Tag Archives: Financial Crisis

Phil Angelides: Banks Were Reckless, Regulators Were Feckless

Phil Angelides is something of a blast from the past in California politics, but since President Obama appointed him to head the investigation into the financial crisis, he’s been a busy guy.  The report came out yesterday, and is now available online.

So, what does the report say? Well, in short, banks disregarded or badly miscalculated risk.  Angelides, in radio interviews, alleges CEOs of actively disregarding risk.

Enabling those developments, the panel found, were a bias toward deregulation by government officials, and mismanagement by financiers who failed to perceive the risks.

The Fed, under Mr. Bernanke’s predecessor, Alan Greenspan, failed to develop mortgage lending standards that could have stemmed the flow of bad mortgages into the financial pipeline, the panel found. “The Federal Reserve was clearly the steward of lending standards in this country,” said one commissioner, John W. Thompson, a technology executive. “They chose not to act.” (NY Times)

There really isn’t anything too shocking here. It is more a matter of scope than of any new knowledge. Unfortunately, the problem is that we haven’t really made the changes necessary to prevent a repeat.  However, the commission did [refer a few criminal complaint

The commission’s chairman, Phil Angelides, said he hoped the report would help bear witness to a preventable catastrophe. “Some on Wall Street and Washington with a stake in the status quo may be tempted to wipe from memory this crisis or to suggest again that no one could have seen or prevented it,” he said.

But little on Wall Street has changed. One commissioner, Byron S. Georgiou, a Nevada lawyer, said the financial system was “not really very different” today from before the crisis.

“In fact, the concentration of financial assets in the largest commercial and investment banks is really significantly higher today than it was in the run-up to the crisis, as a result of the evisceration of some of the institutions, and the consolidation and merger of others into larger institutions,” he said. (NY Times)

The commission did refer a few criminal complaints to the DOJ, but whether there will be prosecutions is unclear.  The dissent wasn’t really all that different from the majority report, other than they were kind of pissed off by some of the rhetorical flourishes in the report.  At any rate, stay tuned to David Dayen at FDL form more on the FCIC report.

50 State Keynesianism – Part 2

Note: This is a cross-post from my group blog, The Realignment Project, and part 2 in a series about how to bring Keynesian economic policy to the state level.

Introduction:

In this post, I'm returning to a theme I initially explored in June, back when California was grappling with its budget crisis.

Now, after nearly two months of additional struggle, we finally passed a bill that cut $26 billion and raised no new revenue, and now we learn that the governor has possibly illegally cut a further $500 million, taking the axe to children's welfare ($80 million), health care ($400 million), Cal Grants (cut in half), HIV/AIDS Prevention and Treatment ($52 million), and domestic violence shelters (cut by 80%). In addition to the moral insanity of attacking the most vulnerable of our citizens at a time when they are most in need of support one must add the economic insanity of believing that you can reduce government spending by $31 billion in the course of a single year (including both the February and July cuts)  and not effect the state's economic recovery.

Lest this be seen as merely a California problem, a recent report by the National Governors Association notes that the collective budget shortfalls of the fifty states comes to a collective $200 billion shortfall. Given that the total Federal economic stimulus for this year only comes to about $400 billion, we are forced to recognize that our system of state government budgeting and finance is creating a massive economic undertow, weakening the impact of Keynesian stimulus by cutting spending and raising taxes (although they've been doing a lot more of the former than the latter).

Background:

Why is it the case that America's state governments have become so strongly pro-cyclical? The basic reason is that all but one state in the Union (Vermont being the exception) have some form of a balanced budget or debt limitation requirement, which makes it impossible to deficit spend during recessions.

Many of these requirements date back over a hundred years, following the Panic of 1837, which caused nine states to default on their “internal improvement” (i.e, transportation infrastructure) related debts in 1842, which prompted a wave of anti-debt measures. The state of New York, for example, adopted a new constitution in 1846, which required a 2/3rds vote for appropriations bills and a 3/5ths vote for any bill that would raise taxes or incur debts. Illinois' 1848 constitution required a 2/3 vote for appropriations, a balanced budget requirement, and a $50,000 cap on state debts. Similar waves of constitutional redrafting tended to follow other major recessions in which states suddenly were unable to finance their debts, such as the Panics of 1857 and 1873 (triggered by the failure of banks that had over-speculated on railroads).

The question is why we allow a “hobgoblin of little minds” over a hundred and seventy years old to continue to rule over us? Why, when even a total economics amateur like myself can pick up Keynes and learn about the “paradox of thrift,” do we continue to allow the political cliche that “well, families have to balance their budgets, so the government should too” to be the conventional wisdom of the stump speech? (Incidentally, given the fact that most American families are horribly in debt and are relying on their credit cards to make ends meet, this couldn't be less accurate).

A 50-State Solution:

One of the things that's often puzzled me about the progressive movement is our lack of willingness to use the initiative process to our advantage in both achieving policy ends and mobilizing the electorate – consider the way in which the Republican Party used anti-gay marriage propositions in 2002 and 2004 to gin up their right-wing base, change the political debate from economic issues to their wedge issues, and attack the civil rights and civil liberties of queer Americans. In 2006, we saw a little bit of this strategy on the progressive side, using minimum wage initiatives to increase working class turnout in states like Ohio, but to the best of my knowledge it hasn't become a standard part of the Democratic Party political toolkit.

