Tag Archives: Mark Leno

SD-03: Migden, Leno Trade Barbs in Milk Club Debate

I wrote this for today’s Beyond Chron, San Francisco’s Alternative Online Daily.

It’s often hard to assess which candidate “won” a debate, but a few basic conclusions can be drawn from the November 17th State Senate forum, hosted by the Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club: (1) State Assemblyman Mark Leno and Senator Carole Migden agree on most issues ideologically, (2) the third candidate, Joe Alioto Veronese, is more politically moderate, and (3) there is harsh acrimony between Leno and Migden – which has made the race far more divisive than it needs to be. Progressives have no one to blame but themselves if the race gets so nasty that Leno and Migden kill each other, though it is very unlikely that Veronese would eke out a victory under such circumstances. But Leno and Migden have a distinct difference in style, temperament and priorities – and that is where progressive voters deserve a clear choice in the June primary. As Veronese said at the debate, “we’re all here today because we have a contested race.”

A race between two prominent local gay politicians has already caused tension in the Milk Club.  At the Club’s last general meeting, Carole Migden’s campaign overwhelmed the room with East Bay attorneys, Sacramento staffers and Willie Brown hacks – in an attempt to ram through an early endorsement schedule that rigged the system in her favor.  Club President Brian Basinger alluded to this episode as he welcomed the crowd to the debate, and proudly rattled off the Club’s accomplishments in the past year.  “Even in the middle of controversy,” he said, “work can still get done.”

Moderated by TV news anchor Belva Davis, the State Senate debate revealed an obvious point – there is little ideological difference between Mark Leno and Carole Migden.  Both want to amend “Three Strikes” to avoid locking up non-violent offenders.  Both want single-payer health care, but are pushing for incremental steps this year that could pass politically.  Both want to raise revenue through split-roll property taxes, restoring the upper income tax bracket and allowing cities to reinstate the Vehicle License Fee.  Progressives want to see a clear distinction before making a choice, but it’s just not there.

Migden tried to position herself to Leno’s left by attacking him on several votes.  “I did not vote to expand prison systems like Mr. Leno did,” she said.  “He also wrote a bill about rental cars that the Consumer’s Union is now suing.”  But the prison bill in question (AB 900) was to add more beds and require rehabilitation services in existing facilities – a move Leno says the legislature had to take, or else the federal courts would have mandated building new prisons.  As for the rental car bill (AB 2592), Migden voted for it – and according to Leno, the Consumer’s Union is not suing.

At one point, the two front-runners had a basic disagreement about whether Leno voted to sell EdFund – a corporation owned (but not run) by the state to manage financial aid money for students.  Leno voted for SB 89 while Migden opposed it, but he disputes the notion that it was a vote to “sell” EdFund.  After an audit raised questions about EdFund’s fiscal management, the legislature passed SB 89 to allow the option of finding another contractor.  It certainly wasn’t to privatize education a la Don Fisher – which is what Migden’s accusation implied.

But while Leno and Migden nit-picked over who is more “progressive,” there was no doubt which candidate is the most “moderate” – Joe Alioto Veronese.  The San Francisco Police Commissioner acknowledged his support of Proposition 83, a measure requiring former sex offenders to wear a tracking device that California voters passed last year.  Prop 83 is currently tied up in court, but Veronese said he supports it “in concept.”  Veronese also said he had “problems” with the health care bill being pursued in the legislature (which is already a compromise from single payer), because the Democrats, he said, “need to work” more with the Governor.

In fact, Veronese’s theme throughout the debate was the need to compromise with Schwarzenegger.  “I’m not going to sit here and attack the Governor,” he said, as the other candidates eloquently criticized Arnold’s budget priorities.  Throughout the debate, Veronese stressed the need to work with Republicans and Central Valley Democrats.  Leno finally responded to him with a line that generated applause: “we have worked too much with the Governor.  He needs to work with us.”

Some observers may surmise that with Veronese in the race, Leno and Migden will split the liberal vote – leaving the 3rd District with a State Senator who is far less progressive than his constituents.  In 1998, when the 9th District in the East Bay had a State Senate election, Dion Aroner and Keith Carson split the progressive vote – which allowed moderate Don Perata to eke through.  But Veronese is no Perata, who at the time was a well-known State Assemblyman and former County Supervisor.  As a local Police Commissioner, Veronese will more likely play the “spoiler” role in this race – if even that.

