Steinberg and Bass on the State of the State

The Legislative Leaders sent their statement out together. Karen Bass put out some audio as well.  Both leaders strike a more conciliatory tone on the speech than some of the other statements released today.  You can tell these are two leaders who desperately want to do what is right for California and get some sort of compromise out there.  

Flip it.

Senate President pro Tem Steinberg:


“We stand here together on behalf of our respective houses to tell Californians that we are working hard to find common ground with Republicans and the Governor on a budget solution.

“We all understand what is at stake: California will run out of money if we fail to act. Tax refunds delayed. Job creating construction postponed.

“There is nothing easy about making up a $41 billion shortfall in our state budget.

“We have children to teach. Roads to build. Natural resources to protect. Seniors to care for.

“But we don’t have the money to do everything this year, thanks to a national and international economic crisis that some say is the worst since the Great Depression. In bad economic times many Californians know what it means, in fact, to cut back.

“State Government must do the same, but in a way that does the least damage to public education, to the environment, to the economy and to those most vulnerable protected by our social safety net.

“We have to and we will, throw out the harsh rhetoric in times like these.

“It’s no time for finger-pointing – Californians want and deserve more from us.  They expect us to work together to fix the problem and that’s exactly what we are in the midst of doing.

“To the extent that we have real differences with our Republican colleagues or the Governor, there will be policy differences and we will work them out the best we can.  We have no choice.

“Like the Speaker, I am still extremely proud that the majority party sent the Governor an $18 billion deficit reduction plan that would have fixed nearly half the budget shortfall and perhaps forestalled the cash crisis.

“And I genuinely believe that our action in that regard, in part has lead to the resumption of Big 5 negotiations and the effort to solve the entire $41 billion problem.

“But I think our action was indicative of where our hearts and minds are at.

“In serious times, you don’t just wait for solutions to fall into your lap – you work overtime to find the solutions.

“So we are working overtime and beyond to find a solution with the Governor and Republican leaders.  The Governor is right, the negotiations have been productive, but we need to keep going.

“There really is an opportunity to turn this situation around on a dime.

“Everyone talks about late budgets. When we get this agreement done over the next weeks, we will have then accomplished the earliest budget in the history of California.

“I can’t wait for those couple of weeks to pass and for the legislature and the Governor to come together on a budget agreement because then we can begin focusing on a positive agenda for California.

“We need to tackle the high school drop-out crisis, education, and the economy.

“We need to get a water agreement. Renewable energy. Health care. There’s so many positive issues, so many positive agendas to tackle.

“Let’s put this behind us so that we can get started on all of those things.

“Thank you.”

Assembly Speaker Karen Bass:

“This week we celebrate the birth, 80 years ago today, of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. – a man committed to empower those left behind in our society.

“We look ahead next week to the inauguration of Barack Obama – a community organizer with his own record of empowering others- as he becomes the President of the United States.

“Looking back at the life and works of Dr. King, and looking ahead to the values and promise of President Obama, we can see great changes that were won at immense cost and great changes to come – along with the shared sacrifice they require.

“Here in California, the governor’s state of the state address underscored the sacrifices ahead of us in guiding our state through this economic emergency.

“In his address the governor committed to working with the legislature to solve the budget problem, and that’s important.

“Californians want us to negotiate a solution to the budget and avoid the cash crisis. They don’t want school districts to go broke and layoff teachers…they don’t want small business vendors getting IOUs and they don’t want their income tax refunds delayed.

“Democrats have stepped up by passing an $18 billion package of solutions ….we’ve stepped up by cutting our operating budget 10%…. we’ve stepped up by introducing bills to aid unemployed Californians ….we’ve stepped up by introducing a green economic stimulus package that will create more than 40,000 jobs …and we’re stepping up by pursuing foreclosure relief and mortgage reform.

“When the governor and legislature work together as partners, real achievements like AB 32 and the infrastructure bonds get done.  The same can happen on the budget.

“One of the lessons we can see in looking back at Dr. King and looking forward to President Obama is that even in tough times, even when there is great challenge and sacrifice, there is also hope and opportunity.

“In the Assembly we look forward to working with the governor to make sure California remains the land of hope and opportunity.”

Sen. Cedillo’s Take on the State of the State

These just keep pouring in.  Here’s Sen. Gil Cedillo’s take over the flip.