Hence, the first step in establishing “50-state Keynesianism” is to promote, state-by-state an “Anti-Recession Budget Reform Initiative.” (if anyone has a better name for it, I'm open to suggestions). This initiative should amend the state constitution's balanced budget requirement to allow the state, when the economy is in recession (i.e, two quarters of negative economic growth) to run a limited deficit (two years maximum) for the purposes of funding counter-cyclical stimulus programs (limited to say, 5-10% of state GDP).  We should begin our push in those areas which are deep blue states and which tend to have weaker balanced budget requirements – New England would be a good starting place, especially with Vermont as the lone non-balanced budget state sitting there as a model for how deficit spending won't destroy western civilization. The Rust Belt states that have been especially hit hard, like Michigan or Ohio, would probably be receptive to a message that it's better to spend money to create jobs than to balance a budget by throwing teachers and other state workers out of their jobs. As usual, the major prizes would be New York and California, given their size and political weight.

Second, in order to build state capacity for Keynesian economic policy, we should also push for the creation of State Reserve Banks.  Here, I really have to credit Ellen Brown over at the Huffington Post for promoting this idea and bringing it to my attention. This amazingly simple yet powerful idea takes its example from, of all places, the state of North Dakota, which has operated the Bank of North Dakota since 1919. It works like this – the state charters a public bank, and instead of placing its reserves, tax revenues, deeds for public lands, and so forth in a variety of state banks (as most states do), it puts all of them in the public bank to act as the bank's capital base. (Note: as long as the bank only circulates U.S dollars, it's perfectly constitutional, avoiding the Article I, Section 10 bar against states issuing coin or bills of credit) The bank then acts like a reserve bank, using the power of “fractional reserve lending” (i.e, that a bank can generate much more money in loans than it keeps in its vaults, thus multiplying many times over its actual reserves, as long as it keeps back a portion to redeem deposits) to generate loans, act as a local “lender of last resort” (thus buttressing the work of the Federal Reserve and FDIC during credit crises), and (this is the key bit) allowing the State to borrow money in order to deficit spend in a recession without relying on the ideologically-biased bond market and the credit agencies who've taken a hammer to state bond ratings while maintaining A ratings for AIG and Lehman Brothers. The State could then use these loans (which would be much cheaper than ordinary bonds, given that its essentially paying interest to itself) to maintain public services and fund public works and other stimulus measures in a recession.

Third, as I've suggested before, one of the best ways to fight a recession is to create jobs directly. Hence, with all this new fiscal and monetary muscle, we should set up a WPA-like system of State “Job Insurance.” While the Federal government is best suited to this task, in that it has superior powers to deficit spend and print money, state governments could run their own permanent job insurance systems, establishing State J.I Funds, contributions from workers and employers, and assistance from the general fund. The idea would be to create short-term jobs (say 6-month duration, with a right to re-apply after a job search at the end of 6 months) at $10 an hour – the number of jobs directed at reducing unemployment by whatever proportion (say, 50% in the example below) needed to keep unemployment at or below a specific level. As the economy turned around, these jobs could be gradually eliminated (at 1/2 the rate of job growth, for example) in order to not damage the recovery as happened when the WPA was suddenly downsized in 1937-8. In return for a monthly contribution, workers would have a right to one of these jobs, as allocated by some fair procedure (order of application, random lottery, etc.).

Let's take California as an example. The state has a normal workforce of 18.5 million people, of which 2.146 million are currently unemployed (a rate of 11.6%). The objective of a new job insurance system would be to create enough jobs to bring the rate down to an acceptable level – say, by 50% down to 5.8%. (Note, while I would consider 5.8% unemployment to be unnecessarily high, and while we may want to consider ultimately lowering the official “acceptable rate,” for the moment, let's consider simply meeting the immediate crisis). In order to create 1,073,000 jobs, the state would need to spend approximately $40 billion (taking into account wages, payroll taxes, and non-labor costs such as equipment, materials and land – although the state would probably require counties and localities to put up at least part of the latter two items).  Now, if we were simply to fund this off of Job Insurance contributions, you’re looking at $200 a month, which is quite high, although I imagine that it would be affordable for middle class folks and up. However, if you were to split the costs between contributions and State Reserve Bank lending (and/or general fund contributions), you could drop it to $100 a month (50-50), or $33 a month (say, 33/66 or, 33/33 and 33 from general fund).

Note that this is the cost if you have to do it all in one go – if we think about this a system to prevent the next recession, you can implement the Job Insurance system in economic good times, and build up a reserve, which would allow you to run the system on still lower job insurance premiums. Moreover, if you create a target for jobs to be created when unemployment grows to a certain level, the lower the level, the cheaper the program. If, for example, California had done this back in October 2008 when unemployment was only 8%, it would only have cost $29.6 billion to reduce the unemployment rate down to 4%, which would have buoyed consumer spending, forestalled foreclosures, and prevented further job losses in the private sector.

Now, I fully acknowledge that this would be a radical transformation of state economic policy, and that certain elements, especially the Anti-Recession Budget Reform Initiative, would be politically tricky to thread the needle on. But I would say that if you can't sell the public  job insurance that costs $33 or less a month, can't persuade people that freedom from economic uncertainty is within their grasp, can't tap into people's desperate desire to be free from the fear of destitution, you shouldn't be in politics.

Salus Populi and the Market – A Case for “Automatic” Regulation

Note: this is a cross-post from my group blog, The Realignment Project.

In my last post (and the post before that), I mentioned the importance and difficulty of talking about financial regulation, a task which has been made all the more difficult by an arcane financial products industry that isn't really understood even by its experts.

So in trying to get to grips with this topic, I'm trying to triangulate in on it from different angles – one of which, the idea of a public bank as a yardstick I discussed last week. Today, I'd like to bring up an important point about financial regulation, that the problem we face is three-fold: deregulation, un-regulation, and regulatory capture (and potential incapacity).

