Tag Archives: Marine Corps

On Asking And Telling, Or, 115,000 LBGT Troops? How Many Is That, Exactly?

I took a couple of weeks off, as Thanksgiving and snow came around (a subject we’ll address in a day or so), but we are all again occupied as lots of things we’ve been talking about  either will or won’t come to pass, and it seems like all that’s happening all at once.

Today we’ll take on “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” (DADT); this because the Pentagon’s top leadership just came out and reported that revocation of the policy, following a period of preparation, would be their preferred way to go.

There will be lots of others who will take on the question of what’s right and wrong here, and exactly how implementation might occur; my interest is, instead, to focus on one little fact that makes all teh rest of the conversation a lot more relevant.

That is the fact that about 70,000 LBGT troops serve in the military today, DADT notwithstanding, and, that if it wasn’t for DADT, almost 45,000 more troops would be serving that aren’t today.

And that one little fact leads to today’s Great Big Question: exactly how much military would 115,000 troops be, exactly?

“Dad, if I were you, I wouldn’t tell that story. Now I have no doubt that there might be a lot of truth in it, but you know how funny these people are. You know you always used to tell us when we were children:  “Never smarten up a chump.”

–“Victoria Whipsnade”, to her father, “Larson E. Whipsnade”, in W.C. Field’s “You Can’t Cheat an Honest Man“

As we so often do, let’s set a stage: we use the 115,000 figure because we have the academic work of UCLA’s Gary J. Gates informing our estimate, and that estimate was updated in May of 2010.

A stage having been set, let’s move on to painting some pictures:

These days the Army organizes themselves around Brigade Combat Teams (BCT), and a BCT might normally be assigned somewhere between 2500 and 4000 soldiers, and 115,000 troops could equal more than 30 BCTs.

It appears that more or less 12 BCTs and two more Combat Aviation Brigades are on the ground in Iraq today, which works out to about 49,000 troops in total…and that means 115,000 LBGT troopers could theoretically fill every billet in Iraq, and then replace themselves after a year, with about 15,000 left over.

The Navy is organized around Carrier Strike Groups, which each consist of one of the 12 aircraft carriers now in service and the additional ships they require to complete their missions.

Those aircraft carriers require crew to operate the ship’s basic equipment, Marines who provide security and other functions, additional crew to operate the “Air Wing”, which is the organization on board responsible for flight operations, and, because carriers also serve as the “traveling headquarters” for the Admiral who is commanding the Strike Group, a few more crew to serve as the Admiral’s personal staff.

Add it all up, and a carrier can have a crew of almost 6,000 on board…and that means there are enough LBGT forces available to occupy every bunk on every carrier in the Navy, from the actual bed in the Admirals’ Cabin all the way down to the “stacks of racks” way down belowdecks for the ordinary Sailors and Marines.

Even beyond that, there would be enough people left over to crew every one of the Navy’s 100 or so submarines-and you’d still have about 30,000 sailors left over to maintain the ships and their associated aircraft when they return to port.

The Air Force, as with the other Services, is composed of components drawn from Active Duty, Reserve, and National Guard forces. As it turns out, the entire Air National Guard is 106,700 strong. Our 115,000 LBGT troopers could fill every one of those slots-and that would still leave enough personnel to completely fill the Air Force’s pilot training schools for seven years after that.

The Marine Corps’ fighting forces are designed to work with the Navy to combine a variety of capabilities into self-sustained “over the beach” units that can, if required, take and hold beaches, ports, or airfields, or build a base of their own and hold it, until a larger force can come in and expand the foothold, so to speak. (The Corps refers to one of these units as a “Marine Expeditionary Force”, or an MEF.)

To provide this capability worldwide, the Corps maintains three MEFs, one on the East Coast, one on the West Coast, and one stationed in the Pacific, based in the Hawaiian Islands and Guam.

115,000 Marines would equal almost half of the entire Corps, Active Duty and Reserve, and that’s more troops than two of the MEFs combined, which might typically comprise 45,000 Marines each, more or less…which means if the LBGT Marines needed to, they could most assuredly take and hold some serious real estate, more or less anywhere in the world-and if they ran into trouble, they could send back home for another 25,000 LBGT troops to help make their point.  

