Tag Archives: tax policy

On Paying For Immoral Things, Or, Is Stupak On To Something?

There has been a great wailing and gnashing of teeth over the past day or so as those who follow the healthcare debate react to the Stupak/Some Creepy Republican Guy Amendment.

The Amendment, which is apparently intended to respond to conservative Democrats’ concerns that too many women were voting for the Party in recent elections, was attached to the House’s version of healthcare reform legislation that was voted out of the House this weekend.

The goal is to limit women’s access to reproductive medicine services, particularly abortions; this based on the concept that citizens of good conscience shouldn’t have their tax dollars used to fund activities they find morally repugnant.

At first blush, I was on the mild end of the wailing and gnashing spectrum myself…but having taken a day to mull the thing over, I’m starting to think that maybe we should take a look at the thinking behind this…and I’m also starting to think that, properly applied, Stupak’s logic deserves a more important place in our own vision of how a progressive government might work.

It’s Political Judo Day today, Gentle Reader, and by the time we’re done here it’s entirely possible that you’ll see Stupak’s logic in a whole new light.

So let’s go back a moment and reconsider what Stupak wants: his religious beliefs are offended by the concept of abortion, and he is taking steps to ensure that the government is not using his taxpayer dollars to pay for the procedure.

This precedent is fascinating-and what I’m inviting you to do today is to consider, for a moment, what our government might look like if we take his logic and…extend it a bit.

“…In the game of life, the house edge is called Time. In whatever we do, Nature charges us for doing it in the currency of time…”

–Bob Stupak, “Yes, You Can Win!“

I always try to find common ground with those I oppose, and the most logical place to start would be to consider the fact that Stupak and I are both morally offended by the idea that we use taxpayer dollars to go around killing people.

So where do we differ?

For starters, I find it morally offensive that my taxpayer dollars are used, on a daily basis, to fund the actual killing of actual, living, people by my Government…so, Congressman Stupak, in the name of finding common ground, how about if the same day your Amendment goes into effect we also stop funding any military activities that might reasonably be expected to, as I hear people say, “stop a beating heart”, so as to prevent offending my religious sensibilities?

John Allen Muhammad, the so-called “Washington Sniper”, is scheduled to be executed today. Are you prepared to support legislation, Congressman Stupak, which will prevent his “post-term abortion” and the potential abortions of all those other human lives on Death Rows around this country if those state-sponsored abortions are as much of an affront to my religious beliefs as they should be to yours?

During the more or less four months worth of slow-walking and stalling that we have seen so far in this process 15,000 Americans have died…or, if you prefer, five 9/11s…simply because they have no health insurance-and unless your religion is a lot more bloodthirsty than mine, the abortions of 15,000 people because of the…what’s the word I’m looking for here…let’s see…could it be…sloth…of your colleagues should be an act as reprehensible as the greatest of blasphemies ever recorded in The Bible.

With that in mind, are you prepared to join me in cutting off the use of my taxpayer dollars to fund the salaries, the “public option” health care, and the office operations of those legislators who are behind these killings?

What else do we do that’s aborting lives on a daily basis that I’m sure Congressman Stupak would be glad to allow me, as a result of the offense to my conscience (and, presumably, his), to “negatively fund with extreme prejudice”?

There’s that Drug War, of course, and whatever we’re doing in those secret prisons-and public ones-and subsidies for those who clear mountains and poison lands…not to mention the tax dollars I’ve been providing for a company who did electrical work that’s aborting soldiers.

So whaddaya think, Congressman Stupak?

Since you’re so proud of your pro-life credentials, are you ready to stand up with me and defend the principle that all human lives deserve to be protected, and that we have the right to withhold funding for all those activities that are morally repugnant…or are you just another one of those “enablers” who helped kill 15,000 people this past few months?

Enquiring minds want to know.  

[poll id=”

327

“]

The Sin That Cannot Be Absolved

If you look at the California GOP, especially the grassroots activists, consistent across all of the (oh, so many) demographics, you will see a shared hatred of paying their fare share.  Sure, they’ll take from the government, in tax credits and bailouts, but when it comes to putting money into the kitty, well, that’s just unAmerican. Because government doesn’t really do anything. Or, as Craig T. Nelson says at about the 4:10 mark in this clip, “I’ve been on food stamps and welfare. Anybody help me out? No.”