Which brings us back to the two major candidates.  As I explained last April, the real difference between Leno and Migden is how they approach representing a safe Democratic district – which is a distinction in their priorities, style and temperament.  Migden is a hard-nosed pragmatist who spends time in Sacramento cutting deals and building political clout.  Leno is a big-picture idealist who engages the grassroots to pressure the state government.

When asked about passing a gay marriage bill next year that Schwarzenegger twice vetoed, Leno said, “our strategy was based on a false premise: that the Governor is an honorable human being.”  While this gave Leno the biggest applause line of the debate, Migden’s rebuttal showed her difference in tactics.  “I’ve worked with the Governor,” she said, “and he doesn’t like being called names.  I got him to get money for us to help transgenders.  You have to work with people no matter who they are.”

Sparks flew when Leno was asked why he was challenging an incumbent State Senator.  “This is an exercise in democracy,” said Leno, “not an assault on a 30-year career.  Carole says that she should be unopposed, but this Senate seat doesn’t belong to her.  It belongs to the voters.”  Alluding to the fact that Migden has not had a contested race in 17 years, Leno added “Carole’s had the good fortune of having the waters parted for all the seats she’s run for.  There’s never been accountability.”

This provoked a harsh response from Migden.  “I know why [running is] a good idea for him,” she said.  “He’s out of a job.”  Migden reminded the crowd that she got Leno his first job in politics – when her election to the State Assembly allowed him to get appointed to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors.  She said that Leno has a “personal animus” against her, because in 2002 she endorsed his rival, Harry Britt, for the State Assembly.  Leno’s challenge, she implied, is about revenge.

Migden supporters have made this accusation ever since Leno first declared his candidacy – but even assuming that it’s true, will the average voter care?

Migden then brought up a point that, if persuasive, will have far more resonance in determining the outcome of this race: which candidate is a more effective legislator?  “[Leno’s] been a little light on accomplishments,” said Migden.  “Mr. Appropriations Chair has only had 3 bills signed into law this year.”  In contrast, she said, 12 of her bills this year have become law.

Unmentioned was the role that State Senate President Don Perata has played in derailing Leno’s legislation.  As Randy Shaw reported in September, six Leno bills that passed the Assembly in this session were stalled in the Senate – even if they enjoyed wide support.  It’s a deeply cynical move by Perata (and presumably Migden) to deprive Leno of any accomplishments that he can tout while campaigning for the Senate seat.

If Leno defeats Migden, all incumbent State Senators could be subject to similar challenges – which explains Perata’s move to undercut Leno’s accomplishments. “In my first four years in the State Assembly,” said Leno, “about 13 out of 15 bills I wrote every year became law.  Then, all of a sudden, my numbers went down.  Guess what?  Politics happens in Sacramento.; Then, all of a sudden, my numbers came down.  Guess what?  Politics happens in Sacramento.”

When it came time to make closing statements, the tension was so palpable that Leno and Migden both wanted to go last.  But the debate moderator made Leno go first, and he made the following veiled statements about Migden: “I will not sing Don Fisher’s praises, I will not hold fundraisers at Clear Channel, and I will not declare marriage equality ‘dead for the year.'”

In a classic game of “tit-for-tat,” Migden then replied by making her own comments about Leno during her closing statement.  “He says he won’t take money from Don Fisher,” she said, “but he’ll take money from strip clubs that exploit women.”  With two top legislators running against each other, expect this race to get far nastier in the next few months.  And with a statewide Proposition to abolish rent control on the same ballot, let’s hope the average voter won’t get so disgusted that they’ll just sit out the election.

Because in the end, a race between two talented elected officials with similar politics should be a good thing – not a bad thing.

EDITOR’S NOTE: As a private citizen, Paul Hogarth is a member of the Harvey Milk Club and has endorsed Mark Leno for the State Senate – but does not play an advisory role in the campaign.  A former Berkeley resident, he actively supported Dion Aroner’s 1998 run for the State Senate against Don Perata.  Send feedback to [email protected]

Real Eminent Domain Reform in 2008

The backers of the California Hidden Agendas Scheme have worked really, really hard to press the idea that they stand for real eminent domain reform. But, oh, by the way, their proposed initiative would also  eliminate rent control and restrict our ability to build water projects and a whole host of other projects.  Nope, the Hidden Agenda is all about tagging along other “reforms” with the eminent domain reform initiative. 

