Tag Archives: lobbying

Was Sen. Rubio Auditioning For Job at Chevron?

Chevwrong

The power of the petroleum industry in California may be unparalleled in the states. Its lobbying machine is stupendously successful.  For instance, California remains the only significant oil producer that does not tax oil extracted in the state. It has very weak–perhaps the weakest–regulation of oil and gas extraction, particularly hydraulic fracturing of deep deposits, known as “fracking.” State environmental laws are under constant attack.

State Sen. Michael Rubio, a Central Valley Democrat elected to his seat in 2010, was in an ideal spot to show whose side he was on in these fights.

Rubio, who resigned from the Senate Feb. 22 to work for Chevron as its chief California lobbyist, was chair of the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, which oversees oil industry environmental issues. In 2011-12, he was a key Democrat on the Senate’s energy committee.

His most recent official action was an inaction: He was scheduled to co-chair his committee’s hearing on fracking with Sen. Fran Pavley. The hearing took place, airing widespread frustration with the weakness and loopholes of current and proposed state regulation of fracking. Rubio, however, was a no-show.

It’s obvious now that on Feb. 12 he was getting ready to jump ship to Chevron, and likely in no mood to hear citizen fears about water pollution, spoiled land and even fracking-induced earthquakes. But Rubio did, in his short tenure, leave a record that Chevron was surely tracking with admiration.

In hindisght, his biggest moment in the spotlight would have been his months-long campaigning on behalf of a corporate effort to weaken the California Environmental Quality Act. The changes would have particularly benefited the oil, energy and property development industries. The proposals didn’t become law, but they’re not dead yet. Rubio will just be working them from the other side of the fence.

Judy DuganIn May 2012, Rubio also cast the deciding “no” vote against a bill (SB 1054) by Sen. Pavley that would have merely required oil companies to notify residents and businesses nearby in advance of fracking activities. The bill, vociferously opposed by the Western States Petroleum Assn. and other oil lobbyists, failed. Industry opponents of the bill recognized Rubio for his role in leading the opposition that killed a bill with wide public support.

Rubio also supported, and may have encouraged, the governor’s firing of two state energy regulators in 2011 after oil lobby complaints about their tightening of oversight.

(Oil and energy weren’t the only supporters he was courting. Rubio also championed the profits of Blue Cross over the pocketbooks of customers. He withheld his vote in 2011 from a measure that would have allowed the state insurance commissioner to reject health insurance rate increases that could not be justified. In the state Legislature, an abstention from voting is effectively a “no” vote, but with no accountability. It’s the coward’s way out. )

Chevron certainly knows what it’s getting with this new top lobbyist.

Rubio stated that he was leaving his elected post two years early to spend more time with his family, including a disabled child. No matter how much that weighed in his decision, the fact remains that his status as a state senator (however briefly) greatly inreased his value to Chevron. His pay will grow by multples. Because there is no law against such a quick trip through the revolving door–from overseeing an industry to lobbying for it–Rubio could be schmoozing his fellow legislators right now, and spreading money to their campaigns. His constituents, meanwhile, are stuck with no representation until a special election that’s perhaps months away.

_________________________________________________________________

Posted by Judy Dugan, former research director for Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to providing an effective voice for taxpayers and consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Visit us on Facebook and Twitter.

Insurance Industry’s Two-Faced Battle Against Patients

Health insurance companies apparently have no problem taking opposite sides of an issue when it serves their bottom line. When it comes to California law, they hate regulation and will spend any amount of money and credibility to kill it. But when it comes to protecting the profits of insurance brokers at the expense of consumers, insurance companies say (approvingly) that effective state regulation will protect consumers from premium increases. Both positions are public record, but health insurance companies apparently figured no one would ever notice.

Health insurance companies apparently have no problem taking opposite sides of an issue when it serves their bottom line. When it comes to California law, they hate regulation and will spend any amount of money and credibility to kill it. But when it comes to protecting the profits of insurance brokers at the expense of consumers, insurance companies say (approvingly) that effective state regulation will protect consumers from premium increases. Both positions are public record, but health insurance companies apparently figured no one would ever notice.

