Tag Archives: consultants

A Tale of One City: How Democrats with Good Data Beat the Odds

(While they won’t replace good old-fashioned shoe leather, tools matter. – promoted by Brian Leubitz)

Consultants in California and everywhere would like us to believe that the money game is everything. But something seems to be changing. On November 3rd of this year, a loose coalition of progressive groups won a tremendous set of victories in a small California city despite getting outspent by a factor of more than 20. This could be what California democracy would look like if it was built on a person to person foundation. The following is a first-person account from Hillary Blackerby, Secretary of the local Democratic Party organization, who asked me to post it (full discolsure, this post says nice things about California VoterConnect):

The City of Santa Barbara on California’s Central Coast is one of those silly places that still has its city elections in November of odd years. Our city ballot this year consisted of a mayor’s seat, 3 city council seats and 4 ballot measures. Two of the five mayoral candidates were current sitting councilmembers with time left in their terms, so if one of them were to win the mayor’s seat, the 4th highest vote getter in the council race would get a 2 year term to finish out the mayor’s council term. There were thirteen candidates for city council.

Progressive organizations with ground forces that were activated for the campaign included…  

…the Santa Barbara Democratic County Central Committee (county party central committees are the local organizations that together comprise the state party), the Democratic Service Club (which is a club chartered under the county committee), and a local social justice focused community based organization, PUEBLO (People United for Economic Justice Building Leadership through Organizing), that has strong roots in the Latino community. The Democratic organizations and PUEBLO share in Santa Barbara’s culture of locally-directed, person to person organizing, which has been growing stronger particularly due to large influxes of volunteers after the 2000 and 2002 elections, as well as by connecting with volunteers activated for Obama last year. The total campaign spending by the local Democratic Party was less than $30k.

The most important ballot measure was Measure B, which proposed a draconian building height limit of 40 feet in the downtown area, thereby diminishing the hope of a vibrant and sustainable downtown core where people could live near where they work, shop and play. This measure also threatened our ability to provide affordable and workforce housing, and would inevitably encourage sprawl into our ecologically sensitive surroundings, like the precious Gaviota coast. Our special kind of NIMBY (Not In My Backyard) here in Santa Barbara (both of Republican and Democratic stripes) was incredulous that anyone would oppose this measure. The political establishment in the town predicted that Measure B would be the defining issue of the campaign, and nearly all of the candidates lined up in favor of it or stayed neutral. The county Democratic Party allied itself with affordable housing advocates and environmentalists and took a strong “vote NO” position on Measure B.

Enter the opposition: We learned in late September that Texas Republican and billionaire developer and owner of First Texas Homes, Randall Van Wolfswinkel, was planning to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on this race. Van Wolfswinkel had started a PAC based in Los Angeles called “Preserve Our Santa Barbara” (POSB) and had selected a conservative slate of 3 city council candidates and a mayoral candidate to support both through independent expenditure and direct donations to the council candidates. He also essentially singlehandedly funded the campaign for Yes on Measure B, and ended up spending over $700,000 on this race.

This was done through television, radio, web banner ads, newspaper ads, and a deluge of mail. In one 9 day period during the election, city voters received 10 pieces of mail from his PAC alone, most of them being hit pieces against 2 of the mayoral candidates (Helene Schneider and Steve Cushman) and 2 of the Democratic council candidates (Bendy White and incumbent Grant House). The tactics for negative campaigning POSB used focused on NIMBY baiting, including making the claim that skyscrapers would spring up on our city streets (our city charter already has a 60 foot/4 story limit.) They focused on race baiting about gang and youth violence, with pictures of graffiti on brick walls (definitely from istockphoto, not pictures in SB.) These problems have increased somewhat over the last few years, but largely due to cuts in services and the increasingly bleak and unequal state economy, a problem that further limiting affordable housing would hardly improve. POSB also railed against public employees and their supposedly bloated salaries and the misplaced priorities of the current mayor and council. The TV ads used the rhetoric of “they’re on our side” and admonished voters to “save our community.” We wondered: “From who exactly?” Santa Barbara is about 35% Latino and fairly segregated; the racial undertones and dogwhistles of these ads seemed clear to progressives.

