Tag Archives: Steve Westly

California Blog Roundup 5/16/06

(Bumped for visibility over my long front-pager(s) – promoted by SFBrianCL)

Today’s California Blog Roundup is on the flip. Teasers: November initiative preview, the race for governor (money and TV ads, same as always), the budget process, education stuff, reform stuff, 15% Doolitle, Paid-For Pombo, immigration, typical Republicans, CA-50, CA-45, urban living.

Initiative Preview

Governor’s Race

Education

  • Assembly Democrats lay out their differences with Governor Schwarzenegger with respect to, vis-a-vis, and regarding the new budget. Alberto Torrico (AD-20), chair of the Assembly Transportation Committee thinks that Schwarzenegger is shorting transportation costs.
  • Educational Justice Blog reminds us that the big chunk of education funding in Schwarzenegger’s budget is only there because ABC and the CTA browbeat the Governor into actually keeping his promise. Why is it that Schwarzenegger needed to be pursued by the very people he attacked last year in order to keep a promise he made to the children of California?
  • California Progress Report has a guest piece expressing concerns about the high school exit exam.
  • The Mad Professah has written a thoughtful (and brief) post on the high school exit exam.
  • Randy Bayne is not so impressed with Sheila Kuhl’s proposal to call out the contributions of GLBT folks in California textbooks, arguing that it perpetuates labelling. I would have agreed with Randy once, but the problem is that almost everyone assumes that people (historical or otherwise) straight unless it’s pointed out that they’re not. Not mentioning a difference like that continues the assumption that GLBT folks haven’t contributed.

Reform & Reformers

Immigration

Paid-For Pombo / CA-11

  • Apparently, Paid-For Pombo is feeling the pinch on his sacrifice of the California salmon fisheries. So, the correct response is? You guessed it: destroy marine sancturies. The guy is a one man cascade failure.
  • Paid-For Pombo is all about stifling dissent, both in committee and in his campaign.
  • It seems that the Pombo-McCloskey debate was a slugfest. Good.
  • If I lived in CA-11, I would not vote for Pete McCloskey in the general, although I don’t think he’s a bad guy. I think a Republican majority in the House is a bad thing. The Republican Party is just too corrupt and too destructive for the few remaining honest Republicans to try to rein in. Pete McCloskey is not really a modern Republican, a charge also made by Pombo’s people. McCloskey takes umbrage and responds, proving that he’s not a modern Republican.
  • Jerry McNerney on renewable energy, at Daily Kos.

15% Doolittle / CA-04

General Purpose Republican Corruption

The Rest

My Westly Dealbreaker

Westly is rabidly anti-tax. This page spews the standard sort of anti-tax garbage I’d expect from a Republican.

rant continues…

Here he’s indistinguishable from any other big-buisness-over-people anti-government destroyer of democracy. Ok, he’s probably not all that, but California is in a revenue pinch and if we’re going to do all that we should do we need more money to pay for those things. Yes, that means raising taxes. But of course it can be done in ways most people never see simply by implementing a fair tax distribution instead of the current regressive mode. Included in Westley’s anti-tax fearmongering are taxes I definitely support like corporate property and income taxes, and “increasing taxes on alcohol to the national average”. Certainly just rising to the national average can’t be bad, eh?

So, conventional wisdom that I hear says that’s it’s a race between Angiledes and Westly. I guess I’m voting for Angiledes.

California Blog Roundup. 5/11/06

It’s big, it’s belated, it’s bloggy. Today’s California blog roundup is on the flip. Teasers: Republican corruption, Angelides, Westly, Schwarzenegger, 15% Doolittle, Paid-For Pombo (and CA-11 generally), CA-50, immigration, net neutrality, voting machines, auto insurance.

Republican Corruption

Governor’s Race + A Little About Bonds

Paid-For Pombo / CA-11

CA-50

15% Doolittle / CA-04

Immigration

Net Neutrality

Other

Debate Diary

I was not able to watch the debate, but from what Frank at California Progress Report had to say, it went down as I expected.  The two candidates spent their time attacking each other and then agreeing on most of the issues.

Last night’s debate, for all its insults and innuendos, did disclose differences that both Angelides and Westly have with Arnold Schwarzenegger in a number of policy areas. The June primary can come none too soon, so we can focus on the Fall classic in November. In the meanwhile, wear a helmet.