The California battle is highly public. The state is the biggest health insurance market in the nation and one of the least-regulated. So it’s no wonder tht the insurance industry is fighting a tooth-and-nail battle against state regulation that would protect consumers from premium increases of up to 86% in 12 months–as Blue Shield tried to impose in the last year. The insurance companies have clubbed doctors into submission, threatening to cut their reimbursement if decent regulation starts to squeeze record health insurance profits. They have also poured money into political contributions to key legislators, according to an Associated Press story this week.

The bill, AB 52 by Assemblyman Mike Feuer, has passed the state Assembly and is up for a vote today (Wednesday) in a key state Senate committee. Here’s a safe bet: Even if it passes and goes to the full Senate, insurers will twist every arm and make every threat to get the bill killed–or more likely, crippled by hostile amendments that would hogtie the state Insurance Commissioner.

The other side of the insurance company mouth is buried in the proceedings of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, where only geeks go to read. Right now the organization is under pressure to back a legislative proposal in Congress that would kill a key consumer protection in the federal health reform. The bill, HR 1206 by Michigan Republican Mike Rogers, would allow insurance companies to pay brokers and agents without counting the payments as an overhead expense. This would trash the reform requirements that insurance companies spend more on health care, holding overhead and profits to 15% or 20% of insurance premiums. If they don’t have to count broker pay as overhead, health insurers wouldn’t have to lift a finger to become more efficient.

Of course, we consumer advocates have argued that if the Rogers bill passes, insurance companies will have a free pass to raise premiums.

The health insurance lobby’s response? Oh, that won’t happen because consumers are well-protected by state insurance regulations!

From a June 2 letter (see last page) by America’s Health Insurance Plans to the NAIC:

“Finally, we wish to comment on a concern we have heard that deserves a response. One commentator has expressed the concern, and assumption, that if commissions are removed from the MLR calculation, then insurers will only increase their premiums – leading to great harm to consumers. We believe this flawed assumption fails to recognize the standard of rate review prevalent in the states. Exempting commissions from the MLR calculation does not pull them from the rates, and certainly does not stimulate insurers to inflate their rates. And states are increasingly focused on assuring value for consumers in their rate review, in accordance with the ACA, making such an assertion even more unlikely.”

If states want to “assure value” in health insurance, they certainly do have to review and regulate rates, and that includes the power to approve or reject rates before they go into effect. Such prior approval is now “prevalent” in the majority of states–though not in California.

When a corporate lobby is as powerful as the health insurance industry’s, it apparently doesn’t have to worry about being consistent.

I hope state legislators weighing the California bill have a grip on how two-faced the industry deliberately is. At least the industry has admitted that regulation is the only barrier between consumers and the next flood of premium increases.

—————-

Posted by Judy Dugan, research director for Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to providing an effective voice for taxpayers and consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Visit us on Facebook and Twitter.

Arnold Achieves ‘Post Partisanship’ With Uniform Disapproval In New Poll

The quote of the week goes to Mark DiCamillo, director of the Field Poll, which is just out with a poll that shows Arnold Schwarzenegger with a 75% disapproval rating among voters and with 90% of Los Angeles residents rejecting him.

The quote of the week goes to Mark DiCamillo, director of the Field Poll, which is just out with a poll that shows Arnold Schwarzenegger with a 75% disapproval rating among voters and with 90% of Los Angeles residents rejecting him.

DiCamillo told the San Francisco Chronicle:  “He was going to be a … politician who really appealed to independent voters and who would reach across party lines,” DiCamillo said. The new poll shows that Schwarzenegger has “achieved the ‘post-partisan’ status.”

Republicans, Democrats, independents, Californians of all walks of life curse their former Governor. What’s made Arnold’s reign so disappointing is not that he betrayed his wife, but that he betrayed voters and their hopes.