More over the jump!

Pretty much all that needs to be said about the impact of deregulation has already been said. And quite a bit has been written about the government's refusal to regulate the new “shadow financial sector.” And if that were all there was to the story, it would be fairly easy to fix the financial sector.

The problem is regulatory capture and potential incapacity – regulatory capture seems to be nearly inevitable, as long as financial institutions can offer jobs to former regulators, contributions to electeds and party organizations, and financial experts to the regulatory agencies themselves; even if that weren't already a massive conflict of interest that allows financial institutions to game the system, you have the problem that even a completely honest regulatory watchdog might not have have the financial, personnel, legal, and expertise resources needed to actually regulate – and Congress certainly hasn't shown itself particularly interested in keeping the FDA up to scratch, let alone the SEC.

So what do you do if old regulations are gone, there aren't new regulations to deal with new problems, and the regulators either can't or don't want to regulate? This brings me to a point brought up by Matt Yglesias, when he pointed out that the failure of regulatory authorities to recognize and halt this crisis:

..leaves us with an appreciation of crude measures rather than hubristic efforts to get the regulations precisely right…The best you can hope from a regulatory regime is that it will be a satisficing [sic] solution wherein some fairly crude rule will improve on the outcomes generated by the unfettered market. When that’s not the case, we may as well let the market go unfettered even though that, too, will be somewhat sub-optimal.

What we don't need is to look to the newest fad in economics (behavioral economics, I'm looking at you) to give us a flawless model for predicting when market faiilures will happen. What we don't need is “regulation for the 21st century,” or for any new paradigm. What we need are regulations that work without regulators – automatic regulation.

Automatic regulation doesn't refer to some sort of sci-fi legislation that creates self-enforcing, self-aware regulatory cyborgs. Although a Wall Street Robocop would be a cool idea, I'm actually talking about regulation that establishes clear and transparent bright lines that any informed member of the public or the media can understand. The Glass-Steagall Act's separation between commercial and investment banking was virtually self-evident: if people could deposit their money in a bank, that bank wasn't allowed to underwrite securities (stocks and bonds); if a bank floated bond issues and acted as a broker in the securities market, it couldn't receive deposits. A reserve requirement, like the Fed's reserve requirement or the 1860s rules that required "national banks" to back their bank notes with T-Bills, is easy enough to check: you look at how much money the bank is circulating, and how much it's supposed to keep in reserve,  and if the two numbers don't balance out, there's a problem. Bob LaFollette, one of the forgotten heroes of American Progressivism, in his 1924 third party race for the presidency called for the breaking up or nationalization of all corporations with (either 9% ot 15%) of market share – a radical proposal, but one that would have been easy to administer.

Automatic Financial Regulation:

In thinking about how to create automatic regulation for the financial industry, three broad categories of regulation come to mind:

  1. Bright Line Regulations – the proposed limitation of oil derivatives seems like a good place to start in terms of automatic regulation – extending these limits to other commodities such as electricity and waster might prevent a future Enron-like fraud-via-false-scarcity (such as befell California).  Another example of how one could establish an automatic regulation in finance would be to ban tranche-ing, preventing one step of the process by which uncertain assets can be repackaged into a more marketable form. Restoring transactions on margin, or establishing a small transactions tax would further reduce speculative bubbles, market “hurn,” and pump-and-dump schemes without restricting long-term investment. If these ideas seem a little scattered, and underdeveloped, I accede to that, but I would point out that all of them rely on relatively simple prohibitions or requirements, reducing the effort of oversight.
  2. Competing Public Ratings Agencies – one major area of the financial sector whose inherent weakness has allowed bubbles to become more frequent in recent years is the fact that the major ratings agencies for stocks, bonds, derivatives, and so on are for-profit private institutions whose livelihood depends on a reputation for providing good ratings for their clients. In this, we see a parallel between virtually all of our recent financial scandals – in the Enron/WorldCom/etc. corporate scandals of 2003, it was accounting/consulting agencies who helped conceal the bookkeeping fraud that made most major American corporations seem more profitable than they really were; in the housing bubble, the subprime/securitization/tranching system wouldn't have functioned without housing evaluators whose conflict-of-interest-ridden valuations helped spiral real estate prices out of rational bounds. Hence, I would argue that one major systemic change that should be done is to create a number of public rating agencies for stocks, bonds, other securities, and real estate, who would be required to use common standards of valuation, and whose ratings would only be published as averages – complicating if not completely eliminating the process of agency capture.
  3. Right of Private/State Suit to Enforce – arguably one of the most important elements in the civil rights bills of the 1960s were the provisions allowing private citizens to bring suit to protect their own rights (Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, and Section V of the Voting Rights Act), allowing enforcement to continue even when the government was hostile to civil rights enforcement. In recent years when the regulatory agencies have been captured by conservative ideologues, the use of state suits to force the EPA or similar agencies to enforce the laws have been crucial in preventing the total undermining of environmental and other regulations. Hence, one crucial factor in creating automatic regulation must be a clear mechanism to allow private groups, state attorneys general, and the U.S Justice Department to bring lawsuits against both regulators and the subjects of regulation to require that bright lines be enforced.

The People’s Bank

Note: this is a cross-post from my group blog, The Realignment Project.

From Whence We Came:

As much as some people cling to the idea that the United States has always been a land of anti-government, laissez-faire bustling capitalists, the fact is that the specters of democratic statism haunt the chronicles of American history, all the way from the beginning. One of the oldest and most powerful phantoms is the Bank of the United States that died and was reborn, again and again through the history of American politics like the immortal monsters of slasher horror films.