Yes, it’s that kind of crazy that rules the “Grand Ol’ Party” these days. And so if you’ve ever had the temerity to ever support a tax, ever, in your life, for any reason, no matter how good, prepare to bear the mark for the rest of your life.  Take Steve Poizner for example, Steve Harmon at MediaNews takes a look at how his past, rather lukewarm, support for some taxes makes the right-wingers very suspicious.

“I absolutely do not buy his sudden fiscal conservatism,” conservative blogger Warner Todd Huston said. “His entire history suggests otherwise.”

Poizner’s campaign went so far as to erase a passage earlier this month from his campaign Web site indicating his association with EdVoice, an education advocacy group he cofounded in 2006 that backed a losing ballot initiative, Proposition 88. The measure would have raised parcel taxes by $500 million. Poizner, a Silicon Valley entrepreneur, insists that he had resigned from the EdVoice advisory board over his opposition to the parcel tax, an assertion backed by Netflix CEO Reed Hastings, who cofounded EdVoice.

*** *** ***

“It’s all kind of sketchy,” said Eric Hogue, a conservative radio talk show host who interviewed Poizner on his Sacramento-based show last week. “When did he have his meeting with the board? When did he resign?” (CoCo Times 8/27/09)

Oh noes! He kind of, sort of, maybe supported a parcel tax for education. That would be terrible. Now, the Right and their friends in the media say that the Democratic Party and the Left thinks in a similar way.  

Except that would be categorically false. It doesn’t take long to think of examples, and you don’t really have to go back that far.  Just look back at the budget fights over the past 8 months. In both fights,  Democratic values have been tossed out the window. Core Democratic constituencies, including labor, the poor, and the elderly, have lost. Yet, how many recall attempts have we seen of Democratic legislators who supported the budget package?

None. While on the GOP side, Anthony Adams and a number of other Aye votes for the February package are fighting for their political lives.

The Republicans have gone so far in the quest for one single principle, that they have lost all perspective. They trade in quality schools, they trade in law enforcement, they even trade in prisons. All in the name of taxes.

That’s not a political party.  That’s a fringe interest group.  The thing that I don’t understand is why the Republicans merit so much coverage. Perhaps the media needs to give some attention to the new parties (PDF). I’m thinking a big story on the Anarchy and Poverty Party. Or perhaps that is just a faction of the GOP, being a little more honest about what they plan for California.

Uncle Milton, Prop 13, and the “least bad” taxes

Joe Matthews has an outstanding column up at Fox & Hounds. It seeks to isolate the question of property taxes, and whether Prop 13 is the best resolution. And to address this question, Matthews pulls out the ol’ WWMFD question – What would Milton Friedman Do?

Matthews has an interesting position from which to comment, primarily because he conducted an interview with “Uncle Milton” in 2004, just two years before his death. He has some pretty choice quotes from that interview on the question of Prop 13:

When the subject turned to Prop 13, which he had strongly supported in 1978, Friedman said he thought the measure had proven to be “a mixed bag.” He did not regret his vote for Prop 13 because it had sent a tax-cutting message that was important for that time.

*  *  *

But as a matter of current policy, he said, Prop 13 was problematic. “It’s a bad tax measure because the property tax is the least bad tax there is,” he said. “Think of the original and indestructible properties of the soil. The least dangerous and harmful tax is a tax on something of which there is an inelastic supply.” He argued that protecting Prop 13 was far less important than cutting other taxes, particularly on the income and sales we need more of.

See, the thing with the Republican Party today is not they are principled conservatives ideologically opposed to progressive goals.  That sort of logical consistency would block much good progressive legislation, but it wouldn’t have lead us to the free-fall in which we currently find ourselves. Protecting Prop 13 no longer has anything to do with conservative goals or low-tax policy, but it has everything to do with a mindset.  From Matthews:

Yes, it’s conventional wisdom that raising property taxes is politically impossible in California. But why is that true? It’s true because California’s conservatives and Republicans have become a party of no. If a proposal increases taxes in any way, they’re against it. In doing so, they ignore the teachings of an economist that they claim to revere.

For more than a generation, conservatives have protected the “least bad tax” to the exclusion of all else. So even as income and sales and all kinds of taxes – with their negative effects on the economy – grow (they’re up again this year), the Prop 13 tax limits remain sacred.

Principled conservatism is frustrating, but you can predict principled conservatives. You can work with principled conservatives.  However, you can’t work with a Zombie Death Cult, hell bent only on their own bizarre politics while entirely ignoring good policy