Consumer Watchdog launched ArnoldWatch.org on Schwarzenegger’s gubernatorial inauguration day because we knew his talk about cleaning up Sacramento was phony.  At the time Schwarzenegger had a 65% plus approval rating.  We launched the blog ArnoldWatch.org to hold California’s new governor accountable to his pledge to clean up special-interest control in Sacramento and to chart the influence of big business over his administration.  By 2005 Californians came to learn the Gov did not live up to his word when they rejected a slate of reactionary ballot measures he proposed.  When Schwarzenegger left office in 2010, before the news of love child scandal, his approval rating was only 27%, tied with Governor Gray Davis at the moment of his recall.

What ruined Arnold wasn’t his infidelity to his family, but to his state.  The blogs at Arnold Watch stand as a reminder of the need to be ever vigilant in holding our politicians accountable.  The special interests he bedded while in the governor’s suite spawned some of the uglier moments of California governance.  Sometimes we stopped him, sometimes we shamed him, other times Schwarzenegger’s donors won more than they should have.  When Arnold was hurting, he was forced to take huge steps forward to rehabilitate his image — an increase in the minimum wage, a greenhouse gas emissions cap, support for gay marriage.

What matters to voters in the end, though, isn’t these strides forward for progress or the master marketer’s cosmetic remakes of himself.  The voter’s final verdict was cast about his character.

Other politicians across America would do well to learn the lesson that, in the end, reputation and trust are all that truly matter. Every vote, every decision should be based not on the power of the interest group of the moment, or the political winds of an insular world, but on what’s right and wrong for history and a public official’s place in it.  Until politicians are ready for that truth, Consumer Watchdog will be here to remind them of it.

—————

Posted by Jamie Court, author of The Progressive’s Guide to Raising Hell and President of Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to providing an effective voice for taxpayers and consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Visit us on Facebook and Twitter.

California Democratic Lawmakers Revive Schwarzenegger Scam To Sell Off Historic State Properties In

Today California’s Democratic state lawmakers announced a budget plan to keep their paychecks coming that included one of the worst ideas Arnold Schwarzenegger had since impregnating his kids’ nanny.

If lawmakers don’t pass a budget today, they lose their pay tomorrow. So Assembly Democrats have included in their hastily-assembled budget plan Schwarzenegger’s political love child, selling off treasured state properties to a group of politically-connected investors.

Schwarzenegger tried to sell off 24 historic state buildings — including the San Francisco Civic Center and the California Supreme Court – to his big campaign contributors. The Los Angeles Times reported the investors behind the so-called “California First” group contributed hundreds of thousands of dollars to Schwarzenegger’s political campaigns (Maria L. La Ganga, “$500,000 `Success Fee` Revealed In Proposed Sale of State Buildings,  Los Angeles Times, December 7, 2010)   The shady deal also included a half million dollar ‘finders fee’ to a local official.

Schwarzenegger’s fire sale was stopped in the courts by legendary attorney Joe Cotchett. My group Consumer Watchdog recently feted Cotchett at our Rage for Justice Awards for the lawsuit and his lifetime of legal achievement.

This short video from the dinner about Cotchett’s role and his acceptance speech of the Phillip Burton Lifetime Legal Achievement Award expose the corruption, stupidity and infidelity to the state’s constitution behind the ploy to sell off state buildings only to pay investors to lease them back.

So what gives with the Assembly Democrats’ plan?   Is it just about passing any budget to get paid? Are the investors behind California First putting up more finder fees and political contributions?

Whatever the reason for this misstep, legislators should realize by now that following Schwarzenegger’s lead is a recipe for disaster.

—————

Posted by Jamie Court, author of The Progressive’s Guide to Raising Hell and President of Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to providing an effective voice for taxpayers and consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Visit us on Facebook and Twitter.

Half a Billion

$538 million.  That’s how much is said to have been spent on lobbying the legislature, and that’s just what has been reported.  

Special interest groups with business before the state government spent $538 million on professional lobbyists to influence the passage or defeat of bills during the 2009-10 legislative session. … State and local governments spent the most on lobbying of any special interest group. Other governmental entities that spent millions to lobby government included kindergarten-through-twelfth-grade schools and public universities. Education ranked fifth on the secretary of state’s list.