“The Governor continues to talk around the central breaking point of the budget negotiation process – he has failed to find the Republican votes for a two-thirds budget deal. By rejecting the Democratic proposal – which was a fair solution that balanced difficult cuts with additional revenue – he has created this stalemate.

We can not ask students, the sick and disabled, or the elderly to bear the brunt of this budget crisis. We should not have to choose between highways and clean air or a balanced budget. Californians are clear on their support and expectations for education, transportation, the environment, and the social safety net that protects those most vulnerable.

The best budget solution will reduce the $41 billion deficit while doing the least damage.  Do the Republicans not receive phone calls from parents, students, or the elderly distraught over the possibility that an education or social service benefit, which is a life-line for them, will be lost? Where is the common ground in a scenario that puts the most vulnerable at risk?

Democrats are committed to working with the Governor and Republicans to fix the budget shortfall.  We have shown a willingness to make the difficult decisions necessary to solve this problem and remain ready to do so again.”

LG John Garamendi’s take on State of the State

You can find the Lt. Governor’s press release over the flip.

UPDATE: I just got a response from the Governor’s folks on Lt. Gov. Garamendi’s response:

Lt. Governor Garamendi’s response sounds like a partisan campaign ad for Governor – exactly the type of rhetoric Californians are sick of.

It is worthwhile to note that this statement is a little more bulldoggish than the statements of the Legislative Leaders. I think part of that just may be that Bass and Steinberg are more familiar with the Governor, but also part of it is most certainly that they are seeking to come to an agreement with the Governor. Garamendi was harsh, and playing for a largely Democratic audience.

I’ll leave it to you to determine which is more effective for their intended goals.

“The speech was extremely disappointing because the Governor stated the obvious and was very lean on solutions. Democrats in the Legislature have offered compromise after compromise and the Governor vetoed their proposals, directly pulling the plug on public work projects.

I believe that California is governable.

We need a governor who can lead.  We need solutions that respect our working families, invest in our children, environment, and the future greatness of California.

We must work together.

The Governor said he would not talk about education, the environment, health care and children in his State of the State because his speech was about the budget.  Yet these are the essence of our state budget.  They are on chopping block and they are on the forefront of the minds of the people of California. “

CA Labor Fed. Executive Secretary-Treasurer Art Pulaski statement on today’s speech

The Governor’s profound failure to lead in this time of crisis will be his legacy.

California’s working families are facing a crisis of epic proportions. We were hoping the Governor would use his State of the State to show us the light at the end of the tunnel — a sensible, fair proposal to balance the budget that would put people back to work and move our economy forward. We deserved much better than we heard today. Instead of embracing real solutions to lift California out of this economic morass, the Governor used his State of the State address to point fingers and peddle more empty promises.

The Governor’s repeated slash-and-burn tactics to balance the budget have left working families much worse off than we were five years ago.

Schwarzenegger’s response to the current budget crisis is so weak that he can’t even gain support from his own party, much less build consensus, bi-partisan support as true leaders do. That lack of leadership comes at severe cost to working families. Our state’s credit rating is tanking, thousands of jobs to rebuild our crumbling infrastructure are threatened and working people’s long-term economic security is in danger.

With working families facing sharply rising unemployment, mass layoffs and stagnating wages, it’s imperative that we stop the bleeding now. California should take a page out of President-elect Obama’s playbook and stimulate the economy by creating, not eliminating, jobs.  We also must take immediate steps to shore up our unemployment system and stem the tide of rising home foreclosures.

These are the real policies of change – plans that will put Californians back to work and get our economy going again.

AFSCME’s Making America Happen – Again

Check out the new video by AFSCME as part of their Make America Happen campaign. The video reminds us that we have overcome financial crisis before, and we can do it again.  It compared FDR’s solutions to the Great Depression with Obama’s plans to tackle our current economic crisis.  

As AFSCME President Gerald McEntee pointed out in his Huffington Post piece yesterday,

“President-elect Barack Obama’s call for bold action and civic engagement in response to our present crisis echoes FDR’s inspiring call to pull the nation out of the Great Depression and forge the New Deal. The video shows how our nation triumphed over economic crisis once before and can do so again by reinvesting in public service, providing health care for all Americans and growing the middle class.”

With a severe economic recession, an unemployment rate that reached 7.2 percent in December and continues to grow, and with more Americans falling into poverty, Americans are demanding action. Please sign our petition and make your voice heard.