This election was Santa Barbara’s first all mail-in ballot election, and we knew we’d have to evolve our GOTV tactics to think in terms of election month, not election day, even more than we had been already due to increasing numbers of permanent vote-by-mail voters. We started with voter roll data provided via California VoterConnect‘s VAN (VAN is the Voter Activation Network, the same software that the DNC and Obama for America deployed nationally in 2008), which we used to run lists for door to door contacts. Our data included vote history from the last statewide elections, as well as the local 2007 city council election, which helped us understand turnout the last time there were only city issues on the ballot. Our focus was on Democratic households, as Democrats enjoy a significant registration advantage in the City of Santa Barbara. Ballots arrived in mailboxes Monday and Tuesday October 5th and 6th. The weekends prior and following the ballot arrival days, the Democratic Party sent volunteers out to go door to door with labeled lit pieces with our party-endorsed candidates and voter information to about 15,000 targeted Dem households in the city.

We planned two early direct mail pieces to Democrats- one prior to the ballots arriving, and one in the first week of voting. In the first 3 weeks after ballots hit mailboxes, the rate of return into the city clerk’s office was abysmal. Republicans are a small percentage of the electorate, but they were voting in much higher percentages than Dems in those weeks. At one point we were seeing around 50% turnout from people over 65, while fewer than 200 registered voters under 25 had cast ballots. The turnout started to pick up in the last week before the election, with 1,100 to 1,500 ballots arriving daily. The city registrar was releasing updated lists of voters whose ballots had been received, so when it was time for GOTV weekend, we had uploaded the most recent list of people who had already voted (the VAN makes this easy), and purged them from our list of targeted voters.

For the knocking and talking phase of the field operation, we cut precinct-based walk lists with the VAN’s nifty turf cutting/mapping tool, dividing precincts up into manageable turfs for volunteers (about 3 or 4 turfs per precinct, with approximately 100 doors per turf). We knocked and talked every Saturday and Sunday beginning on August 30th on through the election. These turfs would later shrink to a 50-60 door size by GOTV weekend as some of our targeted voters had mailed in their ballots. We augmented this door to door effort with aggressive phonebanking with the stellar and affordable Callfire autodialer system. Our phonebanking operation consisted of calling Democratic voters beginning in the last week of August for 3 days a week (Tuesday-Thursday), with about a dozen volunteers calling with the Callfire system from their homes at different times of the week.

Not everything went smoothly, however. The campaigns of the endorsed Democrats (all sharing the same consultant and staff) did not do a single phonebank, and they were without access to data for the final month of the campaign due to their inability to fill out the small amount of paperwork required by the vendor. The consultant also wouldn’t allow the campaigns’ paid field staff or recruited volunteers to walk the party full slate literature (even though all their candidates were the same) because it contained a No on Measure B position, which the conventional wisdom (as propagated by the consultant) said would hurt his candidates. This led to the needless and stubborn duplication of efforts, reinvention of a few wheels, and in certain instances, even the subversion of the wishes of one of the candidates who personally opposed Measure B.

This issue raises serious questions about the role of consultants and campaigns in areas with strong democratic progressive infrastructure. We need better mechanisms to prevent unscrupulous consultants from taking advantage of volunteer time and energy that organizers have built up over years of work, and better ways to hold candidates accountable. One clear path is to strengthen the candidate pipeline from the grassroots upwards. Experience has shown that candidates with origins in the grassroots will be less likely to ignore or turn on the grassroots as they are elected to local and higher office.

The final weekend GOTV phone operation consisted of calling some 3,000 identified supporters using Callfire, as well as from some paper lists due to the small number of computers and large numbers of volunteers. The two main election day field operations were run by the county Democratic Party and by PUEBLO, both using lists from the VAN. There were 7 ballot drop off locations throughout the city. This is a drastic reduction from the number of polling places that are normally open around the city when the election isn’t all mail-in ballots. They were open on Saturday October 31st, from 8am to 5pm, and again on Tuesday November 3rd, from 7am to 8pm.