Rounding out the top five lobbying spenders was the healthcare industry, including hospitals, doctors and pharmaceutical companies, and the manufacturing-industrial category, which includes powerful trade groups and giant industrial corporations such as General Electric Co. and Apple Inc (LA Times)

On the plus side, that number is slightly down from the previous legislative session, so yay for us, right? But the underlying fact is that it is just nearly impossible for the people to break through the din of the moneyed interests.  Sure, occasionally there can be a confluence of interests, or a really widespread organized movement (see organized labor), but when you get down to it, the interests with all the cash get the attention.  It’s basic political law.

With real clean money still being a distant dream, this increased spending means that organizations without all that cash need to put a high premium on a visible presence and consistent contact with legislators.

On Learning To Love Homegrown, Or, Baucus’ Fundraising Considered

So we are now finding out the answers to some of our questions about which members of Congress actually represent We, the People…and which ones represent, Them, the Corporate Masters.

We have seen a Democratic Senator propose a policy that would put people in jail for not buying health insurance and a Democratic President who has taken numerous public beatings from those on the left side of the fence for his inability to ram something through a group of people…and yes, folks, the entendre was intentional.

But most of all, we’ve been asking ourselves: “why would Democratic Members of Congress who will eventually want us to vote for them vote against something that nearly all voting Democrats are inclined to vote for?”

Today’s conversation attempts to answer that question by looking at exactly how money and influence flow through a key politician, Montana’s Senator Max Baucus-and in doing so, we examine some ugly political realities that have to be resolved before we can hope to convince certain Members of Congress to vote for what their constituents actually want when it really counts.

“The idea of covering even the early stages of the cynical and increasingly retrograde campaign has already plunged me into a condition bordering on terminal despair, and if I thought I might have to stay with these people all the way to November I would change my name and seek work as a professional alligator poacher in the swamps around Lake Okeechobee.”

–Hunter S. Thompson, “Jimmy Carter and the Great Leap of Faith“

Now any normal person trying to analyze last year’s election would have said something like “the fact that Obama was promoting a new type of politics-and that a large majority of the public liked what they were seeing-should have meant that politicians would finally do what the public wanted”…and if you’re as cynical as I am, you might have thought that the fact that Obama is the most successful fundraiser in the history of politics would have made other candidates figure that supporting Obama, politically, would be the easy way to put more cheddar in their own pockets.

But here’s the thing: Senator Baucus has been in Washington, in the same job, since 1978, which is about three years short of half of his entire life (and he spent those three years in the House), and unless he wakes up dead one morning or Montana secedes from the Union he’s pretty much guaranteed to be there until at least January 2015.

In those three decades he’s been able to create, and then “outsource”, his own independent fundraising operation-and he’s been so good at doing this that he can donate money from his own Political Action Committee (Glacier PAC) to other Democrats, which is the Congressional version of acquiring really cool “Magic: The Gathering” cards now in an effort to both control votes today and become a more powerful player later on.

He did it by cultivating people in his own office who later went on to become lobbyists. At least 24 of ’em. Since Baucus now runs the Senate Finance Committee and every bill in the Senate that needs money has to pass through his Committee for approval, all those hard working lobbyists now lobby…wait for it…their former boss.

This creates a fundraising “virtuous circle”: “Baucus-affiliated” lobbyists sell access to Baucus…and part of the price of that access is donating to Baucus…which, since “the fix is in”, creates legislative successes that lead to more people wanting more access for bigger favors…which makes the prices all go up, creating more power and influence for Baucus and his orbiting constellation of homegrown lobbyists.

And now that the enterprise has reached the point where the entourage has gone on to have their own entourages, Obama’s vision of “change you can believe in” is sounding more like a promise to screw up a perfectly good hustle than it is a way to run a country.

So how does all this influence the healthcare debate?

At the moment, Baucus could literally coach a basketball team of former staff members who now lobby Baucus on behalf of health care clients:

—David Castagnetti of Mehlman Vogel Castagnetti, Inc. is the vertically integrated busy beaver of the group, representing drug powerhouses Abbot, AstraZeneca, and Biogen, device manufacturers like GE Medical, service providers like Humana and the American Clinical Lab Association, and AHIP, the trade association of health insurers, among others.

