Tag Archives: California Redistricting

California Congressional Districts Analysis

(Great district by district analysis of the Congressional map. – promoted by Brian Leubitz)

by “Alibguy”

Cross posted on my blog http://racesandredistricting.b… which has more election analysis and redistricting maps.

On November 2nd, 2010, California voters passed Proposition 20 allowing a commission composed of 5 Democrats, 5 Republicans and 4 Independents to redraw my state’s congressional districts. Previously, the state legislature drew the maps. In the House of Representatives, the representatives represent voters in districts the legislature draws. In recent years though, states such as Washington and California have chosen commissions to draw districts without political influence. In California, the commission traveled around the state to hear public comments from citizens like me and talk to groups such as MALDEF. On June 10th, 2011, the California Redistricting Commission released their first set of maps for California after hearing public comments from meetings such as this one on May 20th that I attended. The guidelines set for the commission were to draw districts that follow the VRA, stick to county boundaries as much as possible and preserve communities of interest. They approved the final maps in mid August. Also, this is the first election year where all California Congressional elections will have a top two primary where all candidates run in the June primary and the top two vote getters advance to the general election on November 6th.

I posted an earlier analysis of California’s new congressional districts here: http://racesandredistricting.b… but this version is different because it analyzed the 1st draft of California’s redistricting maps. This new version here analyzes California’s Congressional districts after the Commission approved the final maps. Instead of focusing on communities of interest, this analysis will mostly focus on the congressional races themselves and which party is likely to win them. Overall, the Commission’s new Congressional map produces 28 Safe Democratic seats, four Likely Democratic seats, five Lean Democratic seats, two Tossup seats, two Lean Republican seats and 12 Safe Republican seats. This totals to 37 seats expected to vote Democratic with 14 seats expected to vote Republican for Congress, suggesting Democrats could win 3-5 seats under California’s new map.

A few notes: CVAP represents the citizen voting age population.

Here are the maps of the districts drawn in 2002: http://www.govtrack.us/congres…

Here are the maps of the new districts: http://www.mpimaps.com/mapanal…

California’s 1st Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 42%, McCain 53%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 37%, Whitman 53%

Demographics: 12% Hispanic, 79% White

Safe Republican

Rep. Wally Herger (R) recently announced his retirement here. State Senator Doug LaMalfa (R) will probably run here. He should have no trouble winning reelection in this heavily rural and Republican district representing the Sierras and the Central Valley in Northern California.

California’s 2nd Congressional District: Open (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 71%, McCain 25%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 63%, Whitman 30%

Demographics: 17% Hispanic, 73% White

Safe Democratic

This district which represents Marin County and the North Coast is heavily Democratic so it should not elect a Republican. The Democratic Primary though has been extremely competitive. Four Marin County Democrats are running including State Assembly member Jared Huffman (D), Progressive activist Norman Solomon (D), Marin County Supervisor Susan Adams (D), and entrepreneur Stacy Lawson (D). The lone Republican is business owner Dan Roberts (R). Most polls have showed Huffman in the lead with Solomon as the close second. Due to California’s top two primary systems, two Democrats can run against each other in the general election so Solomon is trying to run to the left of Huffman. The strategy seems to be working because most polls show Solomon in 2nd place. Also, Solomon has gained endorsements from progressives such as Raul Griljava (D) from Arizona. The question is how important will these endorsements be in the 2nd district. Huffman has received endorsements from State Attorney General Kamala Harris (D) and three former State Assembly members who represented parts of the 2nd district. As for Adams, her campaign theme of healthy communities and healthy families is appealing but she needs to get more endorsements. Also, for more details on the race for the 2nd district, read my post here: http://racesandredistricting.b…

California’s 3rd Congressional District: John Garamendi (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 55%, McCain 42%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 50%, Whitman 43%

Demographics: 28% Hispanic, 10% Asian, 51% White

Lean Democratic

Garamendi used to represent inland Contra Costa County as well as Fairfield in Solano County but his district is now more Republican with the addition of Sutter, Yuba, Colusa and Glenn Counties. Although Obama and Brown still won the district, the Republican areas in the district’s northern part make the district competitive. The Republican field consists of Sutter County District Attorney Tony Carlos (R) and Colusa County Supervisor Kim Vann (R). Carlos will be a strong candidate in the general election because of his moderate views on immigration in a district where Hispanics are 16% of the CVAP (Citizen Voting Age population.) He can make inroads among the Hispanic voters in Solano County where Garamendi needs to win large margins in order to win. Carlos may be too moderate for voters in the primary because the Republican electorate in the 3rd district is very conservative. As for Vann, most pundits consider her the frontrunner. I see Garamendi winning though because Vann’s primary campaign theme is agricultural issues. Those issues are important to voters in the northern part of the district but if Vann wants to win, she needs to make inroads in Solano County and agriculture is less important there. Also, Obama’s presence on the ticket should increase turnout in Yolo County where Garamendi needs a strong turnout to win.

California’s 4th Congressional District: Tom McClintock (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 43%, McCain 54%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 37%, Whitman 55%

Demographics: 12% Hispanic, 78% White

Safe Republican

McClintock gains new territory in the Central Sierras but the new territory is rural and Republican like the rest of his district. He should have no trouble winning reelection here.

California’s 5th Congressional District: Mike Thompson (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 70%, McCain 26%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 63%, Whitman 31%

Demographics: 26% Hispanic, 11% Asian, 53% White

Safe Democratic

Thompson faces unfamiliar territory by gaining Santa Rosa and the Martinez area. Although Rep. George Miller (D) lives in Martinez, he should run in the nearby district containing Richmond and Concord. Thompson should be safe from a primary challenge though and the 70% Obama number should ensure his reelection against a Republican.

California’s 6th Congressional District: Doris Matsui (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 68%, McCain 29%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 66%, Whitman 28%

Demographics: 13% African American, 27% Hispanic, 15% Asian, 39% White

Safe Democratic

Matsui’s district remains similar to its current form. It is still heavily Democratic and safe for her.

California’s 7th Congressional District: Dan Lungren (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 51%, McCain 46%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 49%, Whitman 44%

Demographics: 8% African American, 14% Asian, 16% Hispanic, 57% White

Lean Democratic

In its 2006 edition, the Almanac of American Politics called Lungren’s district safely Republican but in the last few years, the district’s demographics have changed as the Sacramento suburbs have trended Democratic quickly. The Democrats gained a State Assembly seat in the Sacramento suburbs in 2010 and Democratic candidate Dr. Ami Bera (D) came within seven points of unseating Lungren in 2010, a heavily Republican year. Across the state, Jerry Brown (D) underperformed Obama statewide but in the Sacramento suburbs, he matched Obama’s percentages. Also, Democrats gained a State Assembly seat in the Sacramento suburbs in 2010, further evidence the area is trending Democratic. The commission also decreased McCain’s percentage in Lungren’s district from 49% to 46%. This race should be very competitive because Bera is running again and he is a strong fundraiser (he outraised Lungren in 2010.) Also, 2012 should be more favorable to the Democrats than 2010 was.

California’s 8th Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 42%, McCain 55%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 36%, Whitman 52%

Demographics: 8% African American, 35% Hispanic, 50% White

Safe Republican

The 42% Obama percentage makes this district too Republican to elect a Democrat in the foreseeable future so the Republican primary will be the important contest in this race. Candidates for the 8th district include Victorville city councilwoman Angela Valles (R), Victorville mayor Ryan McEachron (R) and Hesperia city councilman Bill Jensen (R). Jensen plans to run on the tea party platform while Eachron seems to have a more moderate platform. He does not mention the tea party once on his website. Although the 8th district’s Republicans are mostly conservative, the conservative candidates could split the vote, allowing McEachron to consolidate the less conservative Republicans and win the nomination.

California’s 9th Congressional District: Jerry McNerney (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 56%, McCain 41%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 51%, Whitman 42%

Demographics: 9% African American, 14% Asian, 37% Hispanic, 37% White

Hispanic CVAP: 23%

Likely Democratic

McNerney has consistently faced close elections in the current 11th district which voted for Obama by nine points. In the 9th district though, Obama won by 15 points so McNerney will be much safer here. The district becomes more Democratic because it gains heavily Democratic neighborhoods in Stockton and Antioch. 24 year old law student Ricky Gill (R) plans to challenge McNerney and has already raised $800,000. McNerney though has defeated tough candidates before, including former House Resources Chairman Richard Pombo (R) in a less Democratic district. Also, 2012 should not be a Republican year so McNerney should probably win although I expect the DCCC to spend money here.