The Make America Happen Campaign is dedicated to helping President-elect Obama revitalize our economy, provide health care for all, and strengthen the middle class. Our best days are still ahead of us.

http://www.afscme.org/makeamericahappen/

Inauguration Events in California

Post Them if You Got Them, I’ll try to clean ’em up.  To find all MoveOn.org parties, click here. And some parties from DFA here

Glendale:

Moveon.org Party organized by Joseph D.

Oakland:

Barack ‘n’ Roll

San Diego:

Farewell to W at the W hosted by San Diego Young Democrats at the W Hotel. 7:30pm – 1:30am.

Inaugural Bash at Magnolia’s. 5 PM at Magnolia’s

San Francisco:

Inauguration West (Facebook Link) 5:30-8:30 War Memorial Opera House

SF Inaugural Ball (Facebook Link), 9PM, Supper Club

Santa Monica:

Drinking Liberally/MoveOn Party hosted by our very own David Dayen

The State Of The State Is Ungovernable

Dave Johnson, Speak Out California

“People are asking if California is governable.”  Governor Schwarzenegger said in the State of the State address today that California faces insolvency within weeks.  He said there is more gridlock in Sacramento than on our roads, if that is possible.

The governor gave a very short speech, saying there is no sense talking about education or infrastructure or water or anything else as long as we have this huge $42 billion deficit.

But the fact remains that the state’s requirement that 2/3 budget-approval requirement means that the state is, in effect, ungovernable.   A few anti-government extremists are able to continue to block the budget, refusing to compromise or even negotiate, demanding that the state lay off tens of thousands of workers, slash medical help for the elderly, slash police protection and firefighting capability, slash funding for courts, raise class sizes to 40 or 50 students, stop repairing roads and levees and everything else the state government does.

David Greenwald writes at California Progress Report wrote, in State of the People is Grim: More Budget Cuts Are Exactly the Wrong Prescription,

“Budget cuts totaling $16 billion over the last three years have already had severe consequences for the people of California. And the Governor’s proposed 09-10 budget would further harm California families and our economy with an additional $17 billion in cuts to schools, health care, homecare, and state services.”

Leading up to the speech, David Dayen at Calitics wrote, in The State Of The State Is, Well, You Know, “Typically he has done this speech to coincide with the evening news.  This year he’s trying to hide it.”

We at Speak Out California want to invite readers to come up with some solutions for the budget mess.  We are working on some ideas for a prize for the best ideas.

Click through to Speak Out California.

Full Text of the State of the State

Thanks to Shane Goldmacher at SacBee for getting this out. Check it out over the flip.

Lt. Governor Garamendi, Chief Justice George, President pro Tem Steinberg, Speaker Bass, Senate Republican Leader Cogdill, Assembly Republican Leader Villines, Members of the legislature, ladies and gentlemen, we meet in times of great hope for our nation.

Although we hear the drumbeat of news about bailouts, bankruptcies and Ponzi schemes, the nation with great anticipation is also awaiting the inauguration of a new president.

Our nation should be proud of what President-elect Obama’s election says to the world about American openness and renewal.

President Reagan used to tell about the letter he got from a man who said that you can go to live in Turkey, but you can’t become a Turk. You can go to live in Japan, but you cannot become Japanese. And he went through other countries.

“But,” the man said, “anyone from any corner of the world can come to America and become an American.”

And now, we know that any American child, no matter what corner of the world his father or mother comes from, can even become President of the United States.

What a wonderful national story for us.

This nation rightfully feels the hope of change.

Californians, of course, desire change here in their own state as well.

Yet they have doubts if that is possible.

For months, in the face of a crisis, we have been unable to reach agreement on the largest budget deficit in our history.

We are in our third special session and we’ve declared a fiscal emergency – and every day that goes by, makes the budget problem that much harder to solve.

As a result of all this, California, the eighth largest economy in the world, faces insolvency within weeks.

The legislature is currently in the midst of serious and good faith negotiations to resolve the crisis, negotiations that are being conducted in the knowledge we have no alternative but to find agreement.

The importance of the negotiation’s success goes far beyond the economic and human impact.

People are asking if California is governable.

They wonder about the need for a constitutional convention.

They don’t understand how we could have let political dysfunction paralyze our state for so long.

In recent years, they have seen more gridlock in Sacramento than on our roads, if such a thing is possible.