—Jeff Forbes, who is currently self-employed, is representing drug maker Roche Group, Manor Care (who provides long-term care services in nursing homes and other environments), and the Advanced Medical Technology Association (AdvaMed), a group which includes many of the big players in the medical business.

–Roger Blauwet (he of DC’s Canfield and Associates), is representing Wyeth and Pfizer (two more major drug manufacturers), the Association of Financial Guaranty Insurers, who are the “reinsurers” who help carry risk for other insurers (in return for a piece of the action), and the Rx Benefits Coalition, which reports that it represents companies that support “market solutions” to make prescription drugs available.

Some clients feel that their needs require more than one “Baucus alumnus” on the payroll, which is why Scott Olsen and Jeff Forbes are working for biotech giant Amgen (along with about 150 other lobbyists), David Castagnetti and Angela Hofmann are slogging it out for Wal-Mart, and Roger Blauwet and Castagnetti are both hoofing it for the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA), who is, literally, the “Big PhRMA” that everyone talks about.

Drug manufacturer Merck hired three of the anointed: Forbes, Blauwet and Castagnetti.

All of this effort is working-and working well. According to OpenSecrets.org, somewhere in the range of $4.5 million has been donated to Baucus during his career by insurance and healthcare interests.

It isn’t just health care, either. Because somewhere around two dozen former Baucus staffers turned lobbyists are “home on the Washington range”, no matter what is being debated in Congress, Baucus gets paid (two quick examples of his Committee’s jurisdiction: changes in tax policy and financial industry regulation-or the lack of it).

In truth, “Baucus gets paid” is probably a bit too cynical.

What I really should say is that Baucus has been exceptionally successful in listening to all points of view when considering ways to make the lives of every American all they can be, that the people who get listened to are exceptionally grateful for this attention, that millions and millions of dollars worth of gratitude have been funneled to Baucus over the years because he’s such a good listener, and that, from now until at least 2015, if you need a Senator to support “status quo you can believe in” you might want to try launching a great big brick of cheddar into the Senator’s constellation.

So the next time someone asks you how “change you can believe in” could have possibly morphed into “buy insurance or we’ll put you in jail”…well, now you know-and given the choice, wouldn’t you rather watch someone make sausage?

[poll id=”

319

“]

Is Your Legislator Taking Money From Big Tobacco?

Over 40,000 Californians die every year from tobacco smoking, nearly one-fifth of all of the deaths that occur in the state.  That’s 17 times the 2,500 California homicides.  That’s ten times the 4,100 Californians who will die of breast cancer this year.  Despite decreases in smoking rates, tobacco use remains the state’s leading public health emergency.

What, therefore, can you say about an elected official who takes campaign contributions from the industry that needs, for its survival, that that public health emergency continue unabated and thus needs a favorable regulatory climate in Sacramento?

A new report from the American Lung Association of California details the bribes donations that Big Tobacco gave to legislators and candidates during 2005-6.

Big Tobacco gave $130,700 to 2005-6 Senators, $24,900 (19.1%) to Democrats and 105,800 (81.9%) to Republicans.

Big Tobacco gave $366,823 to 2005-6 Assemblymembers, $75,200 (20.5%) to Democrats, and $291,623 (79.5%) to Republicans.

Big Tobacco gave $98,500 to incoming 07-08 freshmen legislators, $50,100 (50.9%) to Democrats and $48,400 (49.1%) to Republicans.

Big Tobacco spent $2,160,864 on lobbying during the 2005-6 Term.  Philip Morris spent $884,694, RJ Reynolds spent $598,507, US Smokeless Tobacco spent $391,137, Lorillard spent $187,202, and the California Distributors Association spent $99,324. 

You can look at the report for the details, but I have compiled the data into lists sorted by party and whether the legislator or candidate took Big Tobacco money during 2005-6.  Please contact your legislator to let them know that you either appreciate that they did not take Big Tobacco’s money or to urge them to cease doing so.