California’s 10th Congressional District: Jeff Denham (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 50%, McCain 47%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 43%, Whitman 49%

Demographics: 40% Hispanic, 46% White

Hispanic CVAP: 25%

Lean Republican

The 10th district represents southern San Joaquin County which is split between Republican leaning Manteca and Democratic leaning Tracy. The 10th district then represents all of Republican leaning Stanislaus County. Also, Rep. Jeff Denham (R) from the current 19th district which voted 46% for Obama, compared to the 10th district’s 50% Obama, plans to run here. Rep. Dennis Cardoza (D) who represents part of the 10th district then decided to retire. The Democrats recruited a strong candidate though, Astronaut Jose Hernandez (D) who the DCCC is strongly supporting.

California’s 11th Congressional District: George Miller (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 69%, McCain 28%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 61%, Whitman 33%

Demographics: 9% African American, 13% Asian, 26% Hispanic, 52% White

Safe Democratic

George Miller should have no trouble winning this heavily Democratic district representing Richmond and central Contra Costa County.

California’s 12th Congressional District: Nancy Pelosi (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 84%, McCain 13%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 78%, Whitman 16%

Demographics: 6% African American, 31% Asian, 15% Hispanic, 44% White

Safe Democratic

Besides gaining part of the Sunset District, Pelosi’s district does not change. It remains located in heavily Democratic San Francisco.

California’s 13th Congressional District: Barbara Lee (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 87%, McCain 10%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 84%, Whitman 11%

Demographics: 20% African American, 21% Asian, 21% Hispanic, 34% White

Safe Democratic

Lee’s district gains Alameda and San Leandro. Besides these changes, her district remains the same. It is still one of California’s most Democratic districts.

California’s 14th Congressional District: Jackie Speier (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 73%, McCain 24%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 66%, Whitman 28%

Demographics: 31% Asian, 24% Hispanic, 37% White

Safe Democratic

Speier’s district does not undergo major changes. It retains most of San Mateo County and remains heavily Democratic.

California’s 15th Congressional District: Pete Stark (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 67%, McCain 30%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 59%, Whitman 35%

Demographics: 7% African American, 27% Asian, 23% Hispanic, 37% White

Safe Democratic

Stark gains San Ramon and Dublin/Pleasanton/Livermore and these changes make his district a bit more Republican. He may face a primary challenge from Rohit Khanna (D) who is a former Deputy Assistant Secretary in the Commerce Department and raised $1.2 million for a possible race. If he runs for Stark’s seat, he could make the primary very close.

California’s 16th Congressional District: Jim Costa (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 57%, McCain 40%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 49%, Whitman 41%

Demographics: 9% Asian, 58% Hispanic, 25% White

Hispanic CVAP: 41% Hispanic

Likely Democratic

Costa’s district moves north as it retains Democratic parts of Fresno and gains Madera and Merced Counties. Merced County is a swing county but Madera County is Republican but trending Democratic. Although Costa faced a tough reelection in 2010, he should win during more neutral years in this district. In 2010, Costa had a close race due to Republican margins in Kings County but Kings County is no longer in his district so Costa has a stronger chance to win.

California’s 17th Congressional District: Mike Honda (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 69%, McCain 28%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 61%, Whitman 33%

Demographics: 49% Asian, 17% Hispanic, 27% White

Safe Democratic

Honda’s district almost becomes an Asian majority district and if population trends continue, the district should become Asian majority. Honda remains safe from a Republican challenge. Although Honda does not live in this district, I expect him to run here because this district contains most of his current district.

California’s 18th Congressional District: Anna Eshoo (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 70%, McCain 27%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 60%, Whitman 35%

Demographics: 19% Asian, 17% Hispanic, 58% White

Safe Democratic

Eshoo’s district does not change much and remains heavily Democratic.

California’s 19th Congressional District: Zoe Lofgren (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 68%, McCain 29%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 60%, Whitman 33%

Demographics: 26% Asian, 41% Hispanic, 27% White

Hispanic CVAP: 29%

Safe Democratic

Lofgren’s district gains Morgan Hill but besides this change, her district retains most of its current lines and remains Democratic.

California’s 20th Congressional District: Sam Farr (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 71%, McCain 26%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 63%, Whitman 31%

Demographics: 51% Hispanic, 39% White

Hispanic CVAP: 28%

Safe Democratic

Farr’s district does not make major changes. It gains some precincts in Santa Cruz and Santa Clara Counties but remains anchored in Central California and is heavily Democratic.

California’s 21st Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 51%, McCain 46%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 47%, Whitman 44%

Demographics: 71% Hispanic, 19% White

Hispanic CVAP: 49%

Tossup

The 21st district represents heavily Hispanic areas in the southern Central Valley. It contains large portions of Costa’s current district but Costa decided to run in the new 16th district so the 21st district lacks an incumbent. Although the district has a high Hispanic population, the Hispanic turnout is usually low so the district is a swing district. It is trending Democratic though because despite underperforming Obama throughout the state, Brown nearly equaled Obama’s performance in the 21st district. The Republicans have a strong candidate for the 21st district though. State Assembly member David Valadao (R) is running and he easily beat Fran Florez (D) for the State Assembly seat. State Assembly member Michael Rubio (D) originally planned to run but he left the race. Democrats hope Florez’s son, former State Senate Majority Leader Dean Florez (D) decides to run.

California’s 22nd Congressional District: Devin Nunes (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 42%, McCain 55%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 35%, Whitman 59%

Demographics: 7% Asian, 45% Hispanic, 42% White

Hispanic CVAP: 30%

Safe Republican

Nunes’s district becomes smaller but remains heavily Republican and centered around Tulare County and conservative Fresno suburbs.

California’s 23rd Congressional District: Kevin McCarthy (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 36%, McCain 61%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 33%, Whitman 58%

Demographics: 36% Hispanic, 51% White

Hispanic CVAP: 23%

Safe Republican

McCarthy’s district loses all of its San Luis Obispo County territory and becomes more centered around Kern and Tulare Counties. The district remains heavily Republican and is McCain’s best district in California.

California’s 24th Congressional District: Lois Capps (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 56%, McCain 41%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 46%, Whitman 46%

Demographics: 34% Hispanic, 57% White

Lean Democratic

Before 2002, Capps ran in a district with similar lines to the 24th and faced competitive races. In 2002, she received a safer district and won easily in 2002, 2004, 2006, 2008 and 2010. The district’s new lines though remove heavily Democratic Oxnard while adding the conservative interiors of Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo Counties. I lived in Santa Barbara for a few years so I realized how Santa Barbara County seems to be a small version of California. It has beach communities, agricultural based communities, upscale liberals, county club Republicans, college liberals, heavily Hispanic communities, and conservative inland communities. Like California, Santa Barbara County has trended Democratic. Gore won by only a few points but Obama won 60% of the vote there. San Luis Obispo County in the northern part of the district has trended Democratic too. Santa Barbara County swung toward the Republicans though in 2010 because turnout in UCSB was low. If Capps wants to win in 2012, she needs to increase turnout there. Her challenger is former Lieutenant Governor Abel Maldonado (R) who is a moderate. Capps is a strong campaigner and has survived tough challenges in the 90s when the district was less Democratic. Being named the “nicest member of Congress” by the Washingtonian magazine does not hurt her chances either.

California’s 25th Congressional District: Buck McKeon (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 49%, McCain 48%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 39%, Whitman 52%

Demographics: 8% African American, 8% Asian, 35% Hispanic, 46% White

Safe Republican

Although Lancaster and Palmdale are trending Democratic quickly, Simi Valley, Santa Clarita and McKeon’s popularity will keep this district safely in the Republican column.

California’s 26th Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 56%, McCain 41%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 46%, Whitman 47%

Demographics: 6% Asian, 43% Hispanic, 46% White

Hispanic CVAP: 26%

Lean Democratic

Gallegly recently announced his retirement which makes this race easier for Democrats. His district became more Democratic with the addition of Oxnard and his home of Simi Valley was placed in Buck McKeon’s (R) district. There are already five Democrats running though. They include Moorpark City Councilman David Pollock (D), retired longshoreman Zeke Ruelas, Oxnard Harbor District President Jess Herrera (D), Westlake Village Businessman David Cruz (D) and Ventura County Supervisor Steve Bennett (D). Bennett represents Democratic leaning Ventura City as a Supervisor, is popular and well known throughout the district. Cruz and Herrera though are getting support from Hispanic groups and should win support from the district’s large Hispanic population in the primary. Pollock is from Republican leaning Moorpark so if he wins the nomination, he could make inroads there. Most pundits agree though that Bennett is the frontrunner in the primary. On the Republican side, Ventura County Supervisor Linda Parks (R) from Thousand Oaks has announced. Other potential candidates include State Senator Tony Strickland (R), and Moorpark City Councilman Keith Millhouse (R). Parks should do well with moderate Republicans while Strickland appeals to the district’s more conservative voters.

California’s 27th Congressional District: Judy Chu (D) vs. David Dreier (R)?