I’d tell both of these candidates to stress their differences with Schwarzenegger and cut out the personal attacks on each other. Respect each other’s differences while you are trying to draw distinctions between your approaches. Debate the big issues facing this state, as you will be doing in the general election. But I don’t think they would listen.(California Progress Report 5/11/06)

Agreed…if you are going to attack somebody, let’s make it Arnold.

New Westly Ad attacks “$10Billion Tax Increase”

( – promoted by SFBrianCL)

Steve Westly has a new ad today, not yet available on the web, that focuses on the issue of taxes.

State Controller Steve Westly launched a television advertisement Tuesday that implicitly accuses Treasurer Phil Angelides of proposing a “$10 billion tax increase.”
Even though the ad does not mention Angelides by name, it represents the sharpest televised message launched by either Democrat in the run-up to the June 6 gubernatorial primary. (SacBee 5/10/06)

Westly’s ads have been far more successful than the Angelides ads.  Of course, that is partly due to the fact that Angelides has not run as many on TV.  I think this is an interesting one though.  This actually focuses on an issue that will be very important during the general.

Now, of all 3 major candidates, none has really given a clear explanation on how they plan to repay Prop98 funds and balance the budget.  Westly has been talking about government audits and the lottery. Phil has talked about raising taxes on the upper incomes.  And Arnold…well…maybe he can hook you up with some oceanfront property.  It’s great, it’s right near Barstow.  You’ll love it.

But this ad does ratchet the pressure up between the two Dems.

Westly campaign spokesman Nick Velasquez denied that the latest advertisement breaks the positive campaign pledge the controller promoted last month.

“This is an ad that focuses on the controller, what he’s done and what he wants to do,” Velasquez said. “It makes no reference to his opponent. This is an ad about Steve Westly and not anybody else.”
***
The latest ad calls Westly “the only Democrat for governor who hasn’t proposed a $10 billion tax increase,” according to a transcript provided by the campaign. It also promotes Westly as “the only candidate for governor who’s a former teacher, with children in public school.”

The last claim may be another swipe at Angelides, who sent his three daughters to the private St. Francis High School in Sacramento.

I’m not too troubled about the children in public school thing.  I actually think it is something that our politicians should be using in their campaigns.  It is more than bit hypocritical to talk a big game about education, and then send your own to private schools that only the rich can afford.

As for the taxes, it’s a very important issue.  I would really love all 3 candidates to just lay their cards on the table and issue a proposed budget with all of their campaign promises.  However, that is not likely anytime soon.  In the meantime…let’s watch those ads I guess.

What makes a Poll worthwhile: Angelides by 10 over Westly

Randy Bayne at The Bayne of Blog has a post about a SurveyUSA poll conducted for SF’s KPIX-TV (local CBS affilliate).  It has him with a 10 point lead:

Here’s the question and the exact breakdown.

  Question:If the Democratic Primary were today, and you were standing in the voting booth right now, who would you vote for? Phil Angelides? Steve Westly? Or some other candidate?

  41% Angelides
  31% Westly
  17% Other
  11% Undecided

The margin of error is a little high, 4.9%, and I’m not sure how this poll should be viewed. As most people know, I don’t look to closely at polls as predictors. But the tread is moving away, big time, from Westly toward Angelides. It should also be noted that undecided is way down when compared to previous polls.

Now, the LA-Times poll just before the Convention had Westly up 13 with 45% undecided.  Perhaps the party endorsement made a big difference.  Perhaps the fact that Angelides now has some ads. 

Or perhaps polling in this state sucks.  There are just too many people and too many distinct interests.  4.9% MoE…ya…right.  I’m waiting for the next Field Poll.  At this point, that’s the only polling operation I have any trust in to do work in California.

But, at any rate, this will put an end to the incessant “momentum Marketing”.  A poll is no reason for me to vote for you, especially not a primary poll.  I know some people love the electability card, but at this point Arnold has so much more name ID than either Angelides or Westly, that any poll is going to pick that up.  Now, once we have a nominee and the hoopla surrounding the primary, then I’ll pay attention to those polls.