Senate Democrats who took no Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

Alarcon, Richard (no longer in Senate)
Alquist, Elaine
Bowen, Debra (no longer in Senate)
Cedillo, Gilbert
Chesbro, Wesley (no longer in Senate)
Corbett, Ellen (new in 07-08)
Dunn, Joseph (no longer in Senate)
Escutia, Martha (no longer in Senate)
Figueroa, Liz (no longer in Senate)
Kehoe, Christine
Kuehl, Sheila
Lowenthal, Alan
Ortiz, Deborah (no longer in Senate)
Padilla, Alex (new in 07-08)
Perata, Don
Romero, Gloria
Scott, Jack
Simitian, Joe
Soto, Nell (no longer in Senate)
Speier, Jackie (no longer in Senate)
Steinberg, Darrell (new in 07-08)
Torlakson, Tom
Wiggins, Patricia (new in 07-08)

Senate Republicans who took no Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

NONE

Senate Democrats who took Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

Correa, Lou ($4,300) – new in 07-08
Ducheny, Denise Moreno ($4,300)
Florez, Dean ($8,600)
Machado, Michael ($1,000)
Migden, Carole ($4,300)
Murray, Kevin ($3,400) (no longer in senate)
Vincent, Edward ($3,300)

Senate Republicans who took Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

Aanestad, Sam ($6,600)
Ackerman, Richard ($9,300)
Ashburn, Roy ($7,050)
Battin, Jim ($8,300)
Cox, Dave ($8,600)
Denham, Jeffrey ($4,300)
Dutton, Robert ($9,100)
Harman, Tom ($9,600)
Hollingsworth, Dennis ($5,300)
Maldonado, Abel ($3,300)
Margett, Bob ($3,300)
McClintock, Tom ($11,550)
Morrow, Bill ($2,600) (no longer in Senate)
Poochigian, Charles ($8,100) (no longer in Senate)
Runner, George ($8,800)

Assembly Democrats who took no Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

Arambula, Juan
Bass, Karen
Beall Jr., Jim (new in 07-08)
Berg, Patty
Bermúdez, Rudy (no longer in Assembly)
Brownley, Julia (new in 07-08)
Chan, Wilma (no longer in Assembly)
Chavez, Ed (no longer in Assembly)
Chu, Judy (no longer in Assembly)
De La Torre, Hector
de Leon, Kevin (new in 07-08)
DeSaulnier, Mark (new in 07-08)
Dymally, Mervyn
Eng, Mike (new in 07-08)
Evans, Noreen
Feuer, Mike (new in 07-08)
Frommer, Dario (no longer in Assembly)
Goldberg, Jackie (no longer in Assembly)
Hancock, Loni
Hayashi, Mary (new in 07-08)
Hernandez, Edward (new in 07-08)
Huffman, Jared (new in 07-08)
Jones, Dave
Karnette, Betty
Klehs, Johan (no longer in Assembly)
Koretz, Paul (no longer in Assembly)
Krekorian, Paul (new in 07-08)
Laird, John
Leno, Mark
Levine, Lloyd
Lieber, Sally
Lieu, Ted
Liu, Carol (no longer in Assembly)
Matthews, Barbara (no longer in Assembly)
Montañez, Cindy (no longer in Assembly)
Mullin, Gene
Nation, Joe (no longer in Assembly)
Nava, Pedro
Oropeza, Jenny (no longer in Assembly)
Pavley, Fran (no longer in Assembly)
Portantino, Anthony (new in 07-08)
Ridley-Thomas, Mark (no longer in Assembly)
Ruskin, Ira
Saldaña, Lori
Salinas, Simon
Salas, Mary (new in 07-08)
Solorio, Jose (new in 07-08)
Vargas, Juan
Wolk, Lois

Assembly Republicans who took no Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

Nakanishi, Alan
Richman, Keith (no longer in Assembly)