Over the flip you’ll find videos of a number of elected officials and community leaders. So, Flip it!

Asm. Mark Leno:


Sen. Carole Migden:

Rally Against so-called California Property Owners and Farmland Protection Act (CPOFPA)

(A cool event if you can make it to SF’s Civic Center at noon today. – promoted by Brian Leubitz)

Last month, Brian wrote about the return of Proposition 90. This “Son of 90” initiative is once again rearing it’s ugly head in California — today marks the kickoff of the opposition campaign.

At noon, across the street from San Francisco’s City Hall, Assemblyman Mark Leno will rally against this deceptive ballot measure with Susan Leal, General Manager, SF Public Utilities Commission; Ted Gullickson, SF Tenants Union; Barbara Blong, Senior Action Network; John Rizzo, Sierra Club; Tim Paulson, SF Labor Council and the League of California Cities.

The San Francisco Sentinel reports:

Opponents argue the Government Acquisition, Regulation of Private Property measure could displace 180,000 residents living in rent-controlled residences.

“If this measure were to pass, thousands of San Franciscans would be forced out of the city,” said Ted Gullicksen of the San Francisco Tenants Union.

“Seniors especially would be hard hit if they lost their rent control protections.”

Paul Hogarth has a long piece for Beyond Chron:

But you don’t have to be a tenant to be outraged about CPOFPA – you just have to drink water. Other parts of the ballot initiative – which would be enshrined in the state’s Constitution – would prohibit the acquisition of land and water through eminent domain to develop public water projects. The initiative would ban eminent domain for private use, but Section 19(b)(3)(ii) includes such “private use” as the transfer of property rights to a “public agency for the consumption of natural resources.”

What does that mean? Any construction projects to deliver running water would be ruled unconstitutional. San Francisco’s long-term plan to revamp Hetch Hetchy that provides our clean water would be nixed, as well as other efforts to bring public drinking water to California’s growing population. That’s why Susan Leal, who manages our Public Utilities Commission, will be speaking out at today’s rally in opposition.

Anyone who cares about the environment should oppose CPOFPA. The proposition would ban laws or regulations that “transfer an economic benefit to one or more private persons at the expense of the private owner.” Because the courts have ruled that virtually all land-use decisions and environmental laws can transfer an economic benefit from one party to another, these laws could suddenly be out the window. That’s why John Rizzo, who chairs the local Sierra Club, will be speaking out today. Other environmental groups are expected to come out in opposition as well.

Right-wing proponents of CPOFPA are hoping that voters will get confused – and simply support it because it says it will restrict eminent domain. There are legitimate reasons to oppose eminent domain abuse – nobody wants the government to take someone’s property and give it to a private developer like Wal-Mart. The Supreme Court’s 2005 decision allowing a local city to take peoples’ homes for private use was certainly misguided. But the solution is not to ban rent control, repeal environmental laws and make it impossible to provide clean drinking water.

Attend if you can.

(CA 80AD) Greg Pettis Endorsed by State’s Top Financial Leaders

Just received this press release from the Greg Pettis for Assembly campaign.  Pettis is Mayor Pro-Tem of Cathedral City and is running for the CA 80th Assembly District.  He announced endorsements from California’s top elected financial leaders this week, including Former State Controller Steve Westly, State Controller John Chiang, Board of Equalization member Judy Chu, and Chair of the Assembly Appropriations Committee Mark Leno.

Re full disclosure, BlueBeaumontBoyz is a financial supporter to the Greg Pettis for Assembly campaign.

More below the flip…

The text of the press release is as follows:

“Democratic candidate for Assembly Greg Pettis announced the endorsements from California’s top elected financial leaders this week.

“Among Pettis’ newest endorsements include Former State Controller Steve Westly, current State Controller John Chiang, Board of Equalization member, Judy Chu, and Chair of the Assembly Appropriations Committee, Mark Leno. 

“”Greg has a track record of making the tough choices to balance Cathedral City’s budget as well as creating thousands of new jobs to increase city revenues to pay for public services,” said Chiang.

“”With health care looming as such a big issue, Greg’s financial acumen will help our State Assembly put together a common sense plan for all Californians,” said Westly.