Because the Bank was there from the beginning – Hamilton drafted it, Washington signed it, and Adams maintained it. Even when the anti-central government Democrats took possession of the Presidency in 1800, Jefferson maintained the Bank and Madison actively promoted it (due to the support of Albert Gallatin (the Secretary of the Treasury and a Democratic-Republican who had begun to learn the virtues of Federal activism in such matters as the Bank and Federally-funded public works). The Second Bank of the United States was established in an era of Democratic-Republican dominance, suggesting that the Bank of the United States had a rough political consensus between 1800-1832. Now, two caveats should be made – first, that the original bank was a public/private venture, and second, that the Bank was highly politically controversial, leading to thirty years of Jacksonian decentralized state banks – but the larger point remains that the Federal government of the Revolutionary Generation was not some libertarian paradise of limited government that left the economy to laissez faire.

 

The second half of the 19th century saw an enormous explosion of central banking. The Civil War gave us the Second Banking System, whereby the Republican Party, strong nationalists that they were, created for the first time a single, national, paper currency, a system of national banks with reserve requirements (held in Treasury securities), regulated by the Comptroller of the Currency.  When this system began to fail (largely due to the requirement to back all notes with Treasuries and the lack of a lender of last resort, as well as the restrictive monetary policy of the era), the Federal Reserve was called into being. However, what few people realize is that the public-private nature of the Fed was the result of a political bargain struck between conservative Republicans like Nelson Aldrich (who wanted a 100% private Fed), Progressives (who wanted a 100% public Fed), and conservative Democrats (who wanted a decentralized and private Fed).

This was not a single grand vision, but a messy compromise, and there remains in the history books, the vision of a Fed that might (and should) have been, a People’s Bank exercising political authority over the economy.

 

Where We Stand Today:

This brings us to our current dilemma. In the last twenty years, the so-called FIRE sector (finance, insurance, and real estate) of our economy has metastasized out of control – helped along by deregulation, regulatory capture, and refusal to establish new regulations to keep up with a changing industry. The vast increase in essentially paper value of derivatives, collateralized debt obligations (CDOs), mortgage-backed securities (MBSs), asset-backed securities (ABS), credit-default swaps, and other financial instruments have dramatically raised the stakes of a potential financial collapse, while making some Wall Street firms and their chief executives wealthy on a scale that puts the Gilded Age to shame. Rockefeller and Morgan were rich as they came, but they at least had the good sense to not order gold-flaked ice cream for dessert.

All of this would be merely troubling if the financial industry was merely off in its own little world making up imaginary money, if it wasn’t for the fact that the financial industry has begun to infect the rest of the economy with a dangerous instability. As Matt Taibbi’s piece on Goldman Sachs shows us, the financialization of the economy has had a predictable effect – with too much money chasing too few vehicles for investment, the financial sector begins to create speculative bubbles in new and untried areas of the economy. In the late 90s, they turned to the internet and tech stocks as their new bubble, because investors who might be wary of new and untried firms in something they understood, like steel or cars, promising massive and infinite returns didn’t know what this magical thing called the Internet might do – maybe their stocks really were worth their weight in solid gold. Then it was the housing bubble, where the massive profusion of new investment vehicles (MBSs, default swaps, etc.) and the deliberate compromising of ratings agencies were used to hide the on-the-ground reality (that money was being flung at mortgages on the expectation that home values would never fall, so it didn’t matter that people couldn’t afford their mortgages) behind the illusion that you could slice up debts into risk-free chunks, hedge yourself with insurance so that you couldn’t lose money, and that prices were only ever going to go up.  Even more recently, it’s been commodities futures, where speculators have been bidding up the price of oil and other basic commodities, leveraging the huge sums they now control to pump up prices in a fashion that Jay Gould would have approved of.

All this has huge consequences in the real economy – if you over-invest in internet and tech companies, you get the boom and bust in Silicon Valley, which made some people rich, left a lot of computer programmers and engineers high-and-dry, and somehow we’re still behind the rest of the advanced world when it comes to broadband. When you turn the housing industry from a way for people to buy homes into a gigantic casino/piggybank, then people can’t afford to live where they work, sprawl accelerates, net savings turn into massive net debt, and when it all goes belly up, we have huge foreclosure rates, ghost towns, millions of people’s homes “underwater,” homelessness, nosediving public revenues, and Depression-level unemployment in areas dependent on the real estate industry. When oil contracts are traded twenty times between production and sale, oil prices go up to $145 a barrel and $4-5 per gallon at the pump, the price of everything else (because we generally burn oil to transport goods) goes up, consumers’ purchasing power goes down, and the economy sours. You know things have gotten bad when we’re actually considering limiting speculation in oil.

And every time we try to fix the mess they made, the financial industry sticks a gun to its head and threatens to pull the trigger unless we give them trillions in public funds. So they make money when the bubble goes up, they make money when it goes down, and they make money when someone else is stuck with the cleanup. Meyer Lansky would be proud.

How Do We Get Out of Here?

Someone like Matt Taibbi can feel comfortable telling people there’s nothing we can do. It’s the journalist’s prerogative, well-honed since the days of H.L Mencken, to stand back and cynically chuckle as the world burns. But as an activist, I don’t feel that I can leave it at that. I think there are things that we can do, or at least try to do. A lot of ink and pixels have been spent talking about the need for new regulation, and I don’t really have much to add there for the moment.