When volunteers spoke to voters on the phone or at their doors, many assumed they could go to their usual polling place- not so. They appreciated finding out where they could go drop off their ballots, or if they had lost or never received the ballot by mail, that they could go to the drop off site and vote on a provisional ballot. Many people never received their ballots because either they had registered before the registration deadline but after the city had sent the list to the mailhouse to send the ballots to (yes they really did that). There were also reported instances of people in apartment and condo complexes seeing a USPS mail bin full of all the ballots for the entire complex sitting beneath the bank of mailboxes, much like the 3rd class junkmail that we get every week.

Election day volunteers did an early morning lit drop with bilingual info for voters about where to drop off their ballots, and with a list of our Democratic Party endorsed candidates and ballot measure positions. They later rewalked the turf in the middle of the day, hitting the homes of people who still had not voted as of the last pass. Volunteers were out in the neighborhoods until the polls closed at 8pm, and phonebankers called through the turfs pulling folks out in the last 2 hours and telling them where they can drop their ballots.

By midday Monday November 2nd, turnout was at 37%, which was the total turnout for the 2007 city elections. By the end of Tuesday November 3rd, total turnout was 49.5%. The GOTV field efforts by the progressive forces pushed turnout in one day up by over 12 percent. In a city of about 90,000 people, where there are 46,718 registered voters, there were 23,167 ballots cast in an off-cycle election year. We beat back the assault on social justice that was Measure B, won the mayor’s race and elected two of our three Democratic Party endorsed city council candidates. Dozens of volunteers on election day made the difference by going back again and again to the folks who still hadn’t voted.

Perhaps the most dramatic shift from pre-election day results to November 3rd results was the comparative result for No on Measure B, which received 62% of the Election Day votes, up from 51% of the pre-Election Day votes. The Texas billionaire spent more than $700,000. The Democratic Party spent less than $30,000. Nothing beats a solid field campaign: not even getting outspent by more than 23 to 1.

Last week, every city voter received another glossy mailer in their boxes. It was Randall Van Wolfswinkel thanking them, and letting us know that he will indeed be back. And when he comes back, we will be ready with our clipboards, volunteers, and shoe leather…and our databases.

Hillary Blackerby is the secretary of the Santa Barbara County Democratic Party Central Committee.

Ah, Mr. Republican Insider Finally Lost It

I’m not sure where to even being rebutting this post, which is a rich combination of paranoia and grandiosity that would make your hero Art Pedroza proud. […]
Andrew, if you really want to see a “noise machine” all you need to do is read your own posts: loaded with straw men, unsupported assumptions, jumped-to-conclusions, screechy rhetoric and paranoia.

Hey, looky here! Jubal/Matt Cunningham responded to my post, which was a response to Jubal/Matt’s response to Art Pedroza’s original “Chismes” post on Orange Juice that caused the entire Orange County Republican Party to explode. Ain’t it amazing how these supposedly omnipotent Republican insiders are shaking at the boots at the thought that their ridiculous scheme to allow someone who ran one of the most racist campaigns in Orange County history to run their “voter registration program” in minority-majority Central County is being exposed? And that the sheer stupidity of this plan of theirs is now out in the open, for all to see?

So why is Jubal/Matt still fuming over this? Well, he completely lost control. And why is he so angry about that? Well, I’ll tell you all about it after the flip…

So what’s the problem here? Well, the Republican Party’s master cyberspace spinner has lost control of the message. He tried so hard to save the OC GOP’s latest blunder from becoming a massive train wreck…

Smart move. There’s no shortage and wannabees and armchair consultants in OC politics. What there aren’t a lot of are campaign operatives with proven track records of success — especially in central Orange County. The OC GOP would have been remiss to pass up utilizing someone who’d been toiling in the central OC vineyards for the past year running very successful voter contact program. Saulo ran the most successful aspect of the Lynn Daucher campaign (the absentee ballot program), and then managed Trung Nguyen — who nearly everyone expected to do no better than third or fourth — to within 3 votes of victory in the 1st Supervisor District special election.

… But all that hard work and fast spinning of Jubal’s couldn’t save his party from the ultimate reality on the ground.

It looks like the first installment of this new column was quite a hit. The O.C. Register’s Total Buzz blog covered our chisme regarding the guy tabbed by the OC GOP to register new voters in central Orange County. That would be Saulo Londono, the campaign manager who sent Trung Nguyen to the border to stop the Mexicans. I’m sure that will go down real swell with the people of Santa Ana!