So there you go: the next time someone’s talking about how much national security might be threatened if we change DADT, you can tell them that there’s a cost to national security from keeping DADT as well.

How much of a cost? If you pulled those 115,000 potentially affected troops from the Army, DADT could cost us two Iraqs worth of troops, with 15,000 reinforcements left over, and if it was just the Navy, it could affect enough sailors to crew every aircraft carrier and submarine and 30,000 more besides.

If you removed that many personnel from the Air Force it would affect more people than the entire Air National Guard and seven years’ worth of new pilots combined-or, if you prefer to look at it through the prism of a eagle, globe, and anchor, it could be enough LBGT Marines to take and hold darn near anything, from the halls of Montezuma, to at least somewhere near the shores of Tripoli.

I don’t want to pay that price, and apparently the Secretary of Defense and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff don’t either…so hey, John Mc Cain…why don’t we just get over this imaginary Great Big Deal and move on to some real ones?

[poll id=”

416

“]

CA-46: Dana Stays the Course, Cuts and Runs in OC

While waiting for Monday’s debate between Congressman Dana Rohrabacher and challenger Jim Brandt, I met a young Marine outside. His blue eyes told me he’d served in Iraq, so we talked about other things. He’s on leave from out-of state and asked me who the candidates were. Then he told me about roadside bombs on the road to Fallujah. This article isn’t about him.

It’s a strange thing to go to a debate in Orange County, and discover the Democratic candidate has the home field advantage…

This diary is re-posted from Long Beach Politics. Also see atdnext‘s CA-46: The Brandt-Rohrabacher Debate at Golden West. Jim Brandt’s campaign site and ActBlue page. Also see Rohrabacher Cuts and Runs on the OC Weekly’s blotter.

Jim Brandt entered the Golden West College to champion’s applause and calls of “Semper fi!!” This was not lost on the ignored Congressman. Rohrabacher‘s sad, sheepish smile suggested he knew what to expect. After his experience at CSU Long Beach earlier in the day (YouTube pending), his staff called and changed the rules for the evening’s debate.

The Congressman cooked each response in illegal immigration, seasoned with lower taxes, Red China, Imperial Japan and Hitler. As if called to the blackboard without doing his homework, the incumbent avoided facts. When asked how the $1.6 billion SAFE Port Act could be used effectively to protect the Port of Long Beach, Rohrabacher acknowledged that mistakes had been made, that the money could probably be used more efficiently but reassured the crowd that his office was working hard to get it right. He gave similar answers on the economy, illegal immigration, the deficit, healthcare and the war in Iraq. Rohrabacher’s four minute answer on gay marriage was indecipherable but seemed to have something to do with the genealogy of arcane laws. He claimed State Senator Alan Lowenthal‘s successes with extending port hours and container fees for himself. While he tried to maintain measured tones, midway through the debate Dana Rohrabacher attacked the crowd with pointed finger before regaining his composure and directing the rest of his responses to either his lectern or his opponent.

Jim Brandt gave a firebrand lecture on public policy. His delivery of detailed and substantive proposals was an impassioned indictment of Beltway Republican policies. Jim Brandt noted SAFE Port will allocate millions (not billions) to POLA/LB for port security. He proposed single-payer catastrophic health insurance, economic incentives for employers to comply with immigration laws, religious freedom as the answer to gay marriage concerns, the application of private sector accounting rules to government, and taking the advice of generals in the case of Iraq. Brandt didn’t hammer on Rohrabacher, he took him to school.

After the debate, Brandt met with audience members as mutually agreed while Rohrabacher vanished through a side door. It seems that in California’s 46th Congressional District the incumbent, like Republicans across the country this fall, fell victim to GOP frames: he talked about Staying the Course on every issue and then Cut and Ran in his own district. “Where’s Dana?” evolved from a surprised question between neighbors into the chant of an angry mob.

Before left I saw my new friend again. “What’s going on?” he asked. “Brandt’s over there but Rohrabacher left,” I replied. Veteran’s eyes surveyed the crowd, looking for Congressman Dana Rohrabacher. “He’s afraid of the Marines,” he replied. “Too bad. I wanted to talk to him.”