But one idea that I do want to explore is to return to where we should have gone with American central banking – the idea of a public finance sector, a People’s Bank. In my imagination, the People’s Bank would focus on three key areas where we need an active, not-for-profit public presence:

  1. Secure Deposits, Open to All– despite the success of the FDIC in making people’s savings and checking accounts more secure than they used to be, the large numbers of bank failures in the recent crisis suggests that we have a need for something even safer than an FDIC-insured bank – a Federal bank where you can put your money without ever having to be afraid of losing it. However, I wouldn’t be a very good progressive if I didn’t extend this idea one further to explore a whole area of the “shadow financial sector” which really hurts people who don’t make enough money to be worried about losing it.
    1. Free Checking/Savings Accounts –  Twenty-eight million Americans don’t have either a checking or a savings account . Usually, this is because they don’t have enough money on hand to make it over the minimum required to open an account, or because they live so close to the line that they can’t wait three days for their paychecks to cover it, or because they’ve become overdrawn and hit with so many bank fees that they owe more than they can put in. Thus, the working poor are forced to turn to check-cashing companies who charge up to 391% interest for their services.  Simply by giving working people a way to put their money in a safe place, we would be increasing the net income of twenty-eight million working poor people by hundreds if not thousands of dollars a year.
  2. Availability of Basic Transactional Credit – in addition to being exploited when it comes to simply getting access to their own paychecks, many Americans, including the working poor but also comprising vast swathes of the working class, are also routinely victimized by their lack of access to basic transactional credit. Instead, they turn to  payday lenders, who charge up to 911% interest, and auto-title lenders who charge up to 300% interest. These companies, together with the check-cashers discussed above, collectively rake in $8.5 billion a year in fees. And if the financial crisis’ underbelly – the racial profiling of subprime loans revealed in the Wells Fargo lawsuit in Baltimore,  the abuse of so-called NINJA loans by middle-men, the ridiculous spectacle of the banks defeating cramdown legislation and watering down credit card interest rate reform – has shown us anything, it’s that the so-called legitimate finance industry isn’t so much better in how it deals with working and middle class Americans. Thus, the second basic function for the People’s Bank – one that I have to give credit to Matt Yglesias for linking to – is Steve Waldman’s suggestion that the government should provide “basic transactional credit as a public good…Every adult would be offered a Treasury Express card, which would have, say, a $1000 limit. Balances would be payable in full monthly. The only penalty for nonpayment would be denial of access of further credit, both by the government and by private creditors…Unpaid balances would be forgiven automatically after a period of five years. No interest would ever be charged.”
  3. Non-Profit Yardstick Home Lending –  in the wake of Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac, it would seem counter-intuitive to argue for a public institution to guarantee home loans. However, I would argue that the failure of those two institutions is more an argument against privatization – for decades, the two institutions worked well at what they were supposed to do, namely guarantee long-term loans; it was when they tried to chase the subprime money (which they came late to) that they went belly-up. So if we’re going to have an institution designed to make it easier and safer to buy mortgages, and as we just spent huge amounts of money rescuing these two institutions, let’s actually do the job right. In the wake of the failure to cramdown mortgages or otherwise deal with the foreclosure crisis, let’s have an institution that values homes correctly (one of the other market failures of the housing collapse was the corruption of home value assessors), that lends wisely, that provides long-term fixed rate mortgages to people who need primary residences…perhaps even using the returns on middle-class loans to make loans affordable to working people without creating crooked sub-prime practices.
  4. A Truly Public Fed – finally, and this would be the largest, most politically fraught, and most unlikely reform, we need to fold the Federal Reserve’s central banking powers into the People’s Bank. An institutional accommodation from 1912 left us with a central banking partly public and partly private, and we all know what happens to a house divided. I believe in central banking, and of the various political groups out there, I have the most contempt for the gold-standard loving Fed-abolishers. But the essence of central banking – controlling interest rates, managing the supply of money, acting as a lender of last resort, and regulating financial institutions – is an exercise in public authority over the economy. I would argue that much of the current lack of faith in the government’s attempt to reboot the financial system stems, among other things, from the hidden nature of the Fed’s operations, how the Federal Reserve as an institution has the singular authority to loan trillions of public funds without any democratic control, accountability, and virtually no oversight. (on a side note, I would also argue that the public-private nature of the Fed is why it for so long has focused on inflation over unemployment, as well as its habitual paranoia over wage growth) So if we’re going to have a central bank, as we should, let’s forgo the inane illusion of laissez-faire, and actually have a people’s bank.

AFSCME’s Making America Happen – Again

Check out the new video by AFSCME as part of their Make America Happen campaign. The video reminds us that we have overcome financial crisis before, and we can do it again.  It compared FDR’s solutions to the Great Depression with Obama’s plans to tackle our current economic crisis.  

As AFSCME President Gerald McEntee pointed out in his Huffington Post piece yesterday,

“President-elect Barack Obama’s call for bold action and civic engagement in response to our present crisis echoes FDR’s inspiring call to pull the nation out of the Great Depression and forge the New Deal. The video shows how our nation triumphed over economic crisis once before and can do so again by reinvesting in public service, providing health care for all Americans and growing the middle class.”

With a severe economic recession, an unemployment rate that reached 7.2 percent in December and continues to grow, and with more Americans falling into poverty, Americans are demanding action. Please sign our petition and make your voice heard.

The Make America Happen Campaign is dedicated to helping President-elect Obama revitalize our economy, provide health care for all, and strengthen the middle class. Our best days are still ahead of us.

http://www.afscme.org/makeamericahappen/

The Myth of Free Markets: Even Greenspan Sees the Light

Not unexpectedly, it required a major disaster to awaken former Federal Chairman, Alan Greenspan, to the long overdue reality that the free-market, free enterprise economic model fails to trickle down wealth to the poor and near poor but concentrates wealth at the top.