Where we go from here: Fighting Arnold’s bond-based momentum

There aren’t that many progressive bloggers focusing exclusively on California politics.  But, pretty much all of us have noted something about how this bond package will affect the governor’s race.  Julia at BetterCA has her opinion, Frank at CPR has his, and Randy at Bayne of Blog has his.  I know Bradley doesn’t like it when you call him a blogger, but he’s got his thoughts too.  And from the other side, Dan Schnur, a Rep operative, posted on FlashReport yesterday that this all but locked up the governorship for another 4 years.

The infrastructure bonds that the legislature put on the November ballot this morning will re-elect Arnold Schwarzenegger. Already armed with advantages over either of his Democratic opponents on taxes, driver’s licenses for illegal immigrants, and Jessica’s Law, the presence of bonds providing money for road, school and levee construction gives Schwarzenegger an issues arsenal that will be almost impossible for either Steve Westly or Phil Angelides to defeat.(FlashReport 5/5/06)

Now many of us would argue with parts of his logic.  I have a HUGE quibble with his belief that anything to do with immigration is a good issue for him.  But, that being said, I think if you nibble around the corners of the analysis from both sides, you get to an overall consensus this was a win for the Governator.

Until today, all he had to run on was the Worker’s Comp “De-form”. (See this BetterCA post about it.) I don’t intend on getting bogged down on Worker’s Comp, but you could get bogged down quickly.  In short form, the Worker’s Comp Reform has had much smaller of an impact than Arnold would have you believe.  In fact, Fabian Nunez called for another round of reform  on it just last month.  Suffice it to say that Worker’s Comp and the failed “Year of Reform” was not the greatest platform from which to run.

But Schwarzenegger found a winning issue in the infrastructure bonds.  It’s a sore spot of Liberal Democrat and Conservative Republican alike.  Who can vote against better roads?  More accessible housing?  Flood protection?  Well, in the end, the Democrats couldn’t stand up to this populist message.  Poll numbers for a bond package were just too high.

But the Dems did a good job on reining this one in.  Arnold had proposed a $222 Billion dollar infrastructure package.  It has now shrunk to under $38Billion.  Not chump change, but not quite $222 billion either.  But at any rate, it’s enough for Arnold to proclaim that he is the “Let’s Build It Governor.”  True, it’s Bullshit.  Arnold Schwarzenegger is no Pat Brown.  Pat Brown revolutionized not only the state, but the entire nation.  He provided a model of how to build infrastructure.  He built the incredible higher education system through his Master Plan for Higher Education.  He provided a water plan that is still, although clinging to life at this point, still the basis for our water delivery.  These bonds do not approach Brown’s broad vision.  By the way, if you are interested in Pat Brown, check out Ethan Rarick’s Pat Brown book, it’s a good read.

See the flip for more analysis

These bonds are broadly popular.  In April’s Field Poll (PDF), 57% of Californians approved of Arnold’s bonds package, with just 30% disapproving.  This includes a net approval of 11 point amongst Dems.  This is all during a time when he was at 39% overall approval, 47% disapproval.  And Dems had a 42% net disapproval.  So with Dems, Arnold had a net 53% swing from overall approval to the bonds.  This is a very, very good issue for him.  A real winner.

And the thing that is going to be even harder to overcome is the fact that there will be Democrats campaigning for this package.  Sen. Perata and Speaker Nunez worked hard on this package, and I’m sure they would genuinely like to see it pass.  A failure on the bond deal would not be a good thing for them politically.

And in addition to those considerations, add in the fact that both Angelides are almost forced to support the package.  And today they both announced that they support the plan – in principle.  Angelides has been a long proponent of bonds to improve infrastructure, dating from before Arnold’s plan.  So he has to come out in favor of “Arnold’s plan”:

“The agreement by legislative leaders on a $37 billion infrastructure bond package is a victory for our State and for future generations of Californians. This is a realistic infrastructure investment package that – when combined with a responsible and truly balanced budget that fully funds our schools – will help build California’s future.

“I’ve been a forceful and consistent advocate for using bonds to invest in an environmentally sustainable future. I’m pleased that this new plan draws from those values, adding a housing and transit component to promote smart growth, providing funds to secure our levees and enhance our educational resources.

“I applaud Senate President pro Tempore Don Perata and Assembly Speaker Fabian Núñez for fighting for an infrastructure plan that will put California on the high road to a sustainable future and a strong economy.”(NewWestNotes 5/5/6)

Phil’s campaign does a good job emphasizing the fact that the legislature designed this package.  Also, he pumps a few areas that he’s fond of: smart growth, levees, and levees.  In general this does a good job tying this package to his values.