“”I am pleased to have this endorsement from theses well known financial leaders,” Pettis said. “They know my qualifications, and know I will hit the ground running in bringing the people of the 80th Assembly District progress on issues like affordable health care, good paying jobs and protecting our environment.”

Pettis has served on the City Council of Cathedral City for the last 13 years. During that time, Pettis has helped change the city into destination where 50,000 people work, shop and live their dreams.

In addition to Pettis’ duties on City Council, he has worked on a wide range of committees designed to improve the lives of Californians.

Pettis has dealt successfully with environmental issues from Salton Sea restoration to serving on the Coachella Valley Mountains Conservancy Board to helping to negotiate the Multi Species Habitat Act which will guide future growth in the Coachella Valley in a more sustainable way.

Pettis has been working on transportation issues through the Riverside County Transportation Commission and the National League of Cities Transportation Policy Committee, working to come up with mass transit solutions that will help combat climate change.

Pettis was the first openly gay elected official in Riverside County, and he has worked to bridge the gap between communities and to provide leadership to other gay candidates who had the desire to serve in public office but needed encouragement and mentorship.

Pettis has a Bachelor’s of Arts degree from Azusa Pacific University and recently completed the Senior Executive Program in State and Municipal Government from the John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard.

Pettis’ goals for a healthy California include:

(1) Creating a truly universal health care system in California that can be the model for the rest of the nation that has been mired in this debate for too long.

(2) Public eduction–For our state to continue to be one of the largest economic engines in the world, we need to educate kids who are ready to compete in the global economy. While California has made great strides in funding public education (mainly by popular ballot measures) we need to eliminate the achievement gap that is plaguing so many communities, especially in my district.

(3) Environmental protection–Simply put, the rest of the nation looks to California for leadership on this issue. I have the background working on land use, building codes and air and water quality issues to make it happen. It is my goal to have California meet the Kyoto standard of reducing carbon emissions to 1990 levels by 2020.”

Pettis sees the primary issues as being universal health care, quality public education across the state, and reducing our carbon footprint.

“I have a long progressive record in office that is also been fiscally responsible,” said Pettis.

SD-3: What the Leno-Migden Race is Really About

Randy Shaw wrote the following article for today’s Beyond Chron.

The absence of a competitive mayor’s race in San Francisco has left some with pent-up energies demanding an outlet. This became clear with the imbroglio at the Milk Club last week, as passions reached a boiling point over a June 2008 State Senate that is actually three elections away. Why such a furor around this race, and what is it really about? Is the race a proxy fight between pro and anti-Newsom camps, a fight for the “soul” of the gay, lesbian and transgender community, and/or a litmus test on the morality/value of challenging incumbent Democrats? Is it a question of which candidate is more aligned with corporate San Francisco, and/or the fabled Brown-Burton political machine? The Leno-Migden struggle has been defined as all of these things, but the contest should really only be about one issue – which candidate will more effectively serve the district.

Last week’s hijinks at the Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club made for great political theater. I don’t think the Club has had such a fight over membership “stacking” since the 1987 Mayor’s race, when Carole Migden and Harry Britt endorsed Mayor Feinstein-backed Jack Molinari -while most progressive gays and lesbians supported Art Agnos.

Those were the days when Club endorsements really meant something. And given the high stakes of the heated battles in 1987, and to a lesser extent in the 1995 Mayor’s race, was not surprising.

But a State Senate race?  I am very involved in state legislation, and would bet that many of those who attended the Milk Club fracas have never been in a State Senator’s or Assemblyperson’s office trying to secure a vote.

With most San Francisco activists paying little attention to Sacramento politics, why the uproar over the Migden-Leno race?  I’ve read many reasons.

Migden vs. Leno=Progressives vs. Newsom:

One is that Migden-Leno gives progressives the opportunity to send a message against Mayor Newsom by defeating his alleged proxy, Mark Leno. This has been the rallying cry of Supervisor Chris Daly, who makes no secret of his strong dislike for San Francisco’s mayor.

Daly’s argument allows activists still smarting over the lack of a serious progressive challenger to Newsom to channel their disappointment into working to defeat Leno. The only problem with this line of reasoning is some stubborn facts.

For example, Newsom has not even endorsed Leno, and has no plans to do so. And Leno has among the most progressive voting records in the entire State Legislature.

Try as he might, Daly cannot turn Mark Leno into Newsom’s hand-picked former District 6 candidate, Rob Black. And there are many people who strongly back both Migden and Newsom.