I will not give the traditional State of the State address today, because the reality is that our state is incapacitated until we resolve the budget crisis.

The truth is that California is in a state of emergency.

Addressing this emergency is the first and greatest thing we must do for the people.

The 42 billion dollar deficit is a rock upon our chest and we cannot breathe until we get it off.

It doesn’t make any sense to talk about education, infrastructure, water, health care reform and all these things when we have this huge budget deficit.

I will talk about my vision for all of these things… and more… as soon as we get the budget done.

So, no, I did not come today to deliver the normal list of accomplishments and proposals.

I came to encourage this body to continue the hard work you are doing behind closed doors.

There is a context and a history to the negotiations that are underway.

It is not that California is ungovernable. It’s that for too long we have been split by ideology.

Conan’s sword could not have cleaved our political system in two as cleanly as our own political parties have done.

Over time, ours has become a system where rigid ideology has been rewarded and pragmatic compromise has been punished.

And where has this led?

I think you would agree that in recent years California’s legislature has been engaged in civil war.

Meanwhile, the needs of the people became secondary.

Our citizens do not believe that we in government are in touch with their needs.

These needs are not unreasonable.

At the end of the day, most people do not require a great deal from their government.

They expect the fundamentals.

They want to live in safety.

They want a good education for their children.

They want jobs.

They want to breathe clean air.

They want water when they turn on the faucet and electricity when they turn on the switch.

And they want these things delivered efficiently and economically.

One of the reasonable expectations the public has of government is that it will produce a sound and balanced budget.

That is what the legislative leaders are struggling to do right now.

There is no course left open to us but this: to work together, to sacrifice together, to think of the common good – not our individual good.

No one wants to take money from our gang-fighting programs or from Medi-Cal or from education.

No one wants to pay more in taxes or fees.

But each of us has to give up something because our country is in an economic crisis and our state simply doesn’t have the money.

In December, we even had to suspend funding that affects 2,000 infrastructure projects that were already underway.

So, now, the bulldozers are silent. The nail guns are still. The cement trucks are parked. This disruption has stopped work on levees, schools, roads, everything.

It has thrown thousands and thousands of people out of work at a time when our unemployment rate is rising.

How could we let something like that happen?

I know that everyone in this room wants to hear again the sound of construction.

No one wants unemployment checks replacing paychecks.

So, I am encouraged that meaningful negotiations are underway. And, as difficult as the budget will be, good things can come out of it.

Because, in spite of the budget crisis, when we have worked together in the past, we have passed measures that moved this state – and even the nation – forward.

When a budget agreement is reached, when some of the raw emotions have passed, I will send to the legislature the package of legislative goals and proposals that a governor traditionally sends.

These proposals are sitting on my desk. Let me tell you, I have big plans.

They include action on the economy, on water, environment, education, health care reform, government efficiency and reform, job creation.

But, our first order of business is to solve the budget crisis.

And I have an idea going forward.

As you know, in the last 20 years of budgeting, only four budgets have been on time.

So, if you don’t mind, let me make a little suggestion.

We should make a commitment that legislators – and the governor, too – lose per diem expenses and our paychecks, for every day the budget goes past the constitutional deadline of June 15th.

You have to admit it is a brilliant idea.

I mean, if you call a taxi and the taxi doesn’t come, you don’t pay the driver.

If the people’s work is not getting done, the people’s representatives should not get paid either.

That is common sense in the real world.

And I will send you some other reforms, too.

Let me close by saying something about the fires of 2008.

At one point, I got a phone call that we had 875 wildfires burning all at the same time.

I said to myself, how do we deal with this?

The next morning I get a call, “Governor, there are now 2,014 fires burning all at the same time.”

The largest number on record.

Imagine, 2,000 fires, a huge challenge and every one of those fires was put out.

You know why? Because we have the best trained, the most selfless, the toughest firefighters in the nation.

Thirteen of whom lost their lives.

They gave their lives for this state.

Ladies and gentlemen, the courageous examples of those firefighters should not be lost on us.

In our own way, we, too, must show courage in serving the public.

Ladies and gentlemen, let this be a year of political courage.

Let us be courageous for the people.

Let us be courageous for the common good of California.

Let us resolve the budget crisis, so that we can get on with the people’s work.

Thank you.