And Westly?  Well, he has a track record of supporting Arnold’s bonds.  Is he going to change now?  Hardly: he can’t logically not support these bonds.  And so he does:

“I applaud the Democratic leadership for reaching across party lines to ensure that California can begin rebuilding its crumbling infrastructure.

“We must move past the partisanship that has paralyzed this State and work together to tackle the tough issues facing California.

“This $37 billion investment is vital to California’s future. We must protect those funds from waste, fraud and abuse. I am calling upon the Governor and the Legislature to put tough fiscal controls in place to ensure this bond is a boon – not a boondoggle – for California.”(NewWestNotes 5/5/6)

Again, this is a well-crafted release.  I like that Westly rolls his audit and clean government ideas into the mix.  Westly’s been all over the government efficiency thing recently, and this message just reinforces that.

But Arnold Schwarzenegger is not unstoppable.  First thing that I would point out is that I am in favor of this bond package.  However, the Dems who helped to work out this package should not appear with the Governator.  He wins if he can regain the bipartisan/moderate patina.  Having Dems at his side at campaign events would do just that and give him a big boost.  Angelides is running as the anti-Arnold and would be harmed if all of a sudden Arnold wasn’t that bad.  Westly, well, he’s getting pegged as a kindler, gentler Arnold.  If the real one is already seen as kind and gentle, he’s in a world of trouble.

Next: repeat this mantra: “One good idea does not a good governor make.”  He has had one, I repeat one, success since he has been elected.  This bond package is his ticket.  Oh sure, he was maneuvered into signing some other good bills, but this is really all he’s got.  You really think he’s going to start campaigning about immigration?  He’s going to start playing Arnold the Nativist.  I think not.  And education?  Hardly!  He can’t say one word without a throng of CTA teachers surrounding him and calling him on his bullshit.  Sure he could say that he was going to use the extra revenue this year to repay the looted Prop 98 funds, but you, I and about 12 million California voters know that this is not true.  And the teachers will make sure that they don’t forget.

So, how do we win on two fronts – the bonds and the governor’s race?  We change the subject as much as possible.  The bonds will practically approve themselves.  At this point, who is out there to protest them? McClintock – he voted against all but flood control?  Well, now that he’s Arnold’s running mate, that would be very poorly viewed upon.  So let the bonds do their own work.

And what should we talk about? 

1) Education.  The looted Prop 98 funds have still yet to be returned, regardless of whatever Dan Schnur has to say. 
2) Special Interests Arnold: The governor who vowed to crush the special interests, and called teachers girly men…yup, this is still him.  Now he is ok with taking special interest money, as long as it is a Grover Norquist-approved special interest.  In summary: Indjuns: bad.  Slave labor supporting, anti-tax wingnuts: good!
3) Prop 73 Redux.  2/3 of the state is pro-choice.  These are the people that are going to vote for a Dem governor.  Arnold endorsed 73 last time.  Let’s not tip-toe around this issue.  We need to take a stand on this issue.  Voters on the left will appreciate it, and pro-choice voters who are waivering will be attracted to a firm stance.
4) The Environment: Arnold tasked a committee to come up with a plan to reduce greenhouse emissions.  Then when he gets the report and Grover doesn’t like it, he hacks it to bits in his proposal to the legislature (Dianne Feinstein: “my heart fell when I saw that Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger had backed away from a strong position on global warming.” (SacBee 4/13/06)

And finally, on the day of the primary, as soon as we know the nominee, we rally around him.  Whether it’s Westly or Angelides, it doesn’t matter if you are luke-warm on him now.  If your guy doesn’t win the primary, well switch on over.  If Westly wins, Angelides, Nancy Pelosi and the 2 senators need to do a press conference the next day saying how much they support him.  If Angelides wins, Steve Westly, and his rainbow of supporters should do exactly the same.  Because in the end, what’s important is that Arnold returns to his acting career and Brutal Deluxe comes out in 2008, not 2012.

Westly’s Spanish Ad

( – promoted by SFBrianCL)

Steve Westly released a Spanish ad entitled Nuestro Futuro today.  It is focused on education, but also explains how his wife is an immigrant. 