A Battle for the “Soul” of the Community:

Migden backers emphasize her leadership in the Milk Club during the 1980’s, and imply that she, far more than Mark Leno, represents the activist legacy of the gay and lesbian civil rights movement. And there is no question that Migden has activist roots that Leno does not have, and a powerful grassroots history.

But Mark Leno’s historic State Legislative leadership on marriage equality also connected him to a grassroots base, and he helped mobilize this base. Meanwhile, the Carole Migden of the 1980’s and the Carole Migden of 2007 are quite different in their relationship to the grassroots.

Many have commented how infrequently Migden was seen in the community in recent years until Leno announced his candidacy; now she is everywhere.

Incumbent Democrats Should Not Be Challenged:

Migden backers argue that Leno’s candidacy is destructive because it diverts financial and activist resources away from battling Republicans. In other words, Democrats should not challenge incumbent Democrats, particularly when the incumbent votes progressively on core issues.

What’s interesting about this argument is that it coincides with the longtime defense of the fabled Brown-Burton machine. The machine avoided nasty fights among Democrats by deciding who would run in certain races, and where resources would go in others.

Ironically, one of the biggest beneficiaries of a San Francisco Democratic Party political machine long scorned by the Bay Guardian and other progressives has been Carole Migden. Since leaving the Board of Supervisors in 1996, Migden has won a string of uncontested races for the Assembly, State Board of Equalization, and the State Senate.

Maybe this is a good thing. Money might have gone into progressive causes that would otherwise have been donated to Migden’s contested elections.

But maybe always running unopposed can make one lackadaisical about delivering for one’s constituency. And a political machine that serves as a traffic cop for aspiring candidates can harm the democratic process, creating the impression that political leadership is decided in the backrooms, rather than by the people in an open process.

Since the June 2008 State Senate primary does not coincide with partisan races, the argument that Leno is diverting resources from fighting the real enemy falls flat. And opposition to the biggest threat on that ballot—a statewide initiative to eliminate rent control in California—will be helped in San Francisco by the large turnout spawned by the Migden-Leno race.

Alignment With Corporate-San Francisco:

Of all of the attempts to frame the Migden-Leno race, the weakest may be the notion that one of the candidates’ is more of a “tool” of downtown interests. Since neither has the personal wealth to self-finance their campaigns, both have had no choice but to turn for support to people and groups that are not progressive.

Supervisor Daly, who appears to have made the Migden campaign a top political priority, has long argued that Leno’s campaign consultants—Barnes, Mosher & Whitehurst—are the same people launching hit-pieces against progressive supervisorial candidates. He is correct.

But what makes this such a fun argument is that many of the most outrageous hit-pieces, such as those targeting Gerardo Sandoval, were funded in part by GAP founder and Republican billionaire, Donald Fisher.  Fisher is a major donor and close ally of Carole Migden.

When one examines Migden’s long and close relationship with Willie Brown, who represented the heart of evil for Daly and others until Gavin Newsom came along, the notion that she is somehow the anti-corporate, anti-downtown, anti-machine candidate is laughable. And Mark Leno also has close ties to forces in constituencies that are often hostile to progressive interests.

That’s why focusing on funders and campaign consultants makes less sense in a race like this one where the candidates have a history of legislative action that can be evaluated.

Who Will Best Serve San Francisco:

For me, this should be the only question. I know that tenants are not the only San Francisco/Marin/Sonoma constituencies that need help from the State Legislature, and the district needs a State Senator who will most effectively represent these interests.

Wouldn’t it be great if the debates at the Milk Club and elsewhere were about the candidates’ effectiveness in Sacramento, rather than the current roster of non-issues?
Bay Area voters routinely complain about the important issues left out of presidential debates, and we have only ourselves to blame if we allow the Migden-Leno race to descend into personal attacks that only demean the candidates and their supporters.

Send feedback to [email protected]

SD-03: Big D Democrats? Check. Little d democracy? Totally absent.

If you've read this blog long, you'll know I support Mark Leno in SD-03.  But you'll also know that I support the concept of primaries in the abstract. Primaries are a part of our system that is integral to a people-powered movement. It puts the voters, not the political machine, in charge of who gets the nomination. While it isn't perfect, it's as Churchill would say, the worst system except for all the others.