Presidential Data: Obama 61%, McCain 35%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 55%, Whitman 39%

Demographics: 37% Asian, 27% Hispanic, 29% White

Safe Democratic, Likely Democratic if Dreier runs

The 27th district is a combination of Chu’s and Dreier’s districts while representing foothill communities currently in Dreier’s district and heavily Asian areas such as Monterey Park in Chu’s current district. Although Dreier is moderate and popular, the 61% Obama number should be high enough to protect Chu. Also, she is a very strong campaigner and a popular incumbent.

California’s 28th Congressional District: Adam Schiff (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 70%, McCain 26%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 63%, Whitman 30%

Demographics: 14% Asian, 26% Hispanic, 55% White

Safe Democratic

Schiff’s district loses Pasadena and gains West Hollywood. His district remains heavily Democratic.

California’s 29th Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 74%, McCain 23%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 68%, Whitman 24%

Demographics: 8% Asian, 69% Hispanic, 18% White

Safe Democratic

The commission created this new district as a Hispanic majority district in the San Fernando Valley. Although the district contains territory from both Reps. Howard Berman’s (D) and Brad Sherman’s (D) districts, they both decided not to run here (see California’s 30th Congressional district.) The frontrunner for the 29th district is Los Angeles City Councilman Tony Cardenas (D). He has received support from important political figures such as California’s Assembly Speaker John Perez (D) and Rep. Howard Berman.

California’s 30th Congressional District: Howard Berman (D) vs. Brad Sherman (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 66%, McCain 31%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 57%, Whitman 36%

Demographics: 12% Asian, 27% Hispanic, 53% White

Safe Democratic

The commission combined the homes of Reps. Berman and Sherman so there will be a contentious primary in this district. Some pundits have suggested that Sherman should run in the open 26th district in Ventura County in order to avoid a possible primary loss in the 30th district. Although no polls have been released for the primary, Berman has gained many endorsements, with 23 representatives endorsing him compared to two for Sherman (Reps. Judy Chu (D) and Grace Napolitano (D).) It is unclear how many voters will be swayed by all the endorsements. This does not indicate Sherman will lose though. He received the endorsement of Lt. Governor Gavin Newsom (D), State Controller John Chiang (D) and has raised $3.7 million, more than Berman’s $2.2 million but Berman is raising money quickly. U.S. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid (D) hosted a large fundraiser for Berman recently. This primary will be very close and could attract national attention.

California’s 31st Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 56%, McCain 41%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 49%, Whitman 41%

Demographics: 12% African American, 7% Asian, 49% Hispanic, 30% White

Hispanic CVAP: 35%

Lean Democratic

This district represents Republican leaning Rancho Cucamonga and Democratic leaning San Bernardino and Colton. The district as a whole leans Democratic and is trending Democratic as Hispanics continue to move into the district. Although Lewis lives in the new 31st district, he does not represent much territory in it and he may decide to either retire or run in the more conservative 8th district. Rep. Jerry Lewis (R) lives in this district but recently announced his retirement. Rep. Gary Miller (R) who represented eastern Orange County and Diamond Bar in Los Angeles County plans to run here instead.  Anyway, Rep. Joe Baca (D) lives in this district but decided to run in the more Democratic 35th district so the Democratic field is open here. Two Democratic candidates, Renea Wickman (D) and Russ Warner (D) have announced plans to run. Wickman is a community activist working with youth and ran unsuccessfully in 2010 for the 63rd Assembly district. Warner is a businessman from Rancho Cucamonga who is more moderate than Wickman is, especially on issues such as immigration. This could be difficult for him in this district with a large Hispanic population. The frontrunner though is Redlands Mayor Pete Aguilar (D) who recently announced his candidacy.

California’s 32nd Congressional District: Grace Napolitano (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 62%, McCain 35%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 57%, Whitman 35%

Demographics: 15% Asian, 63% Hispanic, 18% White

Safe Democratic

Napolitano’s district loses her home but I expect her to run here because it contains most of her current district. Dreier’s home is here so he may run here but I doubt he would win in a 62% Obama district.

California’s 33rd Congressional District: Henry Waxman (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 64%, McCain 33%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 55%, Whitman 40%

Demographics: 13% Asian, 11% Hispanic, 69% White

Safe Democratic

Waxman’s district gains large portions of the current 36th district along the coast. It remains heavily Democratic and upscale.

California’s 34th Congressional District: Xavier Beccara (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 77%, McCain 19%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 76%, Whitman 16%

Demographics: 20% Asian, 65% Hispanic, 9% White

Safe Democratic

Beccara’s district does not undergo major changes. It remains heavily Hispanic and Democratic.

California’s 35th Congressional District: Joe Baca (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 64%, McCain 32%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 57%, Whitman 33%

Demographics: 7% African American, 69% Hispanic, 16% White

Hispanic CVAP: 52%

Safe Democratic

This district should be too Democratic to elect a Republican representative but the Democratic primary will be close. Rep. Joe Baca (D) who represented parts of the district plans to run here and so does State Sen. Gloria Negrete McLeod (D). Both representatives are popular and McLeod defeated Baca’s son in her 2006 State Senate primary.

California’s 36th Congressional District: Mary Bono Mack (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 50%, McCain 47%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 43%, Whitman 49%

Demographics: 47% Hispanic, 44% White

Hispanic CVAP: 27%

Lean Republican

The district voted for Obama and is trending Democratic but Bono Mack is a very popular representative and is moderate. Also, openly gay Palm Springs mayor Steve Pougent (D) has not made plans to run for the seat although he would be a strong candidate. He ran in 2010 and performed well against Bono Mack. The Democrats found a candidate to challenge Bono Mack though. Dr. Raul Ruiz (D), a physician has announced his candidacy and he is the first Hispanic candidate to challenge Bono Mack for her seat in a district with a large and fast growing Hispanic population. Bono Mack’s moderate positions and popularity make her formidable though.

California’s 37th Congressional District: Karen Bass (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 84%, McCain 13%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 79%, McCain 15%

Demographics: 25% African American, 9% Asian, 39% Hispanic, 24% White

African American CVAP: 34%, Hispanic CVAP, 21%

Safe Democratic

Bass retains most of her current territory and represents heavily Democratic areas with a large African American CVAP. She should be safe here.

California’s 38th Congressional District: Linda Sanchez (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 61%, McCain 35%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 57%, Whitman 35%

Demographics: 14% Asian, 61% Hispanic, 19% White

Hispanic CVAP: 51%

Safe Democratic

Although this district is too Democratic to elect a Republican representative, there will be a competitive primary here. State Senator Ron Calderon (D) is challenging Sanchez here. Although Sanchez is a popular representative, she has represented only a small part of the district while she is unfamiliar with the voters in the Montebello area where Calderon lives. She needs to introduce herself to voters in that area. I expect she will receive support from other congressional representatives though so she may win.

California’s 39th Congressional District: Ed Royce (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 47%, McCain 49%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 38%, Whitman 54%

Demographics: 29% Asian, 33% Hispanic, 34% White

Safe Republican

Although this district may be trending Democratic because Democratic voters are moving into it, this district remains Republican at a local level. Reps. Miller and Royce were both drawn into the district but Miller decided to run in CA-31 instead so Royce has the field to himself.

California’s 40th Congressional District: Lucille Roybal Allard (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 77%, McCain 19%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 73%, Whitman 19%

Demographics: 6% African American, 86% Hispanic, 5% White

Hispanic CVAP: 73%

Safe Democratic

Allard’s district becomes the most heavily Hispanic district in the country with an 86% Hispanic population. It also remains heavily Democratic.

California’s 41st Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 59%, McCain 38%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 52%, Whitman 40%

Demographics: 10% African American, 6% Asian, 56% Hispanic, 26% White

Hispanic CVAP: 37%

Likely Democratic

The commission created this new Hispanic majority district combining communities of interest in northern Riverside County. The district also voted for Obama and Brown by double digit margins so Democrats have an advantage here. The Democrat running is openly gay Riverside Community College School Board Member Mark Takano (D). Takano ran for this seat under similar lines in 1992 and lost by 550 votes when the area was less Democratic. Riverside County Supervisor John Taviglione (R) who represents most of the district is challenging Takano. Although Taviglione is popular and well known, the 59% Obama number in this Democratic trending district and Takano’s campaign skills may be too high for him to overcome.

California’s 42nd Congressional District: Ken Calvert (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 43%, McCain 54%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 35%, Whitman 56%

Demographics: 9% Asian, 36% Hispanic, 47% White

Safe Republican

In 2008, Calvert faced a tough race not only because of his ethics problems but also because the district was trending Democratic quickly and voted for Obama. In this new map though, Calvert is much safer by losing Democratic Riverside and gaining more Republican parts of Riverside County.

California’s 43rd Congressional District: Maxine Waters (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 75%, McCain 22%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 69%, Whitman 24%

Demographics: 24% African American, 12% Asian, 46% Hispanic, 15% White

African American CVAP 33%, Hispanic CVAP 29%

Safe Democratic

Waters’s district remains heavily Democratic but the Hispanic CVAP is increasing and is almost as high as the African American CVAP. This creates the possibility of a Hispanic candidate challenging Waters in the primary and winning due to support from Hispanics. Waters’s ethics problems though create an even larger opening for a primary challenger too.