My Spanish is rusty, but I got the drift.  I really, really liked this ad.  He seemed sincere over phony, which he occasionally comes off in English.  If you look at this in combination with the PowerPAC poll, Westly is gunning for a big advantage in the Latino vote.

Brian’s Report Card on the Debate

UPDATE: Thanks to Anxiocrat, here’s the link for the stream.  I like to let these things settle in my mind a little.  So, I’m taking my liberties as a blogger to revise the grades and provide some additional information.

The SacBee has a good recap of the debate:

The two top contenders for the Democratic gubernatorial nomination sharply challenged each other’s commitment to the environment and their records before and after taking office during the hourlong exchange hosted by the California League of Conservation Voters.
***
The two candidates agreed on relying more on alternative energy, developing more urban parks, making California a leader on the environment and fighting offshore oil drilling.

Both won the Sierra Club’s endorsement and have long lists of environmental backers. Both have environmental accomplishments to which they can point – and about which they argued.

Angelides won a 2003 environmental leadership award from the organization that sponsored Wednesday’s debate. But he made his fortune as a developer before his 1998 election, a career that opened him to Westly’s attacks Wednesday night.

Westly cited Angelides’ River West Developments’ destruction of vernal pools and wetlands at a Folsom housing development nearly two decades ago.(SacBee 5/4/06)

My take (on the part I saw anyway.  hey KABC: get with the Firefox bandwagon!):

Angelides: A-
He did a good job at explaining issues.  He had to show that he was capable of maintaining his cool level head.  He did just that. He was able to handle all the questions, seemingly knowing the back story too every issue.

He did a great job on rehabbing his developer career. He blew off the 40% of his campaign funds were from developers attack.  That’s probably the best move.  He doesn’t want to bring up the fact that Westly can’t self-finance and has tons more money in his campaign accounts, and certainly doesn’t want to discuss the developer issue.

Even after all of that, he didn’t fully address the Laguna West issues to the camera.  Also, Angelides still looks like your boring uncle to me.

Westly:  B-
He beat the $3.5billion drum to a bloody pulp.  By the time Angelides corrected him, I was hoping somebody would say something so I didn’t have to hear that phrase again.  Westly didn’t have as good of a grasp on the issues as Angelides did.  he frequently brought up the Million Solar Homes Act whenever he needed something to say about energy.  It was a little broken record-ish.

He was really on the warpath.  For a guy who was trying to say that Angelides didn’t sign his pledge, he sure did bring up the negative stuff.  I think we can officially call that “positive campaigning” phase of Westly’s campaign over.  He went after Westly for development.  He went after Westly for taking funds from developers.  I really, really did not appreciate the constant barrage of Dem-on-Dem attacks.  I’m hoping that both campaigns can clean up their acts in the next few weeks to focus their energies on the real task at hand: defeating Arnold.

Westly does have the telegenic aspect going for him.  His tone and style were excellent.  He looked very confident and was so good at staying on message. He took the old political skill of shifting questions to your own purposes to an artform. And he really challenged Angelides.  If he wins the primary, that hard-nosed attitude that Garry South has imbued him with will be a valuable asset against Arnold.

Winner: Angelides
Both candidates  had good performances.  I think both looked capable of taking on Arnold.  Both candidates received passing grades, but I think Angelides did a better job of explaining the issues and answering the questions at hand. 

Debate Live Online

The Debate is live online tonight at KABC in LA.  It’s not going to be aired live, so it’s probably the best way to watch it.  As of right now, it doesn’t seem to be working, but hopefully we’ll have something soon.  It appears that it’s not working in Firefox, but working in IE.  Of course, you could probably do as most others and just trust the media on how they did.  Here’s a list of the television times of the debates from Angelides.com:

Or watch in your area on these dates:
  San Francisco:
KGO Ch. 7
May 3 at 7 pm (digital channel)
May 7 at 4 pm

  Los Angeles:
KABC Ch. 7 – May 6, 3:30 pm

  Sacramento:
KTXL Ch. 40 – May 6, 12 noon

  Fresno:
KFSN Ch. 30 – May 7th, 4 pm

  San Diego:
KGTV Ch. 10, date of broadcast TBD

  Bakersfield:
KERO Ch. 23, date of broadcast TBD

The debate is sponsored by the League of Conservation Voters and focuses, unsuprisingly, on environmental issues. Both candidates are endorsed by Sierra Club, but neither really came into contact with enviro-issues in their previous jobs.  Angelides has his “green development history” in Sacramento, but I Westly’s environmental record is still a bit of a mystery.  He’s certainly leaning towards environmental groups in speeches, but I think what the Sierra Club is endorsing in both of these candidates is an Arnold defeat.