And that's why I'm disappointed by what I saw at the Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club in San Francisco last night. Over…

What I saw was truly appalling. I mean besides the stifling heat in the building as the room was packed, both literally and figuratively. Literally, in that there was about 225 people in the auditorium. Figuratively in that many were fairly new members of the Harvey Milk Club, but I'll leave the discussions of the machinations to Paul Hogarth at Beyond Chron. To put it mildly, it was a disaster, from start to finish. Strong-arm tactics abound and the mood was anything but congenial. In the picture you see Sen. Carole Migden moving the affair along.

But what got my goat was a statement that received both cheers and jeers. It came after a discussion back and forth, and went something like this (paraphrased): “This is Mark's fault for challenging Carole. What is the difference on issues between these two? Why is he challenging her?”

But the difference is inherent in the question. It's that little d democracy again. It's the belief in machine politics over people powered politics. Look, Sen Migden became a Senator by general acclimation, same thing with the BOE, and the Assembly. Good for her, I suppose, but bad for little d democracy. Were there better candidates? Who knows? The machine picked her, and you better sit down and shut up. That's not democracy, that's Soviet-style Politburo. 

Of course, there's the sense of entitlement there, that she's earned 8 years by winning her non-competitive election. You know, by angling others away via the backrooms of SF politics. Is this what we want San Francisco politics to be about? Is this the Shining City on the Hill that we want others to emulate? Machine politics without representative democracy?

That's not what I signed up for. 

Governor Vetoes Mark Leno’s Limited Industrial Hemp

Not cool:

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger has vetoed a hemp farming bill for the second time.
The Republican governor announced Thursday that he had turned down a measure by Assemblyman Mark Leno, D-San Francisco, that would have authorized a five-year program under which farmers in four counties-Imperial, Kings, Mendocino and Yolo-could grow hemp in plots of up to five acres.

Hemp is a distant cousin of marijuana but contains only traces of THC, the drug that gives marijuana its intoxicating effect.

It’s legal to grow hemp in more than 30 countries, and the plant can be imported into the United States and used in a wide variety of products, including food and clothing.

Last night, Assemblyman Mark Leno was on Air America to discuss this legislation, check out the audio. Also, video of Leno discussing this important issue after the flip.

No Toxics Day in San Francisco

IMG_2745IMG_2772Or at least it felt that way. For me, anyway. At City Hall, Assemblywoman Fiona Ma busted out the giant not-so-rubber ducky to encourage the governor to sign her bill banning phthalates from use in children’s toys (AB 1108). The chemical can lead to early onset of puberty and hormone imbalance. Peep the relevant Assembly Report over the flip.

In Union Square, Assemblyman Mark Leno joined a protest outside of the Grand Hyatt, where chemical manufacturers were meeting. Perhaps they were scheming for ways to block his bill, AB706, in the Senate again.  Good work chem-folks.  You really pulled one over on the people of California so that you can continue to poison our state!  Yay! By the way, I think Assemblyman Leno is the one in the fireman’s hat behind the sign.

New Problems Emerge With Term Limits Measure

I wrote this for today’s Beyond Chron.

In February, Californians will vote on Proposition 93 – which would modify the term limits law for the state legislature. Supporters claim that it will help legislators serve longer, but reducing the total length of time one can serve in the legislature (from 14 to 12 years) will cut short the career of some officials. In June, Assemblyman Mark Leno will challenge Senator Carole Migden in the 3rd District. If Prop 93 passes in February and Leno prevails in June, he could not run for another Senate term in 2012 – but Migden would be able to if she wins.

While Prop 93 would shorten Leno’s career, the measure’s drafters were eager to create loopholes for other legislators to avoid a similar pitfall. Under an earlier draft of the measure, State Senate President Don Perata would have been ineligible to run for another term; when the drafters of Prop 93 realized this, they promptly fixed the situation. Incumbents like Migden also got an escape clause so they can run again. Prop 93 is not about extending the term of all state legislators -just the ones who are currently in power.

Members of the State Assembly serve two-year terms, and State Senators serve four-year terms. Under current law, on can serve up to three terms in the Assembly (six years), and up to two terms in the Senate (eight years.) In other words, a Sacramento legislator can reasonably expect to serve a total of 14 years. Most State Senators, for example, served in the Assembly before getting termed out.