California’s 44th Congressional District: Laura Richardson (D) vs. Janice Hahn (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 81%, McCain 15%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 77%, Whitman 15%

Demographics: 17% African American, 68% Hispanic, 7% White

African American CVAP 28%, Hispanic CVAP 49%

Safe Democratic

This district will see a tight primary race for the Democrats. Only a small portion of Hahn’s district is in the new 44th but Hahn has a strong shot at winning not only because she is popular with the district’s many working class voters but also because Richardson has ethics problems. Hahn is a former city councilmember from Los Angeles and represented large portions of the district in the city council. A poll showed her leading Richardson 47-26 but the poll was conducted in August so it may be outdated.

California’s 45th Congressional District: John Campbell (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 46%, McCain 51%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 34%, Whitman 59%

Demographics: 21% Asian, 18% Hispanic, 56% White

Safe Republican

Campbell’s district loses territory on the Orange County coast and gains more conservative towns inland such as Lake Forest. Although Irvine is Democratic leaning, the rest of the district leans Republican and should keep this district strongly in the Republican column.

California’s 46th Congressional District: Loretta Sanchez (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 58%, McCain 39%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 50%, Whitman 40%

Demographics: 12% Asian, 67% Hispanic, 18% White

Safe Democratic

Sanchez’s district remains similar to its current form; heavily Hispanic and Democratic.

California’s 47th Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 58%, McCain 39%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 50%, Whitman 42%

Demographics: 8% African American, 21% Asian, 34% Hispanic, 34% White

Likely Democratic

State Senator Alan Lowenthal (D) is facing Long Beach City Councilmember Gary DeLong (R) in this district combining the city of Long Beach with some Orange County communities such as Garden Grove. As of last October though, DeLong had outraised Lowenthal but the district has a large Democratic base and if Obama motivates the Democratic base, Lowenthal should receive a large boost and be able to win.

California’s 48th Congressional District: Dana Rohrabacher (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 46%, McCain 51%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 35%, Whitman 58%

Demographics: 17% Asian, 20% Hispanic, 59% White

Safe Republican

Rohrabacher’s district loses the entire Los Angeles County portion and gains more of the Orange County coast. It remains Republican and safe for him.

California’s 49th Congressional District: Darrell Issa (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 49%, McCain 47%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 37%, Whitman 55%

Demographics: 7% Asian, 26% Hispanic, 62% White

Safe Republican

Issa’s district becomes more Democratic by gaining Carlsbad and Del Mar which were formerly in Bilbray’s district. Issa’s district still remains safe for him but if Democratic trends continue and Issa retires, this district could become competitive. Bilbray faced competitive races in 2006 and 2008 in a district with similar territory.

California’s 50th Congressional District: Duncan Hunter (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 39%, McCain 58%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 30%, Whitman 66%

Demographics: 30% Hispanic, 59% White

Safe Republican

Hunter should be safe in this district representing inland San Diego County. It was Whitman’s best district in California and McCain’s best district south of Bakersfield.

California’s 51st Congressional District: Open

Presidential Data: Obama 65%, McCain 32%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 58%, Whitman 31%

Demographics: 7% African American, 8% Asian, 68% Hispanic, 14% White

Safe Democratic

Rep. Bob Filner (D) represented most of this district in Congress but the seat is open because he plans to run for mayor. State Sen. Juan Vargas (D) is running to replace him. Vargas has an advantage because he is well known in the San Diego portion of the district and his State Senate district covers almost the entire new 51st district. Denise Duchney (D), a former State Senator from Vargas’s district is running too so there will be a competitive primary for this seat that should vote Democratic in the general election.

California’s 52nd Congressional District: Brian Bilbray (R)

Presidential Data: Obama 55%, McCain 43%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 43%, Whitman 50%

Demographics: 18% Asian, 13% Hispanic, 62% White

Tossup

Bilbray’s district still represents northern San Diego City but the district suddenly jumps from 50% Obama to 55% Obama. He now faces three strong Democratic challengers: Assemblywoman Lori Saldana (D), businessman Bob Nascenzi (D) and Port of San Diego Commission Chairman Scott Peters (D). Most pundits believe that Saldana and Peters will be the Democratic frontrunners for the seat. Bilbray though has fended off difficult challenges for the seat in 2006 and 2008 but the new district is more Democratic so he should worry.

California’s 53rd Congressional District: Susan Davis (D)

Presidential Data: Obama 61%, McCain 36%

Gubernatorial Data: Brown 52%, Whitman 40%

Demographics: 8% African American, 13% Asian, 32% Hispanic, 43% White

Safe Democratic

Davis’s district becomes less Democratic as it gains some San Diego suburbs. The 61% Obama number though should keep her safe.

[poll id=”

482

“]

Analysis of California’s Proposed Congressional Districts Part II

Cross posted on http://racesandredistricting.b… which you should check out for more election analysis and redistricting maps.

This is the 2nd post out of three posts analyzing California’s new congressional redistricting maps.This post covers districts 18-35. The 1st post is here

Update: I saw that the 1st post could not be accessed. The problem has been fixed and here is the post! http://racesandredistricting.b…

For district maps, click here: http://www.latimes.com/news/lo…

For demographics and partisan data, click here: http://redistrictingpartners.c…

Edit by Brian: See the extended entry for the full details of this rather detailed and fact-rich post.

California’s 18th District Vacant (Dennis Cardoza (D) ? vs. Jeff Denham (R)?) Tracy/Manteca/Stanislaus County

Brown 44%, Whitman 49%

Obama 50%, McCain 47%

Demographics 4% African American, 6% Asian, 40% Hispanic

Status: Toss Up/Tilt Republican

The 18th district used to contain Democratic neighborhoods in Stanislaus County but gains all of Stanislaus County now, including the Republican towns of Oakdale. The 18th district also loses Stockton and all territory south of Stanislaus County. In San Joaquin County, the 18th district represents Democratic leaning Tracy and marginal Manteca. Despite Obama’s win, Stanislaus County leans Republican but is trending Democratic due to its growing Hispanic population. The combination of these areas creates a slightly Republican leaning district but Cardoza has a strong shot here because he is a strong incumbent and the district is trending Democratic. If a strong Republican candidate such as Denham runs here though, Cardoza will have a very difficult race. Denham is a very strong candidate who formerly held a State Senate district that voted 59% for Obama before becoming the 19th district’s representative.

California’s 19th District Dennis Cardoza (D) vs. Jeff Denham (R)? vs. Jim Costa (D)? Merced/Madera/Fresno

Brown 50%, Whitman 42%

Obama 58%, McCain 39%

Demographics: 6% African American, 9% Asian, 58% Hispanic

Status: Likely Democratic

This district does not share much territory with the current 19th district which the commission divided between the new 18th, 21st and 4th districts. Although Denham represented the old 19th district, he lived in Atwater which the old 18th district represented. Due to the 58% Obama number in this district, Denham will probably not run here and run in the 18th instead. Cardoza may run here if Denham runs in the 18th so Cardoza does not face an uphill battle. Cardoza’s current district and this one share Merced and Madera Counties. Cardoza may face a primary challenge from Rep. Jim Costa (D) who lives in Fresno and lives in the new 19th district. In 2010, Costa barely won reelection in the 20th district which contained Republican areas such as Kings County. He may want a safer district that does not contain Kings County. To avoid a primary challenge from Cardoza though, Costa may run in the 71% Hispanic 20th district. Although the district represents Hispanic areas, splitting Fresno may not be the best idea for communities of interest. Still, respecting the Voting Rights Act which mandates that districts designed to elect minority candidates should be drawn is more important than respecting communities of interest. Drawing a district containing all of Fresno and its suburbs would most likely not have enough Hispanics to elect a Hispanic candidate but this district that contains Merced County and Hispanic parts of Fresno does.

California’s 20th District Vacant (Jim Costa (D)?) western Fresno County/Kings County/Bakersfield

Brown 48%, Whitman 44%

Obama 51%, McCain 46%

Demographics: 5% African American, 4% Asian, 71% Hispanic

Status: Lean Democratic

The new 20th district loses its population base in Fresno and gains some Hispanic parts of Tulare County as well as more territory in Kern County. Although the district’s population is 71% Hispanic, Jerry Brown only won the district by four points. The reason is that the Hispanics in this district tend to have lower turnout rates and vote less Democratic than Hispanics in nearby districts such as the new 19th. As for the 20th district’s representative, Costa may run here if he wants to avoid a primary challenge from Cardoza but Costa’s close win in 2010 may deter him from running in a district that contains heavily Republican Kings County. If Costa chooses to run in the 19th, possible candidates include former State Senator Dean Florez (D) and State Senator Michael Rubio (D) from Bakersfield. On the Republican side, State Assembly member David Valadao (R) may consider running. He is a strong candidate because he is Hispanic in this heavily Hispanic district and currently represents a heavily Hispanic assembly district.

