Tag Archives: Estate Tax

It’s a revenue problem, stupid

Here’s today’s question, which talks about the revenue side of the state budget, cross-posted from OC Progressive

What are the three biggest revenue cuts of the last ten years, and how much do they cost now?

Have we eliminated 1.2 billion, 2.9 billion, or 7.3 billion dollars in revenue streams?  

The first one is easy, because it’s been in the news again. California had a vehicle license fee (VLF) of 2% of the value of every vehicle in the state, that was in effect from 1948. It was a broad-based tax that everyone paid, and it was progressive, so that folks with more expensive, newer vehicles paid more money. It was also very, very stable, and was allocated to local government as a key source of their revenue.

When the state was flush with huge incomes from capital gains and alternate minimum tax on stock options, Republicans pushed through, and Gray Davis signed a bill that reduced that tax by two-thirds.

When the internet bubble burst, and the billions in revenue from phantom income disappeared, Gray Davis  re-instate that stable tax to help balance the budget that had been savaged by the volatility of the income tax.

Talk radio went crazy, Davis was recalled, and the Governator’s first order of business was to eliminate the re-instituted vehicle tax, promising to replace it by eliminating waste and inefficiency.

If that revenue were still in place, the state would have an additional 4.6 billion dollars a year.

The second biggest revenue loss is the shift of .25 cents of the sales and income tax to repay deficit spending bonds, part of the the financing scheme put together by the governator to replace the loss of revenue from the car tax, while he suspended his search for waste and inefficiency to join OJ in his search for the real killer.

Annual cost for this loss of revenue is 1.5 billion dollars per year.

The third major revenue source was the loss of the California State Estate Tax.

California once had an estate tax that was fully deductible against federal estate tax; it didn’t cost any California estate one penny more in taxes. To help make the 2001 federal estate tax cut program seem less expensive, Congress cynically phased out and then elininated a credit for the type of “pick-up” estate tax that California had assessed, knowing full well that we had hamstrung ourselves with propositions that would require a 2/3 vote to re-instate an estate tax.

In 2007, Californians paid 20% of all Federal Estate taxes. An estate tax would have yielded California somewhere in the range of 1.2 billion dollars.

Total annual revenue lost –  7.3 billion dollars.

So we’ve eliminated three major revenue streams, totalling 7.3 billion dollars.

Spending has been level for ten years when adjusted for population growth and inflation.



It’s a revenue problem, stupid!

[poll id=”

263

“]

November 3, 2007 Blog Roundup and Open Thread

Today’s Blog Roundup is on the flip. Let me know what I missed in comments, or just use this as an open thread.

To subscribe by email, click
here and do what comes naturally
.

Read These

Dianne Feinstein is
Principle-Free or Actively Pro-Torture:  You make the call.
(With Bonus Jane Harman Posts)

Reflections on the SoCal
Fires

Local

Environment

All the Rest

November 1, 2007 Blog Roundup and Open Thread

Today’s Blog Roundup is on the flip. Paid work is nuts this week, so just a link dump. Look for categories to return next week. Let me know what I missed in comments, or just use this as an open thread.

To subscribe by email, click
here and do what comes naturally
.