I love what Londono had to say about the story, over at the Total Buzz, “Although the blogs are heavily dramatizing the situation, the real reason for being quiet (about the new job) is quite simple: strategy.” Sure – great strategy. Maybe they can get Lupe Moreno and Tan Nguyen to help register new Reep voters too!

Red County/OC Blog stepped up to defend Londono, predictably. Matt Cunningham/Jubal referred to Londono’s successful track record. Last time I looked he LOST the last two campaigns he headed up. Maybe second place means first place in Jubal’s book?

Jubal is angry because Jubal can no longer control the message. In the bad old days, when OC Blog was really the only big kid in Orange County’s political blogosphere, Jubal/Matt can simply get the good word out on his clients and control what was said about them online. And since OC Blog was really the only big source for what was happening in OC’s political scene, everyone would just believe what Jubal and his minions were saying…

However, this isn’t the case any longer. Orange Juice now offers different perspectives on what’s happening throughout the county. The Liberal OC now offers a progressive point of view to counter the right-wing spin at OC Blog-land. And yes, now I’ve become a thorn on Jubal’s side as well. Basically, Jubal’s not the sole star of the show any more. The new kids on the block are finally growing up, and speaking out.

I guess this is the real issue here. Now it certainly is important in and of itself that the OC Republicans are hiring someone who was part of a VERY RACIST CAMPAIGN to head a minority outreach and voter registration program in Central OC. However, another major issue has entered into the fray. The Orange County Republican elite is no longer in control of what we say and what we think online. Competition has arrived, yet the supposed “champions of the free market” don’t seem to like the free flow of ideas and opinions.

Too bad for them. ‘Cuz this new diversity of thought is really letting some fresh air rush in behind the Orange Curtain. ; )

Republican Insiders See Us As “Punks With Computers”

(Oh yeah, and before I forget… Horray for Orange Juice! They’ve been so courageous during this whole time in standing fast against efforts by the Orange County Republican Party to censor them. I only wish I had the tenacity of Art Pedroza, Claudio Gallegos, and the entire O-J Team! : ) – promoted by atdleft)

A long time ago I was told that in this business you are judged by your enemies. If your enemies are mostly democrats then you must be doing something right. They’re willing to tear you down, especially people like Andrew Davey who posted on the Calitics page. He’s just a punk with a computer.

That was former campaign manager for Republican Alan Uke in the 50th Congressional District, campaign manager for Republican Lynn Daucher in SD 34, and all-around insider in the Orange County Republican Party, Bryan Lanza… Speaking about little ol’ me. So why is the OC GOP political elite suddenly wailing over me at Red County/OC Blog? Follow me after the flip to find out…

Remember when I called out the Orange County Republicans for blaming Orange Juice blogger Art Pedroza for their own problems with Latino voters? Well, Jubal/Matt Cunningham found out about it… And he’s not very happy with me right now for shining some light on the OC GOP’s ridiculous decision to hire someone who was part of Trung Nguyen’s virulently anti-immigrant and anti-Latino campaign to head a voter outreach and registration effort in Latino-heavy Central County. So what is he doing about it? Oh, he’s just resorting to bashing ALL OF US who have the nerve to call out the OC GOP on their great mistake.

Of course, there are the inevitable detractors. ex-Republican Art Pedroza thinks it is bad idea because Trung Nguyen posed in front of the border fence for one of his mailers. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Let’s not hire the guy with the proven track record of success because of a mail piece (which Art terms “anti-Latino,” which I suppose it is if you look at it through MeCHista-colored glasses). And Saulo committed the cardinal sin of being a staffer for Assemblyman Van Tran, a stain not even Saulo’s previous stint with Lynn Daucher, the previous object of Art’s political affections, could wipe away. Too bad anti-Van Tran prejudices obscure the ability to render a fair estimation of Saulo’s talent and experience. And here’s some fan mail for Art’s post and Claudio Gallegos hyperventilation-disguised-as-a post/All-Republicans-Look-Alike-To-Me rant from local lefty Andrew Davey. It should speak volumes when the attaboys for attacking Saulo are coming from the Left Wing.