The free market model or Neoliberalism was developed by Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman at the Chicago School of Economics Chicago where it became an axiom that the private sector was the key to long-term economic stability.  Neoliberalism has gradually become the prevailing economic conventional wisdom in the United States and has been foisted on most countries through pressure from the United States or through the IMF and World Bank, America’s secret instrument of exploitation.

Simply stated, free-markets, a system with as little government interference as possible in the operation of market mechanisms, have been allowed to operate with increasing privatization and deregulation and a minimum of government transfers.  In theory, when free-market economics operates at peak efficiency, the so-called fabled “invisible hand”, coined by Adam Smith, was empowered to distribute wealth to all deserving citizens.  The theory of the “invisible hand” must be one of the most distorted ideas in the history of economics.  Adam Smith did not mean nor imply that people should be deserted by the government to fend for themselves but rather that all peoples’ needs must be met.

The deregulation of the banking system and the privatization of the Federal Reserve in 1913 are at the root of the current financial crisis and have paved the way for unfettered greed  to trigger the virtual collapse of that system.  The collapse spells the end of any credibility for the notion that by investing wealth at the top it will automatically reach the bottom.

Managing the money supply, interest rates, and exchange rates, or the monetary system, is a vital function in the economy and should serve the public interest in a democratic society.  Since it is privately owned, the Federal Reserve is almost entirely independent of the government consisting of twelve regional Federal Reserve Banks located in major U.S. cities in twelve regions and organized in a similar fashion to private banks whose shareholders consist of private banks in each district.

As well, funding for the Federal Reserve System is independent of the government and depends on interest earnings on its portfolio of investments.  Its decisions do not need to be ratified by either the president or Congress.

Instead of protecting consumers in recent years, the Federal Reserve has adopted policies that have supported large financial institutions in their frenzied, greedy pursuit of wealth ultimately pulling the rug out from under the economy.  While deregulated financial institutions were offering mortgages at initially low interest rates to high risk borrowers, the Federal Reserve was expanding the money supply and lowering interest rates to facilitate this feeding frenzy.  Eager homebuyers flocked to their nearest bank to borrow money at the ostensibly bargain basement interest rates and without the need to meet stiff credit requirements.  Mortgage-debt in 2000 was $4.8 trillion while in 2006 it rose to $9.3 trillion.  When borrowers began defaulting on their mortgages, banks that had used the mortgages as collateral to borrow for investments in other risky instruments were suddenly unable to meet their obligations.  The downward spiral into total collapse was well underway.

If the Federal Reserve had been a public institution, it might have implemented a different set of policies to avert the disastrous bubble that has now burst.

Another way in which the Federal Reserve has become complicit in the financial crisis is through its non-interventionist approach to the proliferation of very risky financial instruments known as derivatives.  With risky mortgages backing further risky, highly-leveraged investment in derivatives, the calamitous outcome was inevitable.

In addition, deregulating the financial system created the conditions which engendered the financial crisis by transforming commercial banks, whose primary purpose was to serve as a safe place for consumers to deposit their money, into investment institutions where risk-taking for profits was the central objective.  Now, consumers hard-earned money was now being deposited into apparently safe institutions when, in fact, it had indirectly become the source of funds for greedy investors who were willing to take risks to earn large profits.

Regulation of the banking system was solidified in the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 which prohibited a commercial bank from owning speculative financial institutions.  It imposed restrictions on the integration of banking, insurance and stock-trading companies to protect the consumer from losing their money through risky investments.

Since the 1980s, the banking and investment sector has been pressuring Congress to repeal the Glass-Steagall Act to afford them the opportunity to increase their profits by using depositor’s money to back risky investments.  Their efforts succeeded when Congress passed the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act in 1999 which repealed Glass-Steagall and allowed commercial bankers to underwrite and trade instruments of a highly risky nature.  It also lifted most restraints on the monopolization of the institutions in the financial sector of the economy.

To compound the problem of deregulating banks, Congress passed an amendment to an appropriations bill which deregulated derivatives.  Derivatives are an extremely risky investment which is highly leveraged.  Banks would now be free through their investment arm to risk depositors’ money in an investment that should be reserved for those who want to gamble large profits at the risk of large losses.

By deregulating the banking system, freeing derivatives from regulation, and creating a privately owned Federal Reserve System paved the way for the financial crisis which is not only destabilizing the American financial system but the global one as well.  Deregulation and privatization are two of the main pillars in the free market economic system and their failure is proof that the non-wealthy members of society are adversely affected.  In this case, it is clear that privatization and deregulation were not intended to benefit the non-oligarchical members of society but to create opportunities for large accumulations of wealth.  The only hope of ending the financial crisis and avoiding another one is to reform the system to protect all the people.

State of Darkness: US Genocides since 1945.

http://www.stateofdarkness.com

Bankrupting Education

The quality of education at the University of California (where I have been a graduate student since 2003) is plummeting.  I hear from my friends at the California State Universities that things are looking equally bad there, too.  Why are these proud institutions rapidly losing their reputation as world-class centers of learning?

Budget cuts.  Every year since 2003, the budget for the UC and the CSU have been slashed.  This year, it’s worse than ever.

While the university administration and Republicans in Sacramento can blame the financial crisis for the free-falling budget, make no mistake.

The budget for California education has not been slashed because of the 2008 bank mess.  The budget for education has been slashed because of the failed Republican ideology which says that all public money is “socialism.”

Well, like you, I really like my “socialist” libraries, highways, fire departments, and universities.  The anti-public Republican philosophy is bankrupt, and the damage from that philosophy is continuing to spread.  Over the past five years, I’ve watched as the GOP has gutted the University of California.