The State Of The State Is, Well, You Know

(KQED here in the Bay Area will be airing live coverage at 10, as well as an hour of “pre-game” coverage on their Forum program at 9.  You can listen live here.  The California Channel will be covering it live as well. – promoted by Brian Leubitz)

Arnold Schwarzenegger delivers the State of the State Address at 10am this morning.  Typically he has done this speech to coincide with the evening news.  This year he’s trying to hide it.

I don’t blame him.  As David Greenwald discusses, people pretty much know the State of the State already.

As Governor Schwarzenegger prepares to report on the State of the State tomorrow, California’s families today declared that “the State of the People” is increasingly grim with a record number of Californians having lost their jobs and health care and their homes. California educators, students, health care workers, seniors and people with disabilities said more state budget cuts are exactly the wrong prescription after they’ve suffered the consequences of more than $16 billion in state budget cuts to critical services over the last 3 years.

“California families are here to report what you won’t hear from the Governor tomorrow: budget cuts over the last three years have deeply wounded our families’ health and well-being, diminished our children’s opportunity for the future, and damaged our economy.” said Evan LeVang, Director, Independent Living Resource Center of Northern California.

Californians who have personally been affected by budget cuts detailed the severe consequences that the cuts, including $10 billion in cuts already this year, have had on California families who have already been hit hard by the nation’s economic meltdown.

“Before our elected leaders slash another dollar from our hospitals, they should think about what health care would be worth to them if their husband, their daughter, or their father needed care. Because every patient that comes to our hospital is someone’s parent, spouse, or child,” said Beverly Griffith, an environmental services worker and SEIU member at Summit Medical Center in Oakland. “While longer hours and staff shortages caused by budget cuts have been rough on hospital workers, they’ve been unbearable for our patients.”

And of course, this is bound to get worse.  It’s important to split the two major problems into their discrete parts – we have a budget crisis AND a cash crisis.  Even if the budget hole is at least partially filled (and with any luck, we’ll be able to access some federal stimulus money, either through direct payments or tax revenues on increased economic activity, by February), the cash crisis would persist, and we could see IOUs even after a budget deal because of the inability for California to go to the bond markets and borrow.  And the converse is also true.  In sum, it’s a different problem which needs a different solution.  The LAO is obscure here, but I believe “restricted funds” refers to Prop. 98 money:

The Legislature’s budget analyst, Mac Taylor, says that schools, colleges and bondholders will have first call on the state’s money if its cash flow crisis hits home in a few weeks.

But Taylor says in a report on the looming cash flow crisis that even if the Legislature fails to reach agreement on closing the state’s budget deficit, the cash crisis could be relieved with some emergency legislation to allow more internal borrowing of restricted funds.

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger and legislative leaders have been conducting closed-door negotiations this week on both the budget and the cash crisis, which are related but separate issues. Controller John Chiang has said that the state will be forced to curtail state disbursements sometime in February unless there’s rapid action on the budget and/or cash flow-related legislation […]

The administration has asked the Legislature to approve measures that would free up about $2 billion in restricted funds that could be borrowed by the state general fund and thus stave off the cash crunch. It’s also said that rapid action on the budget would allow the state to defer more than $1 billion in payments to schools that otherwise would have to be made.

As a budget solution would at least have some impact on loosening the bond markets, this could be the intent of Schwarzenegger’s delay – so he can raid dedicated funds for schools and health care.  It’s important for us to start figuring out Arnold’s gambit.  When I talked to State Senator Fran Pavley at one of the election meetings last weekend, she said “It’s hard to negotiate with someone if you don’t know what they want.”  My next several posts here will seek to figure that out.

Anyway, you’re not going to hear it at 10am, I gather.

State of the State Live Coverage

PhotobucketGov. Schwarzenegger gives his State of the Disaster Area State at 10 AM, and I’ll be listening and/or watching.  On the listening front, KQED here in the Bay Area will be airing live coverage, as well as an hour of “pre-game” coverage on their Forum program.  You can listen live here.  Also, I imagine the California Channel will be covering it live as well.  However, the details of their coverage isn’t yet on their website.  That’s also available in some cable packages.

What exactly will Arnold say? Who knows?  I mean, what can he say that he or Mike Genest haven’t said already?  This is a horrific disaster, and Arnold and the GOP are playing shock doctrine. What’s left to say? What’s one more round in the cage match at this point to him? Well, we shall see at 10.