Oh, joy! So now I REALLY KNOW what these GOP insiders think of not just me, but of bloggers in general. We are supposed to be their tools, their mouthpieces, their vehicles to spread their propaganda… Kinda like what Jubal/Matt Cunningham and his buddies do all the time at OC Blog. And when we’re not doing a good little job of spreading the Orange County Republican Party’s propaganda, we’re just worthless “punks with computers”. Never mind that most of us bloggers consider ourselves to be independently minded individuals who are not beholden to ANYONE. In fact, I thought that the real goal of political bloggers is to take on the establishment. I didn’t know that we were supposed to be PAID SPINNERS FOR IT.

I guess this just reveals the true dilemma with Republicans and blogging. The blogosphere is meant to be a force of nature, something that no one can control or should control. Bloggers have minds of their owns, and they shouldn’t be forced or bribed into promoting someone else’s agenda. However, Republicans don’t seem to understand that. They think they can control what we say and do in the blogosphere. And when they fail in trying to dominate us, they whine and scream about our petulant, “punkish” behavior. My goodness, no wonder why Art Pedroza left the Republican Party. I complain when Jubal/Matt tries to rough me up every so often, but what if I had to deal with this all the time, and from someone who’s supposed to be my comrade in arms? No wonder why Art could not take any more of their disgusting consultant-driven, insider-incestuous, corruption-fueled extreme right-wing noise machine.

To them, we’re just “punks with computers”… Who are threatening their entire power structure.

CA-42: The “Red County” GOP Machine Stands By Its Man

(Cross-posted at Trash Dirty Gary, Southern California’s resource for revealing Gary Miller’s true record of disservice to his constituents… AND a place for action in restoring honor and integrity to the 42nd Congressional District – promoted by atdleft)

I hope the Dems spend huge sums of money trying to defeat Congressman Miller.

Given the demographics of the district as well as Mr. Miller’s ability to self fund any defensive campaign which might be required, I can’t think of a better way for them to waste their resources.

So why is “One Who Knows” getting all worked up on GOP insider hangout Red County/OC Blog about a challenge to Dirty Gary Miller in the 42nd Congressional District? Oh, only because the DCCC is actually turning up the heat on Dirty Gary. Oh my, real democracy is such a “waste of resources”… But wait! It gets better!

(And I’ll tell you all about it after the flip…)

Here’s what OC Blog’s sister “Red County” San Bernardino blog has to say about the DCCC online ad:

The YouTube or MySpace quality web ad is noticeable edited and nowhere near the professional standards of any relevant political media consultant or producer.  At this point we may be witnessing the cheep work of a DCCC or DNC college intern that barley knows how to use his Apple Final Cut Pro. See the web ad here.

OK, so this “Republican kewl kid” who can’t even use Spellcheck is criticizing the DCCC for the quality of the online ad? And again, why all the moaning and groaning over the possibility of a REAL EXERCISE IN DEMOCRACY TO HOLD A VERY CORRUPT CONGRESSMAN ACCOUNTABLE?

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again:

Neither Democrats, nor Republicans, nor Independents, appreciate a member of Congress who is being investigated by the FBI for his questionable land deals. Voters do not like someone who misuses his position of power to enrich himself while ignoring the best interest of the people in the district. Simply put, the more the people here find out about Gary Miller and his very dirty ways, the less they can tolerate it.

This is not political harassment. And it’s not wasting time. It’s democracy. And it’s about time that Gary Miller and his pals realize that.

Now when will people remember this? I really don’t like repeating myself. ; )

We’re Voting on February 5… And Our Opportunity Has Just Arrived!

This just in from The OC Register:

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger today moved California’s presidential primary from June to February, giving the nation’s most populous state a greater stake in selecting nominees and shaking up the 2008 political calendar.

“Now California is important again in presidential nominating politics … and we will get the respect that California deserves,” Schwarzenegger said during a bill-signing ceremony.

Hopefully, all of us will now use this opportunity to truly SHAKE THINGS UP. Now that California voters will now be “The Deciders” in who gets the party nomination, let’s get out there and tell our family, friends, and neighbors why their votes matter. I know I’m excited about the change, and I’ll explain to you why I’m so excited after the flip…

For far too long, California has been left out of the national conversation. And especially as Democrats, we have not had the chance to let our voices be heard on issues that we care about. We have not been able to speak out, as the candidates have asked for our money but not for our opinions. Perhaps it’s time that the party and the candidates appreciate us for more than just our money. And come to think of it, the Democratic Party would most certainly benefit if they let California Democrats have their say on these issues.