California’s 21st District Devin Nunes (R) Clovis/Visalia

Brown 35%, Whitman 59%

Obama 42%, McCain 55%

Demographics: 7% Asian, 45% Hispanic

Status: Safe Republican

The 21st district loses Porterville and its territory in the Sierras but besides these changes, the lines remain similar. Nunes still represents a strongly Republican district combining Republican parts of Fresno and Tulare Counties. This district also represents communities of interest by combining small cities and suburbs such as Clovis that have a mix of Hispanics and conservative white voters.

California’s 22nd District Kevin McCarthy (R) Bakersfield/Porterville/Lancaster

Brown 33%, Whitman 58%

Obama 35%, McCain 62%

Demographics: 6% African American, 5% Asian, 35% Hispanic

Status: Safe Republican

The 22nd district undergoes a few changes. It loses all of heavily Republican inland San Luis Obispo County and gains parts of Tulare County such as the Sierras and Porterville. Besides these changes, the 22nd district remains safe for McCarthy and heavily Republican.

California’s 23rd District Lois Capps (D) San Luis Obispo County/Santa Barbara County

Brown 47%, Whitman 46%

Obama 57%, McCain 42%

Demographics: 4% Asian, 35% Hispanic

Status: Lean Democratic

The 23rd district undergoes some major changes as its lines become similar to its lines during the 1990s. The 23rd district loses all of heavily Democratic Oxnard and gains inland San Luis Obispo and Santa Barbara Counties, both strongly Republican areas. Before the commission changed the lines, the 23rd district protected Capps from Republican challenges by representing a thin line along the coast that contained Democratic areas such as UCSB, CAL Poly and Oxnard. A 10 mile wide strip along the coast was not compact so the new 23rd district combines communities of interest. As for Capps, her district was extremely competitive during the 1990s but the 23rd district is trending Democratic with its universities and growing Hispanic populations. Also, she is more entrenched now but she may face a challenge from former Lieutenant Governor and State Senator from San Luis Obispo County Abel Maldonado (R). Although Obama won solidly here, Brown barely won because the university areas had much lower turnout than they did in 2008. As long as Capps can keep the turnout in the universities high, she should win but if it is low and Maldonado wins big in San Luis Obispo County, Capps will be in trouble.

California’s 24th District Vacant (Elton Gallegly (R)?) Oxnard/Thousand Oaks/Malibu

Brown 47%, Whitman 47%

Obama 57%, McCain 40%

Demographics: 6% Asian, 42% Hispanic

Status: Lean Democratic if Gallegly does not run, Lean Republican if he does

The 24th district undergoes major changes as it loses all of Inland Santa Barbara County and Simi Valley and gains the Democratic areas of Oxnard and Malibu. The old 24th district voted for Obama by a small margin but Gallegly always performed strongly there. His home Simi Valley is now in the 25th district but Gallegly will probably not run there because voters in the other parts of the new 25th district such as Palmdale are unfamiliar to him. In the last few election cycles though, Gallegly hinted he wants to retire. He has not run a tough race in many years and a 57% Obama district will definitely interest a strong Democratic candidate. That percentage may convince him to retire, paving the way for a strong candidate such as State Senator Fran Pavley (D) from Oxnard. If State Senator Tony Strickland (R) who represents Santa Barbara and the more conservative parts of Ventura County runs, this race will be tough. Still, the Obama turnout in 2012 should help Pavley.

California’s 25th District Buck McKeon (R) vs. Elton Gallegly (R) Simi Valley/Santa Clarita/Palmdale

Brown 39%, Whitman 53%

Obama 45%, McCain 51%

Demographics: 8% African American, 7% Asian, 35% Hispanic

Status: Safe Republican

The 25th district changes as it loses Mono and Inyo Counties while gaining conservative Simi Valley. The 25th retains conservative Santa Clarita and Democratic trending Palmdale. Although parts of the district are trending Democratic, McKeon is an entrenched incumbent and McCain still won here by 6. McKeon should have no problems against Democrats here and should beat Gallegly in a primary.

California’s 26th District David Dreier (R) Covina/San Dimas/Baldwin Park

Brown 57%, Whitman 35%

Obama 61%, McCain 33%

Demographics: 15% Asian, 63% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

Dreier’s home of San Dimas is in the district but due to Obama’s 61% performance here and the 63% Hispanic population, Dreier will probably not run in this district. This district is extremely different from Dreier’s current district because this district contains the Hispanic areas of El Monte and Covina although retaining the Republican leaning San Dimas and Glendora areas. As for possible candidates for this district, State Senator Ed Hernandez (D) and the State Assembly’s Assistant Majority Whip, Roger Hernandez (D) may consider running here.

California’s 27th District Brad Sherman (D) vs. Howard Berman (D) Calabasas/West San Fernando Valley/

Brown 57%, Whitman 38%

Obama 65%, McCain 33%

Demographics: 4% African American, 12% Asian, 27% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 35% for McCain is too low to let a Republican win in the new 27th district so the real contest should be the primary. In 2002, the San Fernando Valley had a large Hispanic population but it was divided between Sherman’s and Berman’s districts so Sherman and Berman could be reelected. The commission though decided that the San Fernando Valley needed a Hispanic majority district so they placed the whiter parts of the San Fernando Valley into this district. Although the new 27th district contains more of Sherman’s district, Berman has more seniority. Berman has said although the lines are not final, he expects to run in the district he lives in and he lives in this district. If Sherman does not want to face a primary challenge from Berman, it is possible Sherman will run in the nearby Ventura County district containing Oxnard. As for communities of interest, this district follows that criterion by combining mostly upscale parts of the San Fernando Valley area.

California’s 28th District Vacant San Fernando/East San Fernando Valley

Brown 67%, Whitman 28%

Obama 71%, McCain 27%

Demographics: 4% African American, 8% Asian, 68% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

In 2002, many Hispanic groups were unhappy that the San Fernando Valley did not receive a Hispanic majority, despite the area’s large Hispanic population. The commission created this Hispanic majority district though by combining areas near I-5 and I-210. Although this district contains most of Berman’s current district, he may not run here due to the district’s high Hispanic population. A possible candidate includes rising star in the State Senate Alex Padilla (D).

California’s 29th District Adam Schiff (D) Burbank/Pasadena/Upland

Brown 55%, Whitman 40%

Obama 62%, McCain 36%

Demographics: 6% African American, 12% Asian, 27% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic, Likely Democratic if Dreier runs

The 29th district mostly represents communities of interest by combining the similar areas of Burbank, Glendale and Pasadena. It also represents Upland in San Bernardino County which is far from BGP but is a community of interest as an upscale foothill community. Dreier may run here because this district and his current district share many of the foothill towns such as Upland and Claremont. Schiff should win though due to his base in the Democratic Pasadena area.

California’s 30th District Henry Waxman (D)

Brown 69%, Whitman 25%

Obama 71%, McCain 28%

Demographics: 4% African American, 18% Asian, 37% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The current 30th represents communities of interest by combining upscale communities in the Westside including Malibu, Santa Monica and Beverly Hills. This district though does not completely combine communities of interest. Although it combines some upscale communities such as Pacific Palisades and Beverly Hills, it combines these areas with more working class neighborhoods near Downtown Los Angeles. The 30th district should represent either upscale areas in West LA or working class neighborhoods near Downtown Los Angeles, not both. The two areas have different concerns, one having a large film industry presence while the other is focused more around labor. As for Waxman, he should no problem winning in this heavily Democratic district and the 37% Hispanic is not high enough for a Hispanic primary challenger.

California’s 31st District Xavier Beccara (D) vs. Lucille Roybal Allard (D) Eagle Rock/East Los Angeles/Huntington Park

Brown 76%, Whitman 17%

Obama 78%, McCain 16%

Demographics: 10% Asian, 71% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

This district combines two VRA Hispanic majority districts so if this map passes, it is likely to receive a lawsuit. The Hispanic population in the Los Angeles area is growing and can definitely support Beccara and Allard’s districts. The district does combine communities of interest though by representing the heavily Hispanic areas of Huntington Park, East Los Angeles and Commerce.

California’s 32nd district Judy Chu (D) Arcadia/Pasadena/Diamond Bar

Brown 54%, Whitman 41%

Obama 61%, McCain 38%

Demographics: 49% Asian, 29% Hispanic

Status: Likely Democratic

The 32nd district becomes less Hispanic by losing all of East Los Angeles, El Monte and West Covina. The district becomes more Asian by gaining Arcadia, Temple City and San Marino. The district then goes toward the San Bernardino County border to gain heavily Asian cities there including Walnut and Diamond Bar. This district suits its representative, Judy Chu because her current district is heavily Hispanic and a Hispanic candidate could unseat her in the primary. The Hispanic population in this district is 29% though so Chu should have no problems winning the Democratic primary. Asians do not consider themselves one ethnic group but they will probably support another Asian candidate over a Hispanic candidate. Although Chu is safe from a primary challenge, Rep. Gary Miller’s (R) home of Diamond Bar was drawn into this district. He will probably not run here because not only does this district lean Democratic; he is unfamiliar to the voters in the western half of the district. As for communities of interest, the district combines heavily Asian suburban areas but the western part is in the San Gabriel Foothills while the eastern part is closer to San Bernardino County.