Check out Bill Bradley’s preview.  It’s got some good background.


Live blogging is on the flip.

Sorry I missed the first half hour.

7:28: Westly brings up his $3.5billion that he brought
7:29: Solar energy

Westly attacks Angelides for arguing for government take-over of electricity companies. Westly says that he has worked very hard for solar energy

  Angelides says that he stood up for the public against the electical companies.

7:30 Coasts:
Angelides is against off-shore drilling.

Westly: More public access to the beaches.  Once agian, he says $3.5billion he brought in.  And then attacks Angelides for attacking him.  Huh?


7:32 Toxics in environment, CA versus Feds
Westly: We need better laws than the Feds. Can fully fund CalEPA.  Talks about $3.5billion AGAIN.
Angelides: Will fight against pre-emption.  Tries to disagree about $3.5Billion

7:34: Ports and their pollution
Angelides: Ports need to handle trade for the state while not polluting.  Supports NRDC’s suit to improve ecological conditions in LA.  Shippers should pay for cleanup.
Westly: He says $3.5 billion is the right number.  Convert to electrification. “He knows how to make it happen”

7:36: Global warming
Westly: California must lead.  He created Global warming.  Supported Solar Energy Homes bill.  Points out Angelides job as a developer.
Angelides: He is proud of his career.  Supported legislation to green state’s cars.

7:38: Contaminated runoff bringing contaminants into water.

Angelides: We need strong urban runoff standards.  We should help localities do this.  Better development standards when building.  Says he fought Arnold when loosening standards

Westly: He stood up to governor too.  We need tougher standards too clamp down on developers.  Giver Air Resource Boards more support to clean air.

*Break* Candidates will question each other next…hmmm.
Westly to Angelides: Are you really proud of your developer record? Paved over watershed, Sierra Club sued him.
Angelides: He is proud of his business record.  Livable, walkable, sustainable community.  Helped close down nuclear power plant.  Got awards for environmental issues. 

Angelides to Westly: After governor became less green, Westly called him pro-environment.  Why did he gloss over differences with Arnold.

Westly: I stood up to Arnold.  I sent check even though Arnold signed executive order.  Ahnold took hard right turn.  I can win.  Tax increases are bad.  I know

Laguna West was a catastrophic failure.  EPA said Angelides paved over wetlands.  Is it really democratic to take 40% funds from developers.

7:47 Nuclear power
Westly: It is too costly.  We should subsidize alternative.  Never support nuclear until we can safely dispose of the waste.

Angelides: No on nuclear, yes to alternatives.  Led green wave.  Says Steve has lots of oil companies in his personal portfolio.

7:49 Environmental laws inhibit housing
Westly: We need more housing, but we need smart grwoth.  Stop sprawl. 
He says all of his assets are in a blind trust.  What are the developers buying with the 40%

Angelides: All investments are open records.

He supports smart growth.

7:51: Diesel Exhaust
A: Pensions invest in alternative.  Require filling stations of alternative fuels.  CA should be leader

W: They agree!  5 top polluted cities are in CA. More at ports.  Convert diesel to electric at ports.

7:53: Lower gas prices by more refineries
A: Need a path away from fuels.  I will stand up to Bush on this area.  He says Westly was conserving his energy not the environment, rather than fighting Arnold

W: “If only your environmental record was as good as your sense of humor” I ahve a track record

Closing statements:
A: Who has truly led?  I stood up for the environment.  I set up smart growth 7 years ago.  Westly did that last month.  Westly followed me in my environmental leadership.  CA has big enviro challenges. CA needs a governor who is ready to lead.

W: Election is about who is prepared to lead on the environment>  I worked in Carter administration for the environment.  Angelides built collosal failures.  Toughest rules against pollution.  Angelides is a developer.  We led on catalytic converters, we can do that again.  I will lead on the environment.