Yesterday, the UC President and UCSB Vice Chancellor were quoted saying that this year’s round of budget cuts will cause layoffs, more crowded class sizes, delays in classroom repairs and maintenance, and more.  These cuts will directly affect student education in addition to affecting the broader economy in the immediate term (fewer jobs in higher education means fewer Californians working) and in the long term (there will be less attraction for workers and creative entrepreneurs to move to California).

The UC President and others are blaming all of the painful budget cuts on the 2008 financial crisis.  Sure, the meltdown in banking and the recession is definitely having an effect.  But that can’t explain the budget cuts in 2003.  Or 2004.  Or 2005.  And 2006 and 2007 came when California’s economy was still relatively strong.  The main reason for budget cuts is the Republican philosophy of shrinking the public sector, no matter what.

Let’s not forget that California by itself has a bigger economy than many European nations.  And yet, the Republicans have made it so that that we can’t afford to fund higher education.

Michigan is an excellent counterexample.  Michigan’s economy has been in a recession pretty much non-stop for the last 30 years.  Despite Michigan’s terrible economy, this year the Democrats in Lansing passed a budget increase for Michigan’s public universities.  The reason for this is simple.  The only way to improve Michigan’s economy is by attracting more jobs, and today’s best jobs require more educated workers.  Leaders in Michigan, especially Governor Jennifer Granholm, understand this, and they’ve fought to make sure the ongoing economic recession doesn’t destroy Michigan’s universities.

Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger and the Republicans in Sacramento have different priorities.  The GOP leaders in Sacramento have stonewalled every single vote that included an increase in revenue.  Rather than allow a responsible budget, the Republicans have protected tax loopholes for yacht owners and big corporations.  They believe in trickle-down economics: if the wealthy are taxed less, then the economy will do better.

That bankrupt philosophy doesn’t work, and this year’s meltdown provides even more dramatic proof of how wrong trickle-down economics really is.  Removing ideologues from Sacramento is step one in saving the University of California.

The ongoing crisis in California’s schools shows once again that elections matter.  Fortunately there are some good candidates on the ballot this year who understand the need for responsible leadership.

On Crying Wolf, Or, Why I Don’t Want To Give You $700 Billion

As this is being written we are in the midst of the second day of testimony before Congress by Ben Bernanke and Henry Paulson in support of the Administration’s proposed financial rescue package.

The basic sales pitch is that the Nation’s financial problems are at this moment so severe that the only solution is to expose to risk $700 billion dollars of taxpayer money to buy assets with a currently unknown price…and to give the absolute and total power over what those valuations are, what should and should not be bought, what repayment terms will be sought-and additionally, what happens to any money recovered–to one man, Henry Paulson.

There are those who are not on board. They have critics, who continue to stress the dire consequences of inaction.

With all due respect to those critics…we have been down this road before with this Administration-and last time, they weren’t so big on telling the truth…or getting the job done effectively.

We’ll cover that ground, we’ll talk a bit about “mark to market” issues-and on a positive note, we’ll address the role of “warrants”, the negotiating power of Warren Buffett, and how the taxpayer could actually see substantial recoveries of money down the road.

So let’s start with the biggest elephant standing in the Plan’s way:

Weapons Of Mass Destruction.

This Administration flat-out lied to the American people to justify the current Iraq adventure. “Just trust us” was the basic message at the time, followed by “we absolutely know that Saddam is an imminent threat because of his Weapons Of Mass Destruction”, followed by “this will cost maybe $50, 60 billion…maybe as much as $200 billion”–which turned out to be possibly the worst estimate in the history of budgeting–followed by variations on The “I’m not the Commander-in Chief, General Petraeus is” Theme…followed by flag-draped caskets that the Administration still hides from public view.

All of this to find not one single operable WMD.

Now comes before us Federal Reserve Chairman Henry Paulson and Treasury Secretary Ben Bernanke, who tell us of imminent threat, who tell us to just trust them…who tell us that they are the most qualified people to understand the issues and take the appropriate action…and who, to top it off, must be left to the task unsupervised and uncontrolled, otherwise the plan will fail.

We are also being told that if we were just economically sophisticated enough we would understand why this plan must be put into place, and that our objections must be related to our economic ignorance.

To which I pose a question to the Joe Kernans of the world (well, one of them anyway): what if the public fully understands that the system is at risk…but we don’t trust the leadership?

(Ever watch “Sex And The City“? This would be the part where they would cut to Carrie’s laptop screen and we would see the words appear as she types them…)

…What if we think the Administration is lying?

I have heard so many lies from the President and his advisors that if Jesus Christ was Treasury Secretary and Mohammed (PBUH) was Chairman of the Federal Reserve I would have doubts about this proposal.

Back in March, Paulson (who, it turns out, is not a Deity) was telling us that “the worst is behind us“…meaning he either does not really understand what is going on here-or that somebody is trying to blow smoke up some unpleasant places, using Paulson as a sort of economic “General Petraeus” who is intended to divert attention from the real economic Commander-in-Chief.

So can this Administration be trusted to handle this without outside supervision?

“Trust, but verify”, Ronald Reagan used to say, and without outside oversight this proposal should be instantly dead on arrival to the Congress.

This might be the most critical issue surrounding this entire plan…and we must demand Congressional oversight. This is far too big a process for any single individual to manage-and too big for any single branch of Government, as well.

Go watch this satirical slap at Bernanke from a wannabe Bernanke.

It’s hilarious-and revealing.

That issue resolved, some economic education is in order:

What, you may ask, is “mark to market”?