Assembly Speaker Fabian Nunez and Senate President Don Perata have pushed Prop 93, which would allow a state legislator to serve up to 12 years in either the Assembly or the Senate – but would then be termed out of the Capitol. Right now, legislators do not gain enough experience in either house before having to leave. We have a system that gives lobbyists and staff more power, and puts the legislature at a distinct disadvantage with the Governor.

But the biggest beneficiaries of Prop 93 would be Nunez (who could remain Assembly Speaker for another six years), Perata (who could run for another four-year term), and other current legislators who have clout in their respective chamber but are facing imminent retirement. The short-term effect of Prop 93 is to keep the current legislative leadership in Sacramento – and they clearly had that in mind when pushing for it.

Prop 93’s unknown outcome in February has already put a monkey wrench for the June 2008 calendar – as many legislators prepare contingency plans for a new job. In the East Bay, Loni Hancock – who has served in the Assembly for six years – will run for the State Senate if Prop 93 fails. But if it passes and Don Perata can run again, she will naturally hold onto her seat. This puts people like Berkeley City Councilman Kriss Worthington in limbo, as they wait to see if they can run for an open Assembly seat.

One termed-out legislator who is not waiting on Prop 93’s outcome is San Francisco’s Mark Leno – who has already endorsed a successor (Tom Ammiano) for his Assembly seat. When he announced he would challenge Carole Migden for her Senate seat, Leno made it perfectly clear that he would not change his mind if Prop 93 passed and he could run again for the Assembly. For Leno, it’s the State Senate or nothing.

It’s a decision he could live to regret. If Prop 93 passes, Mark Leno could not serve more than a total of 12 years in the legislature. He’s already been in the Assembly for six years, and Senators get elected to a four-year term. So if he defeats Migden in June and serves a four-year term in the State Senate, he won’t be able to run for re-election.

But if Prop 93 fails in February and Leno prevails in June, the status quo would allow him to run for a second Senate term in 2012. That’s because the current law allows one to serve in the State Senate for up to two terms – or eight years.

While Prop 93’s effect would be to shorten Leno’s tenure in the State Senate, the drafters of Prop 93 made sure that some legislators would not be adversely affected – including, ironically, his opponent: Senator Carole Migden.

If Migden defeats Leno in June and gets to serve a second Senate term, Prop 93’s effect would be to allow her to run for a third term in 2012. That’s because Prop 93 has a clause that reads: “a Member of the Senate or the Assembly who is in office on the effective date of this subdivision may serve 12 years in the house in which he or she is currently serving.”

In other words, Prop 93 allows any legislator as of its passage in February 2008 to serve up to 12 years in their respective chamber – regardless of past service in the other chamber that would normally disqualify them. Although Migden served six years in the Assembly before reaching the Senate, she could still run again because she was a sitting Senator as of February 2008.

But there is no such provision for people who try to switch chambers right after Prop 93 goes into effect. Unlike Migden, the fact that Leno served six years in the Assembly would be counted against him. He would be precluded from running for a second four-year Senate term because that would put him above the 12-year cut-off.

Whether the drafters of Prop 93 anticipated a situation like Mark Leno is unknown – after all, their intent was to let legislators serve longer in Sacramento so they are less beholden to special interest lobbyists, Capitol staff, and can negotiate on a more even footing with Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger. But it’s clear that they never made any plans so that Mark Leno could bring his talents to the State Senate.

But the drafters were eager to create a loophole for Don Perata when it was apparent – in an earlier draft form – that Prop 93 would not allow him to run again. That’s because Perata will have already served 10 years in the Senate by 2008: he won a special election to his Senate seat in 1998, served half a term, and got re-elected in 2000 and 2004. So they tweaked the measure so that Perata’s original half-term “didn’t count” for the purposes of Prop 93.

Everyone agrees that the status quo is a mess, and that term limits reform is needed to help experienced Democrats get things done in Sacramento. But a measure like Prop 93 that rewards party bosses like Don Perata and Fabian Nunez – while handicapping insurgents like Mark Leno who take on an incumbent Senator – is not real “reform.” I will probably be voting “no” in February.

EDITOR’S NOTE: As a private citizen, Paul Hogarth has endorsed Mark Leno for State Senate. He does not play an advisory role in the campaign, and did not communicate with the Leno campaign about this article. He is also a strong supporter of Kriss Worthington’s State Assembly bid in the East Bay. Send feedback to [email protected]

[poll id=”

155

“]