(Cross-posted from Working Californians)
Today seemed like an appropriate time to release the second half of our presidential poll on the Republicans, given that all of them are attending the debate here. It is split into two polling memos from Mellman, our pollster. The first is on the horserace, post to come later on the issues. The summary says:
Our recent statewide poll shows Rudolph Giuliani currently sporting a 15-point lead in the California Republican primary. Despite Giuliani’s lead, however, the race is far from over. His advantage is based importantly, though not completely, on a malleable factor: the belief that he would be the strongest general election candidate. At present, John McCain, a popular second choice candidate, provides the only serious competition. Furthermore, if McCain were no longer running, his supporters would be more likely to move towards Giuliani, while Giuliani supporters are less likely to identify McCain as their second choice. While Giuliani is in a strong position, there is opportunity for other candidates to break through to California Republicans between now and February 5, 2008; the race is very much still up-for-grabs.
There is talk that unless McCain raises $20 million in the second quarter he will drop out. Our polling makes clear that Giuliani would benefit the most from that development. Considering the manner in which the Republicans allocate their delegates, even those who have lower numbers have an opportunity pick up a few in California.
Giuliani is nearly as well known as McCain and far better liked.
Giuliani not only has the highest overall favorables, but is also well liked by those who know him; his average favorability rating (a figure which takes into account both the direction and intensity of feeling) is 3.03, so that among those who know him, his average rating is just over “somewhat favorable.” Although Romney is less well known than McCain, he is better liked by those who know him (mean favorability of 2.75, compared to 2.70 for McCain). Neither candidate, however, is as popular as Giuliani among those who know them.
For now, Giuliani holds a strong lead, with McCain in second and Romney trailing. The Thompson in this case is Tommy. Obviously, if Fred gets into the race, it will shake these numbers up a bit.
Giuliani’s lead is greater (40%) among those paying very close attention to the primary, while Romney (11%) is actually slightly ahead of McCain (10%) in that attentive segment. Among those paying only somewhat close attention, Giuliani maintains a strong lead with 38% of the vote, while McCain’s support increases to 26%; Romney maintains his third place position at 12%. However, among voters who are not following the election closely, Giuliani’s support declines to 33%, McCain is at 21%, and Romney has just 5% of the vote. Nearly 3 in 10 (29%) voters not paying close attention are undecided.
The race shifts among voters who are familiar with all three top-tier candidates. Among these voters, Giuliani’s support holds steady at 36%, while McCain’s total drops to 15% and Romney’s support jumps to second place with 17%; just 14% of these most knowledgeable voters are undecided. This suggests that part of Senator McCain’s support is based on his higher name recognition, an advantage that could disappear as primary day approaches.
Other highlights from the poll: Giuliani’s support is strongest among Californians highly concerned about national security and iraq. McCain does relatively well among voters concerned about health care. Republican primary voters now believe Giuliani has the best chance to win the general. Giuliani and McCain are equally popular second choice candidates.
Much, much more in the full pollster memo on the .