Holders of assets are required, for accounting purposes, to report the value of those assets based on what they are worth at the current time. Normally you do this by seeing what “the market” thinks your asset is worth-something that is fairly easily done if the asset is, for example, your house.

On a larger, corporate scale, this marking to market each accounting period can cause the state of your company’s balance sheet to lurch around and gyrate from time to time-sometimes violently…which is the source of much complaint from corporate interests, but for the most part, it all works out. Recently, it has not.

The challenge in today’s economic environment is to figure out what an asset is worth when no market exists for that asset.

Banks are holding quibzillions © of dollars worth of paper that represent streams of mortgage payments that will continue for years into the future…but some unknown number of those mortgages will not be repaid.

The concerns about what can be repaid (or not) and who is holding how many of these “nonperforming” loans has caused virtually all the normal buyers of these kinds of assets to run away in fear, which is the simplest way to explain the “credit crunch” we hear so much about.

The Paulson proposal is based on you and I buying some portion of those assets, today, from the current holders and reselling the assets later. This will allow banks and other institutions to begin making loans, and will hopefully create the confidence needed to induce investors to again buy “pools” of those loans from those banks…after which, the lending cycle begins anew.

The hoped-for outcome, from the perspective of ordinary mortals such as you and I, is to minimize any losses to the taxpayer…or maybe, if we get lucky, generate a profit.

The hoped for outcome, for the current holders of these assets, is to minimize their loss.

So how do you decide what price the taxpayer will pay for these assets?

Picture, if you will, a $100 US Savings Bond. If you bought that bond today, it would cost you $50, and in 17 years the US Treasury will pay you $100, representing the interest income to you from that loan to the Treasury.

The “hold until original maturity” value of that bond is $100.

The “mark to market” value, if you’re “marking” it the day you bought it, is $50.

If you became convinced the Treasury might not pay back the loan, or all the interest, you might sell the bond for less than the original $50, just to recover something from the deal.

That process will work as long as someone else is willing to believe the bond will be repaid, and is willing to put up enough money on that bet to get you to sell.

If no buyer can be found, your bond’s value becomes either “unknown” or “zero”, your personal assets decline-and maybe, down the line, your credit score is affected by some small amount.

Picture that on a massive, quibzillion © dollar scale, and you can see what is happening in the mortgage market today-and to the investors, all over the world, that hold the debt from our collective mortgages.

When the Treasury prepares to buy a CDO or some other mortgaged-backed security from an investor in the near future, Paulson will have to decide, with no help from any market mechanism, if that paper is worth the “hold to maturity” value, zero, or somewhere in the middle…and he has no way to know if the pool of mortgages he’s buying with our money will be 100% repaid, 0% repaid, or something in between.

This issue will be one of the most contentious parts of the entire deal (and the most ripe for abuse…as it would be very easy indeed to reward friends and punish enemies in a system with no oversight), so watch carefully to see how it plays out.

Hint: when asked about this today, I heard Bernanke answer that he expected the Treasury to pay prices similar to what are seen “…in a more normal market…”.

Another satirical video: “Damn, it feels good to be a Banka”.

What’s a warrant?

It sounds all technical and tricky, but actually it’s not.

Warren Buffet invested $5 billion dollars this morning in Goldman Sachs, and as part of the deal he got the right to purchase up to $5 billion in Goldman Sachs stock, at a time in the future of his choosing, for $115 a share (roughly 43.5 million shares). That right is referred to as a warrant.

At this moment, the stock’s last trade was at $130.48. The difference between $115 and $130 is the current available profit to Buffett if he were to “execute” this warrant right now (which is just over $650 million profit in less than 12 hours)…but it’s not the maximum potential profit executing this warrant might bring.

In November of ’07 Goldman Sachs traded at $250 a share…and if Buffett is able to someday execute the warrant at that “strike price” (fancy technical term) the profit on his 43.5 million available shares would be $5.8 billion.

When we take assets from banks and other investors with depressed stock prices, we as taxpayers need to make the same deal Warren Buffet made-we need to demand warrants, and later, sell that stock back to the market, reducing the cost to the taxpayer over the long term…and maybe even making us actual profit….which could help to repay some national debt, perhaps?

There is precedent here. In the 1980’s the US did a bailout deal with Chrysler that involved issuing warrants…and the profit to the Treasury was substantial.

This is an additional huge part of the deal…and you can bet that there will be investor stockholder groups that will lobby-and lobby hard–to stop us from getting warrants.

We need to demand that we get our cut of the profit our tax dollars create…and to do that we need to get warrants as part of these deals…so bug your Member of Congress loudly and quickly on this one.

So, for the moment, let’s recap:

If the Administration wants to sell this plan they better acknowledge that it isn’t economic ignorance that’s the issue…that, instead, the problem is the basic element of distrust that they previously created by lying about matters of war and peace and Katrina…and if you want any plan at all, this is the issue you need to fix first.

Next, we need confidence that the prices paid for bad assets are not going to be excessive, we need oversight that allows us to be confident this isn’t another typical “reward and punish with taxpayer dollars” operation; and finally, we need to demand warrants, the tool that could make this something that turns the transactions, for a change, to the advantage of the taxpayer.

If we insist on these sorts of protections we have the chance to make this at least a fair deal for the taxpayer-and maybe even a good one. After all, if Warren Buffet can get good terms for a mere $5 billion investment…imagine the negotiating power $700 billion should be able to get us.

Even without the Priceline Negotiator, we should still demand the best deal possible…and if the currently frozen financial services industry doesn’t like that, perhaps they should borrow $700 billion somewhere else.

[poll id=”

226

“]