply because the majority didn’t like what you had to say? It’s a similar concept to what Brea is doing.

Yes, why not just leave it up to the developers? I mean, what motivation do they have besides the very noble urge to “exercise their property rights”? Perhaps, do they also have a motivation to maximize their profits off the land? Now, I’m not saying that all development is evil, or that developers do not have a right to profit off their own land. However, what may be best to maximize the developer’s profit may not be best for the community’s well-being.

This is where government steps in. Local government should be expected to set reasonable standards and limits in order to provide enough of an opportunity for developers to profit off their land, but at a reasonable level that also respects the wishes of the greater community. And oh yes, isn’t government also supposed to respect the will of the people? I mean, isn’t that what representative democracy is all about? The Register might call Brea’s new development standards “rank majoritarianism”, but I’ll call it a reasonable set of standards that tries to respect the right of the developer to develop as well as the community’s right to safe and pleasant surroundings.

Too bad that The Orange County Register’s editorial page’s love for “freedom” does not extend to respecting the wishes of the greater community.

[poll id=”

111

“]

Brea City Council Faces Choice of “Property Rights” or “Protection and Preservation”

Hmmm… I noticed this in today’s OC Register, and it’s making me think:

Landowners in the hills of Brea blasted the idea as too restrictive.

A majority of speakers during Tuesday’s public hearing applauded it as an overdue step toward preservation.

And as of late Tuesday, the City Council had not reached consensus on new zoning laws that would slash the number of homes that could be built in Brea’s Carbon Canyon region – more than 1,100 acres east of the Orange (57) Freeway.

So would Brea be limiting property owners’ rights by limiting the amount of homes that they are allowed to build along the hillsides of Carbon Canyon? Or would Brea simply be taking a common sense step toward preventing a terrible tragedy like the Laguna Landslides of 2005 from happening in their community?

Follow me after the flip for more on this debate over property rights, public safety, and hillside preservation…

So what is this really about? According to our favorite right-wing blogger, Jon Fleischman, this is all about the Brea City Council infringing on people’s property rights. Here’s what he wrote yesterday on OC Blog:

Tonight the members of the City Council in Brea will face a rather straight forward vote on whether they support private property rights, or not. Before them is a proposal that is, in polite terms, a ‘taking’ of the property rights of many property owners in Brea. To be more blunt, there is a zone change coming before these Councilmembers that, if passed, would severely restrict the number of homes that can be built on properties than can currently be built, according to existing standards. In the wave of an arm, or rather the press of a button, these Councilmembers may Lord over these property owners, and literally reduce the value of their land by a huge sum.

Oh, really? So is the city of Brea obligated to respect the “property rights” of a few over the safety and well-being of the larger community? Maybe the city needs some sensible standards in order to prevent Carbon Canyon from becoming the next Bluebird Canyon. From yesterday’s Register:

City leaders say they have no obligation to ensure a landowner can make a profit; their obligation is to safety and public demand for preservation.

“We’re trying to set some realistic, specific standards so they know exactly what they can build,” Councilman John Beauman said. […]

Supporters of the new regulations say it gives teeth to the goals of the city’s 2002 General Plan, which calls for future development in the core of Brea while limiting building in the hillsides.

During 2002 hearings, hundreds of residents spoke out, demanding that the city do all it can to preserve the land that separates Brea from sprawling developments in Los Angeles and San Bernardino counties.

Brea officials said recent landslides in Laguna Beach and Anaheim Hills are examples of what can go wrong when steep slopes are overdeveloped. New regulations would determine the number of homes allowed based on the grade of the slope – the steeper the slope, the fewer the homes.

As we saw in June 2005 in Laguna, a great amount of damage can be done when we humans mess with Mother Nature and overdevelop these steep hillsides. So perhaps, the city of Brea does have an interest here in protecting residents from this type of catastrophe.

And oh yes, what about all the other residents in Brea? What if they’d like to see some of their hills remain hills, and not just become sprawling McMansion tracts like much of the rest of the region? Hmmm… I guess their “rights” aren’t as important as the “property rights” of a few rich developers, at least according to the folks at OC Blog.

[poll id=”

105

“]