In a private caucus meeting, House Democrats said that they would not pass the Obama concession tax plan as it stands:
“In the caucus today, House Democrats supported a resolution to reject the Senate Republican tax provisions as currently written,” Ms. Pelosi said. “We will continue discussions with the president and our Democratic and Republican colleagues in the days ahead to improve the proposal before it comes to the House floor for a vote.”
The caucus vote, which is not necessarily binding, nonetheless put Ms. Pelosi in a rare direct conflict with the White House, which is pressing Congress to approve the tax cut proposal.
“House Democrats share the president’s commitment to providing the middle class with a tax cut to grow the economy and create jobs,” Ms. Pelosi said. “The House passed a bill last week to provide tax cuts for all Americans but not a bonus tax cut to millionaires and billionaires. The extra tax cut for the top 3 percent does not create jobs and increases the deficit. (New York Times)
As Chairman Burton pointed out, the “tax deal” was a giveaway to the Republican goals. It blocked attempt after attempt to balance out the funding, and instead handed billions of dollars to a tax cut bonus for the wealthiest in the country. But, this isn’t just a national blog, so there’s more to the story. The tax plan, as written, would have piled another $2.7 billion or so onto the California budget deficit next year because of the way the the estate tax is handled.
California has collected hardly any estate tax revenue for several years in the wake of the 2001 Bush tax law changes. Come 2011, absent any action on the federal level, the estate tax law would revert to 2001 law, in which case the state would gain $2.7 billion in revenues.
But the tax framework negotiated between President Barack Obama and Republicans appears to eliminate the mechanism that once provided estate tax revenues for states like California, according to the Tax Policy Center of the Brookings Institution and Urban Institute (hat tip to the Legislative Analyst’s Office for sending the link). That mechanism was phased out over the past few years, so the fact that it has again been eliminated was not entirely a surprise.(SacBee)
So instead of providing additional stimulus to the states to help us preserve education, public safety and other important day to day expenditures, the tax plan was to take away funds from the states? The estate tax is one of the most common sense items in our whole arcane tax structure. After all, America, as a nation, was founded on anti-dynastic principle. The development of a group of new oligarchic families should not be welcomed by even the most anti-government amongst us.
In the end, I think Speaker Pelosi might have even pulled some punches. The deal was a mess from the get go. While we took a beating on Nov. 2, we still control most of the levers of government. We don’t need to cede power just because John Boehner is coming. We’ll see what the next step is, and whether the Republicans are willing to really play for the nation’s interest or whether they stick to grandstanding.