California’s 33rd District Karen Bass (D) Culver City/Ladera Heights

Brown 77%, Whitman 17%

Obama 81%, McCain 18%

Demographics: 22% African American, 11% Asian, 37% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 33rd district becomes less African American as it gains neighborhoods between Sunset Blvd., Santa Monica and Beverly Hills and loses some neighborhoods just to Beverly Hills’s south. These changes reduce the African American population to 22% and increase the Hispanic population to 37%. Hispanic turnout rates are usually low so there should be higher African American turnout in the Democratic primary than Hispanic turnout. Also, Bass is popular with white liberals so she should perform well with white voters in the primary too. As for communities of interest, this district splits the white population in the Westside that should be represented in one district. The 33rd district’s new lines should be similar to its current ones instead.

California’s 34th District Vacant Pomona/Ontario

Brown 49%, Whitman 41%

Obama 55%, McCain 44%

Demographics: 7% African American, 9% Asian, 57% Hispanic

Status: Lean Democratic

This new district contains mostly Hispanic areas by combining Pomona and Ontario. The district also contains Rancho Cucamonga which has a smaller Hispanic population but is close to Pomona and Ontario so it can be considered a community of interest. As for the district’s next representative, Gloria Negrete McLeod (D) said, “I’m in.” She is a Hispanic State Senator representing Pomona and Ontario. Possible Republicans include David Dreier (R) because he formerly represented Rancho Cucamonga. For Dreier to win though, he will have to perform well with Hispanic voters in Pomona and Ontario. This will be difficult though because McLeod should perform well with Hispanic voters and win in Pomona and Ontario because the voters there are familiar with her. Also, this district is trending Democratic as more Hispanics move here so if a Democrat does not win in 2012, a Democrat should win in ’14.

California’s 35th District Maxine Waters (D) Inglewood/Westmont/Bell Gardens

Brown 84%, Whitman 9%

Obama 88%, McCain 11%

Demographics: 21% African American, 75% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

This district is too Democratic to elect a Republican but the primaries will be interesting. The 35th district is now 75% Hispanic and the 21% African American population is probably not enough for Waters to win the primary. Rep. Linda Sanchez (D) may run here because her current district becomes less Hispanic and the new 35th district gains some of her current territory by gaining South Gate. The district’s large Hispanic population plus a strong challenge from Sanchez should unseat Waters. The 35th combines communities of interest by representing working class areas in and around South Central Los Angeles.

.

[poll id=”

462

“]

California Redistricting Commission Meeting June 27th: Thoughts and Analysis

Cross posted on my blog http://racesandredistricting.b… which you should check out for more redistricting analysis and maps.

I attended the May 20th commission meeting in Santa Rosa, Ca. My analysis of that meeting is here: http://racesandredistricting.b…

In that meeting, most of the attendees were residents from the North Coast, Sonoma County and Marin County. Only one San Francisco resident attended. Most of the commenter’s advocated for not placing Marin in the same district with San Francisco. The commission listened to the commentors by not placing San Francisco and Marin in the same district. Instead, the commisssion’s initial plan placed Marin and Del Norte Counties in the same district instead. I also attended a rally on June 18th in San Rafael, Ca and Rep. Lynn Woolsey (D) said we should write to the commission to declare our opposition to the new lines connecting Del Norte and Marin Counties. I believed that because of the subject’s local attention, many people would attend the June 27th meeting to oppose the new lines the commission drew for the congressional district. I arrived early to get a good spot on line. I was speaker #16.

.

While waiting, I talked to a few people in the lobby. I talked to a couple from Mendocino County who disliked the lines connecting Marin County to their district. Also, I talked with a group that wanted fair representation for Asians under the new lines. They disliked the State Senate lines that combined Daly City and San Francisco because they believed that Daly City would be underrepresented in the new district. I also talked to a member of the American Cancer Society. She was a resident from American Canyon and later, I would learn that she was not the only one.

The first speakers spoke about redistricting in the South Bay. “Put East Palo Alto in the 12th district,” one of them said. Another wanted the tri cities of Menlo Park, Palo Alto and East Palo Alto to be in the same district. A few people advocated for uniting Fremont in one congressional district instead of splitting it between two districts. I believe that Fremont should be split the way it is because I want to increase the Asian percentage in the Milpitas area district to increase the likelihood that this district elects an Asian representative once Mike Honda (D) retires. A group who worked with Napa Valley Winegrowers argued that Sonoma, Lake and Napa Counties belonged in the same congressional district. They did not want Marin with Sonoma but as the speakers in the May 19th meeting indicated, Marin residents did not want to be in the same congressional district with San Francisco.

Finally, the commission called #16 so I went to the podium to speak. I advocated for keeping Marin and Sonoma Counties in the same congressional district because we are connected by the SMART train, dairy farms and Route 101. We also are filled with transplants from San Francisco. I explained how Mendocino County was mostly rural with an economy based on wineries and tourism and Humboldt County also had a tourism based economy. Other facts I highlighted include that Del Norte County is a six hour drive from Marin and that Santa Rosa had around 160,000 people so it belonged in a district with a more urban environment. Marin and Sonoma combined would create a more urban/suburban environment that would be a community of interest with Santa Rosa. I highlighted how the commission’s initial plan placed Santa Rosa is in the same congressional district as Yuba City and some Sierra Foothills and I asked the commission what Santa Rosa had in common with those areas. The only road connecting the Sonoma/Napa area to Yuba City is a curvy road through the mountains. If people want to go to Yuba City from Napa, they would drive on Route 80 to Route 5 and this drive passes through four other congressional districts. I also mentioned that Yuba City has a larger agricultural economy while Santa Rosa has less agriculture.

After I spoke, I heard speakers express concern for creating that congressional district that extends from Sausalito to Crescent City. Residents in Crescent City probably disliked the new lines but would not drive six hours to San Francisco to testify. Scott Weiner, the representative of District 8 in San Francisco, argued that San Francisco should be in an odd State Senate district. If San Francisco is in an even one, San Francisco will have no State Senate representative until 2014. He wanted Diamond Heights and Castro to be in the same district. After Weiner spoke, a man wearing a “Don’t Tread on me” jacket came and suggested that the districts should be divided by zip codes. A Redwood City resident later said he did not know who his representative was because his zip code was split. I disagree with the zip code idea because while drawing districts, the commission needs to examine factors such as the Voting Rights Act and zip codes do not always combine minority communities effectively. A speaker from Dana Point in Orange County spoke at the meeting too, advocating for combining Monarch Beach and Dana Point in the same district.

Speaker #28 was the first of many speakers working with the California Conservative Action Group (CCAC). They drew maps for California’s districts that they say will address the concerns of California’s residents. Chris Bowman and Alan Payton drew the maps. Speaker #31, Jerry Diaz with the CCAC said that the congressional plan would combine Marin and Sonoma Counties while Redwood City and Scotts Valley would be in the same congressional district too. Another CCAC speaker criticized the State Senate map that placed Gilroy and Lompoc in the same district. I hope the commission alters this district by dropping the Santa Barbara County portion containing Lompoc because this district will be contested and northern Santa Barbara County leans Republican. #32, Sue Carol with the CCAC argued that the commission should not create district with the same voters but should combine voters by the same regions. If commissioners combined voters by regions, not only would they violate the Voting Rights Act, they would help the Republicans. The current 18th and 20th congressional districts are represented by Democrats because the districts combine Hispanic urban and farming communities across the Central Valley. Even if they do not live near each other, Hispanic farm workers in Fresno and Kern County have similar concerns involving fair treatment and wages. White voters in Clovis and Hispanic voters in South Fresno will have different concerns. #37 also advocated for a congressional line change that will help the Republicans. #37 said that Antioch should not be in the same congressional district with northern San Joaquin County. San Joaquin County is a swing area (it was one of the few counties Boxer lost and Brown won in 2010,) but Antioch leans Democratic and brings the Obama percentage in that district to 58%. By removing Antioch from the district, the San Joaquin County district would have to add more Republican areas such as Manteca and perhaps some Republican leaning parts of Stanislaus County.