So why not allow us to let our voices be heard on Iraq, health care, climate change, transportation, land use, water use, and other important issues? After all, these are not just California issues… These are national issues, as well! Why not open up the primary process to some real diversity? What’s so bad about shaking up the process, and allowing a big urban state like California, with big issues to tackle and big dreams to share, to have a say alongside the small rural states? Why not let ALL OUR VIEWS be heard?

And for all those who are worried about an early California primary meaning the “end of democracy”, I have this to say: Why not take advantage of this real chance to revitalize the California Democratic Party? I am hoping that we in the progressive movement here will take this unique opportunity to breathe some new life into the Democratic Party here, as well as to get our neighbors excited about voting again. There’s nothing like telling someone that his or her vote really matters… And now that our primary will be early and important, ALL OF OUR VOTES REALLY DO MATTER AGAIN!

We can continue to bitch and moan and whine and complain about everything that’s wrong right now, and just see more of the same…
Or we can get up and take action to change this! If we really care about building a grassroots movement here, then why don’t we use this primary as a way to start growing it? If we’re so concerned about the “media ad buys” and all the consultants, then why don’t we get out there ans start growing some real grassroots? No, the candidates cannot meet all of the voters in California… BUT ALL OF US WORKING TOGETHER CAN! If we don’t like the status quo, then why do we keep whining about it? Why not just get out there and CHANGE IT?!

The opportunity is now here… We just have to get off our duffs and TAKE IT! : )

The Surreal Politics of Orange County: Republican Consultants Need a Wake-up Call

I was lurking OC Blog/Red County (the Orange County hangout for Republican insiders and consultants) yesterday and found this doozie by GOP consultant Jubal/Matt Cunningham. Basically, it’s a rebuke of Nicole Rivera’s recent post on the California Progress Report about the resurgence of Orange County Democrats. Now Jubal would like to think that it’s Nicole who needs a “tutoring in reality”, but I must beg to differ. If anything, Jubal and his GOP consultant friends need to wake up and smell the coffee:
Their party is falling apart in Central Orange County while we’re getting our act together!

Would you like to see how OC Blog is wrong in its slam of OC Democrats? And is OC forever doomed to be “Red County”? Well, follow me after the flip to find out…

Jubal’s post is a pretty standard display of OC GOP hubris, but he certainly drops some nasty rants in there:

Let me get this straight. The OC GOP virtually wipes out the Democrats voter registration edge in the 34th Senate District in less than a year and then comes within an eyelash of ending 8 years of Democratic control with by nominating a white lady from Brea who out-worked the Dems. And this is a sign of a Democratic tide?

No, Jubal, let me get this straight! Yes, we shirked our responsibility by ignoring the threat you guys were posing in the 34th Senate District until last year. However we get back in the game by getting involved in the community again, and by genuinely connecting with voters. Oh yeah, and we turned that registration “wipe out” into a 2.5% registration edge!

Oh, and shouldn’t we remember that despite going against the GOP machine’s “bounty hunting” in Central Orange County, endless Republican “dirty tricks”, and numerous problems on Election Day, LOU STILL WON!

Now I don’t know about Jubal, but I wouldn’t call that “Republican strength”…
And speaking of Republican strength:

Let’s see: the 68th AD is 45% GOP to 31% Dem. The 70th AD is 48% GOP to 28% Dem, and the 35th SD is 48% GOP to 28.5% Democrat. In other words, the GOP registration advantage in those districts is 14 points.

Yes, and the Democratic advantage in the 47th Congressional District is only about 5.5%, yet Loretta Sanchez won reelection with over 60% of the vote! However with a much greater registration edge in their respective Assembly Districts, Assemblymembers Van Tran (68th) and Chuck Devore (70th) barely even got 60% of the vote! And as for the 35th Senate District, it isn’t as conservative as Jubal and other GOPers would really like it to be.

So basically, I don’t think Jubal should have to worry about us needing “tutoring in reality”. If anything, he should worry about his own party needing a wake-up call!

(Cross-posted at the California Progress Report)

[poll id=”

62

“]