After most of the CCAC group members spoke, we heard from many of the LGBT groups in San Francisco. Usually, groups such as the Log Cabin Republicans and Equality California do not join forces but they did for the commission meeting. Dan Brown, a leader with the Log Cabin Republicans said they want an Assembly District with more same sex couples. I also heard from some residents of the DPL area (Dublin/Pleasanton/Livermore) who wanted to be in a congressional district with San Ramon and other communities in the San Ramon Valley. Mark Cameron, a city councilmember from Cotati in Sonoma County disagreed with the congressional lines connecting Cotati with Yuba City and said, “We share a common agricultural history with Petaluma and Sebastapol.” #43 drove from Siskiyou County on the Oregon border and invited the commission to Siskiyou County because the commission had not been to the Oregon border area in Northern California. I also saw Calitics’s own Brian Leubitz who advocated for Marin sharing a congressional district with Sonoma County and more LGBT representation.

Speaker #47 was Mark Joseph, an American Canyon council member and one of the many speakers from American Canyon. Although American Canyon’s population is 19,000 people, its residents were well represented at the meeting. A bus from American Canyon brought residents to the meeting and the American Canyon residents had food provided for them. Joseph said that Napa needed to be kept whole and that American Canyon is the industrial base of Napa County with wine bottling and warehousing. 20 years ago, the wine industry in northern Napa County disliked American Canyon but the Assemblywoman they shared worked to unite American Canyon and the rest of Napa County. Speaker #48 was the Napa County Supervisor from American Canyon. He said that, “[the commission] has rallied Napa County like no other.” He also mentioned how American Canyon was treated as “North Vallejo,” and American Canyon did not want to be treated that way. Another speaker referred to American Canyon as “a great little city,” and severing American Canyon from Napa would stifle its voice. One of the most convincing speeches though was delivered by Brenda Knight, Speaker #56 and the chair of Napa Valley College. She described American Canyon as “the most diverse city in Napa. We had to fight for our zip code and post office. We are now accepted in Napa. The new districts erase everything we fought for.” After Knight finished her speech, the American Canyon mayor Leon Garcia announced that he had a petition with 1,103 signatures for keeping American Canyon in the same district with all of Napa County. Speaker #59 was Susan Lee with the American Canyon Chamber of Commerce. She said local business owners oppose the new districts. Speaker #65 said, “Keep Napa Napa.” After the American Canyon residents had finished their presentations, Commissioner Peter Yao said he hears American Canyon, “loud and clear.”

Overall, I believe American Canyon did a fantastic job organizing their opposition to the new lines. Not only did they bring in many speakers, they brought a diverse array. They had elected officials, education officials, business representatives and residents. They had representatives of almost every aspect of American Canyon. My advice is that if your town/city wants to advocate for a cause, do not bring one part of the town, and bring people who represent all aspects of the town, suggesting unanimous support for a cause. Not only did American Canyon’s presentation teach me about their town and struggle for acceptance, it taught me how to effectively organize a town for a cause such as fair congressional representation.

Other highlights from this meeting include that only a few Marin residents came to protest the new congressional lines connecting them with Del Norte County. In the May 19th meeting in Santa Rosa, Marin residents were motivated to come and advocate for not being combined with San Francisco. In this meeting, only a few Marin residents appeared to advocate for being combined with almost all of Sonoma County. This could mean that Marin residents are happier with the lines extending to Del Norte County. If one Marin and one North Coast politician face each other in a top two primary, the Marin politician would probably win because of the higher population in the congressional district’s southern part. Also, a few Sonoma County residents attended and many of them wanted to combine Sonoma County in a congressional district with Napa and Mendocino Counties due to the presence of winegrowers there. If the commission combines Napa, Sonoma and Lake into the same congressional district, they may combine Marin County with San Francisco. Although I dislike the congressional district that combines Marin and Del Norte Counties, I would prefer this North Coast district to a San Francisco/Marin district.

.

[poll id=”

460

“]

Analysis of California’s Proposed Congressional Maps Part I

Cross posted on my blog http://racesandredistricting.b… which you should check out for more redistricting analysis and maps.

On November 2nd, 2010, California voters passed Proposition 20 allowing a commission composed of 5 Democrats, 5 Republicans and 4 Independents to redraw my state’s congressional districts. Previously, the state legislature drew the maps. In the House of Representatives, the representatives represent voters in districts the legislature draws. In recent years though, states such as Washington and California have chosen commissions to draw districts without political influence. In California, the commission traveled around the state to hear public comments from citizens like me and talk to groups such as MALDEF. On June 10th, 2011, the California Redistricting Commission released their first set of maps for California after hearing public comments from meetings such as this one on May 20th that I attended. The guidelines set for the commission were to draw districts that follow the VRA, stick to county boundaries as much as possible and preserve communities of interest. This analysis examines the first 17 congressional districts to examine whether they fit the communities of interest requirements and what happens to the districts’ incumbents under the new lines. The commission has dismantled gerrymandered districts such as the 25th which connected Mono County in the High Desert with Santa Clarita in the Los Angeles suburbs. Still, I want to ensure that they have drawn all the districts so the districts respect communities of interest. Here is a link to the new maps of California:

http://www.latimes.com/news/lo…

The demographics and the voting percentages can be found here: http://redistrictingpartners.c…

A few notes: I will give district numbers according to the incumbents who live in the districts and/or which incumbent is most likely to run in the district due to factors such as the partisan makeup and familiarity with the constituents.

District 1 Mike Thompson (D) Santa Rosa/Napa/Yuba

Brown 54%, Whitman 38%

Obama 62%, McCain 34%

Demographics: 5% Asian, 29% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

I attended the meeting where the commission heard comments about Santa Rosa. A few meeting attendees said they wanted to combine the Napa area with the Central Valley but no one mentioned combining Santa Rosa with the Central Valley. Santa Rosa is more working class than the surrounding communities but it is not similar to Yuba County. Sonoma County does have agriculture but Santa Rosa is not very agricultural. Yuba County is very agricultural.  Anyway, this district may be a “leftovers district” because these areas had no district for them so they were placed in the 1st district. I would suggest that the lst district should have similar lines to its current form. This would unite Yolo, Napa, Mendocino, Lake, Humboldt and Del Norte Counties. Although Yolo and a few of the North Coast Counties may be different, they are more similar than Santa Rosa and Yuba City because Yolo County has Davis with university liberals and Humboldt County has Humboldt State also with university liberals. It also keeps the theme of counties with small cities instead of one city with around 160,000 people (Santa Rosa) with more rural territory with a few small cities.  Placing Santa Rosa with Marin County and the rest of Sonoma County keeps the theme of medium sized cities/suburbs with some rural areas mixed into the district. The lines help the Democrats though by placing Yuba County in this district because Yuba County could be used in another district to make it more Republican. Anyway, Santa Rosa and Napa County should keep this district in the Democratic column. Mike Thompson’s home of St. Helena is located in this district so he may run here.  

District 2 Wally Herger (R) Redding/Susanville/Chico

Brown 39%, Whitman 51%

Obama 44%, McCain 50%

Demographics: 14% Hispanic

Status: Likely Republican

The 2nd district combines the northern section of the current 2nd and 4th districts. It appears to follow communities of interest at first because it combines conservative small cities and towns across Northern California. The district contains both agricultural and mountain communities though with Susanville and Tehama County so the district does not completely follow communities of interest. Still, the communities are similar enough but I would prefer a district that contains the Valley and one that contains the high desert instead of containing both. As for a partisan standpoint, the district appears Republican but due to the inclusion of Nevada and Butte Counties, the Republican margin drops. Herger made a gaffe by calling a self described right wing terrorist a “Great American” so a strong Democrat in a very Democratic year will have a shot.

District 3 Dan Lungren (R) Sacramento suburbs

Brown 49%, Whitman 45%

Obama 51%, McCain 46%

Demographics: 7% African American, 10% Asian, 17% Hispanic

Status: Tossup

This district does follow communities of interest by staying in Sacramento County and representing Sacramento suburbs. I have no quibbles with this district from a COIs point of view. As for its partisan makeup, the district becomes a few points more Democratic with Obama’s percentage rising from 49% to 51%. This will help Ami Bera (D) who will challenge Lungren in 2012. Bera is a strong fundraiser and lost by seven points to Lungren in 2010, a very Republican year and Lungren ran in a more Republican district.

District 4 Tom McClintock (R) Placer County/Sierras from Placer to Fresno

Brown 36%, Whitman 57%

Obama 41%, McCain 56%

Demographics: 4% Asian, 11% Hispanic

Status: Safe Republican

This district contains Placer County, formerly part of McClintock’s 4th district but it now contains counties in the Central Sierra instead of the southern Sierra. If McClintock ran here, he should have no trouble because the district is heavily Republican but there is a slight chance the representative of the 19th district Jeff Denham (R) will run here.

District 5 Doris Matsui (D) Sacramento/Elk Grove

Brown 66%, Whitman 29%

Obama 68%, McCain 30%

Demographics: 13% African American, 20% Asian, 26% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 5th district adds Elk Grove but besides this change, it remains similar to its current form. McClintock lives in this district but it is strongly Democratic so Matsui should have no trouble winning here. McClintock will probably run in the 4th district because it contains most of his current district.

District 6 Lynn Woolsey (D) Marin/North Coast/Del Norte County

Brown 64%, Whitman 30%

Obama 71%, McCain 25%

Demographics: 16% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

I live in this district but I am opposed to its lines because I believe that Marin County has more in common with Sonoma County than Del Norte County on the Oregon border. Santa Rosa may be more labor based but it shares transportation corridors with the SMART train and closeness to Marin instead of Del Norte which is a 5 hour drive. The 6th district contains some of Sonoma County fortunately with Petaluma, the coast, Windsor,Healdsburg and Cloverdale. The district is too Democratic to elect a Republican representative with Obama winning 71% of the vote under these lines so if Woolsey retires, the battle will be in the primary and three candidates from Marin will likely  run. They are Marin County Supervisor Susan Adams (D), progressive activist Norman Solomon (D) and State Assembly member Jared Huffman (D). I attended a peace rally on June 18th in San Rafael actually that featured Norman Solomon, Susan Adams and Lynn Woolsey as speakers. At the rally, Woolsey stated that she wants people to write to the commission to argue for combining Marin and Sonoma in the same district. I hope you will join them.

As for Woolsey’s replacement if she retires, Wesley Chesbro (D) a State Assembly member may run from the newly added North Coast. His Assembly district starts in Windsor and extends to Del Norte County on the Oregon border. Although the Marin County/Southern Sonoma and North Coast parts of the district have similar populations numbers, the three Marin candidates may split the Marin vote allowing Chesbro to win by carrying the North Coast. In 2008, a similar scenario appeared likely when the 3rd State Senate district opened and Joe Nation (D) from Marin faced SF candidates Mark Leno (D) and Carole Migden (D). The 3rd State Senate district represented Marin, southern Sonoma County and part of San Francisco. The majority of the district’s population lived in San Francisco though. Nation hoped the two SF candidates would split the SF vote. Leno though campaigned hard in Marin, highlighting his liberal positions and lost Marin County by only 7 points, which allowed Leno to win the primary. One of the most important issues for North Coast voters is the environment so a Marin candidate may campaign heavily in the North Coast on the environment. Huffman and Solomon may fight to win the environmental voters while they each try to claim they are more environmentally friendly. This creates an opening for Supervisor Adams though. She can win by running by highlighting her work on three areas: family, health care and women’s issues which are important issues for Marin’s suburban voters while Huffman, Solomon and Chesbro try to outdo the others on the environment. She has worked on the environment too by helping the Marin County Open Space District and the St. Vincent’s/Silveira land but she should highlight her strong record on families, health care and women’s issues while Solomon and Huffman fight for the environmental voters. This strategy could give her the opening she needs to win.

District 7 George Miller (D) Pinole/Solano County/Davis

Brown 60%, Whitman 34%

Obama 65%, McCain 33%

Demographics: 11% African American, 16% Asian, 25% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 7th district moves northward and now contains all of Solano County as well as Davis in Yolo County. Garamendi may run in this district because it contains part of Sacramento County where Garamendi lives. Miller would probably win here though because the 7th district contains parts of his current district including Pinole, Vallejo and Vacaville.

District 8 Nancy Pelosi (D) San Francisco

Brown 78%, Whitman 17%

Obama 84%, McCain 13%

Demographics: 6% African American, 32% Asian, 15% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

This district grows a bit to eliminate population deviation but remains strongly Democratic.

District 9 Barbara Lee (D) Richmond/Berkeley/Oakland

Brown 85%, Whitman 10%

Obama 88%, McCain 9%

Demographics: 21% African American, 19% Asian, 23% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 9th district remains the most Democratic district in California by gaining part of Richmond. Also, the 9th district becomes more African American making it harder for a non African American candidate to defeat Lee in a primary.

District 10 John Garamendi (D) Walnut Creek/Concord/Inner Contra Costa County

Brown 59%, Whitman 37%

Obama 67%, McCain 31%

Demographics: 6% African American, 15% Asian, 21% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 10th district contains communities of interest by representing higher income communities such as Walnut Creek, Lafayette and Danville in Contra Costa County. Although Garamendi does not live in the 10th district, he could run here because it contains most of his old district which represented the Walnut Creek area and Fairfield. Miller lives here but most of his current district is not in the 10th so it is unlikely he will run here.

District 11 Vacant Jerry McNerney (D)? Antioch/Oakley/Lodi/Stockton

Brown 52%, Whitman 42%

Obama 57%, McCain 40%

Demographics: 9% African American, 14% Asian, 37% Hispanic

Status: Likely Democratic

This district represents towns in eastern Contra Costa County including Antioch, Brentwood and Oakley. It also represents San Joaquin County north of Manteca which includes Democratic Stockton and Republican leaning Lodi. I believe these areas are communities of interest because they include medium sized cities near and in the Central part of the Central Valley. McNerney’s current district was carved up under the new lines and he currently represents Brentwood and Lodi. The new lines place McNerney in a district with Rep. Pete Stark (D) so if Stark decides not to retire, McNerney may run here. A primary challenge from a Stockton Democrat is likely though. As for a Republican challenge, McNerney won in a 54% Obama district in a very Republican year so he should win in a 57% Obama district in a neutral year.

District 12 Jackie Speier (D) San Francisco/San Mateo/Redwood City

Brown 67%, Whitman 28%

Obama 74%, McCain 23%

Demographics: 30% Asian, 22% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

Besides gaining East Palo Alto and Half Moon Bay, the 12th district maintains similar lines. Speier should have no trouble winning in this solidly Democratic district.

District 13 Pete Stark (D) vs. Jerry McNerney (D) Hayward/San Leandro/Pleasanton

Brown 62%, Whitman 33%

Obama 68%, McCain 29%

Demographics: 8% African American, 27% Asian, 25% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 13th district undergoes some changes as it loses Fremont and gains Dublin, Pleasanton and Livermore over the hills. Although the district remains strongly Democratic, Jerry McNerney’s home of Pleasanton is in the new 13th district. Stark represents more of the new 13th district than McNerney does but Stark is 80 years old so this new district may convince him to retire. If Stark retires, McNerney should not lose in the Republican primary but a Hayward or San Leandro Democrat may run in a primary. The Hayward/San Leandro area has a higher population than the Dublin/Pleasanton/Livermore area does so McNerney will have to work hard for the Hayward/San Leandro area. As for communities of interest, Dublin/Pleasanton/Livermore are separated by hills but they are in Alameda County and connected by Route 580 to the rest of the district.

District 14 Anna Eshoo (D) Palo Alto/Sunnyvale/Scotts Valley

Brown 62%, Whitman 33%

Obama 71%, McCain 25%

Demographics: 31% Asian, 17% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 14th district stays mostly similar to its current form. It does become more of a Santa Clara County district as it loses all of Santa Cruz County except for Scotts Valley. It gains Santa Clara city and Cupertino. These areas are communities of interest by being high income communities in the Silicon Valley area. Scotts Valley though is closer to Santa Cruz than the rest of the district but Scotts Valley was most likely added for population deviation.

District 15 Mike Honda (D)? Campbell/San Jose/Gilroy

Brown 57%, Whitman 37%

Obama 66%, McCain 30%

Demographics: 18% Asian, 30% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

Although Honda lives in this district that represents southern Santa Clara County and the Campbell area, he may not choose to run here. The reason is that the nearby 16th district is heavily Asian and Honda may prefer a district with a larger Asian population. Zoe Lofgren (D) lives in the 16th district but Lofgren and Honda can move and switch districts. As for communities of interest, the district combines the most urban parts of San Jose with the more suburban and rural parts of Santa Clara County but due to population deviation, this could not be avoided.

District 16 Zoe Lofgren (D)? Fremont/Milpitas/San Jose

Brown 62%, Whitman 31%

Obama 69%, McCain 27%

Demographics: 44% Asian, 33% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

This district represents communities of interest by representing Fremont, Milpitas, and Alum Rock which have similar demographics of large Asian and Hispanic populations. Although Lofgren lives in the 16th district, she may decide to switch districts with Honda if Honda wants to represent a district with a large Asian population. They may both like the respective districts that contain their residencies so they may not move.

District 17 Sam Farr (D) Santa Cruz/Hollister/King City

Brown 63%, Whitman 31%

Obama 71%, McCain 25%

Demographics: 5% Asian, 49% Hispanic

Status: Safe Democratic

The 17th district adds Corralitos and a few rural communities in Santa Cruz County but besides these additions, the 17th district does not change at all. It retains communities of interest by representing the two counties on Monterey Bay: Monterey and Santa Cruz Counties. The 17th also represents San Benito County which has farming communities similar to the farming communities in Monterey’s Salinas Valley. Obama’s 71% of the vote in this district should prevent a Republican candidate from winning but if the district’s Hispanic population continues to grow, Farr may face a serious primary challenge from a Hispanic candidate.  

[poll id=”

456

“]