Assembly Democrats who took Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

Baca Jr., Joe ($8,700) (no longer in Assembly)
Caballero, Anna ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Calderon, Charles ($14,400) – new in 07-08
Calderon, Ronald ($15,100) (no longer in Assembly)
Canciamilla, Joseph ($3,300) (no longer in Assembly)
Carter, Wilmer ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Cohn, Rebecca ($500) (no longer in Assembly)
Coto, Joe ($6,600)
Davis, Mike ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Galgiani, Cathleen ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Horton, Jerome ($10,900) (no longer in Assembly)
Karnette, Betty ($1,000)
Ma, Fiona ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Mendoza, Tony ($1,000) – new in 07-08
Negrete McLeod, Gloria ($8,600)
Núñez, Fabian ($3,300)
Parra, Nicole ($7,600)
Price, Curren ($6,300) – new in 07-08
Richardson, Laura ($3,300) – new in 07-08 (on her way to Congress)
Swanson, Sandre ($4,300) – new in 07-08
Torrico, Alberto ($2,000)
Umberg, Tom ($3,300) (no longer in Assembly)
Yee, Leland ($4,300) (no longer in Assembly)

Assembly Republicans who took Big Tobacco money during 2005-6:

Adams, Anthony ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Anderson, Joel ($5,300) – new in 07-08
Aghazarian, Greg ($9,100)
Benoit, John ($11,600)
Berryhill, Tom ($6,600) – new in 07-08
Blakeslee, Sam ($6,600)
Bogh, Russ ($13,118) (no longer in Assembly)
Cogdill, David ($14,800) (no longer in Assembly)
Cook, Paul ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Daucher, Lynn ($7,700) (no longer in Assembly)
DeVore, Chuck ($8,900)
Duvall, Michael ($4,300) – new in 07-08
Emmerson, Bill ($8,100)
Fuller, Jean ($4,300) – new in 07-08
Garcia, Bonnie ($17,028)
Gaines, Ted ($4,800) – new in 07-08
Garrick, Martin ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Haynes, Ray ($5,300) (no longer in Assembly)
Horton, Shirley ($11,350)
Houston, Guy ($12,600)
Huff, Bob ($7,600)
Jeffries, Kevin ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Keene, Rick ($12,850)
La Malfa, Doug ($13,350)
La Suer, Jay ($3,300) (no longer in Assembly)
Leslie, Tim ($1,500) (no longer in Assembly)
Maze, Bill ($8,100)
McCarthy, Kevin ($9,778) (no longer in Assembly)
Mountjoy, Dennis ($5,800) (no longer in Assembly)
Niello, Roger ($5,300)
Plescia, George ($20,699)
Runner, Sharon ($9,800)
Silva, Jim ($3,300) – new in 07-08
Smyth, Cameron ($6,600) – new in 07-08
Spitzer, Todd ($10,100)
Strickland, Audra ($14,350)
Tran, Van ($7,600)
Villines, Mike ($13,600)
Walters, Mimi ($8,600)
Wyland, Mark ($13,100) (no longer in Assembly)

Disclosure? Distraction? Confusion? Contribution?

Brian Joseph has a frightening tale for us in today’s “Capitol Watchdog” column in The OC Register. He was just trying to figure out how much the County of Orange was spending on lobbying expenses. He ended up diving into a maze of total confusion.

I had downloaded lobbying expenditures from the Secretary of State’s Web site and found that over a little more than six and half years the County of Orange had spent $5.1 million on lobbying – more than the Irvine Co., Pacific Life Insurance and the Walt Disney Co. combined.
According to the state’s official numbers, Orange County ranked 32nd out of 4,321 lobbying interests, just seven spots behind British Petroleum ($5.9 million) and 10 behind Verizon ($6 million).

Wow. Doesn’t that sound crazy? Well, what if I told you that Orange County ACTUALLY DIDN’T spend $5.1 million on lobbying? Follow me after the flip for more on this story of disclosure gone wild…

Hold on a moment. So Orange County didn’t spend $5.1 million on lobbying Sacramento? Well, it depends on how one counts the money.

Digging much deeper, I found the state’s reporting standards for government agencies differ from other lobbying interests. Governments, unlike other groups, are required to report membership dues to organizations that spend more than $15,000 or 10 percent of their annual expenditures on lobbying. So while a county has to count its membership fee to a politically active chamber of commerce, a business doesn’t have to.
That might not sound like a big deal, but $3.5 million, or nearly 70 percent, of Orange County’s reported lobbying expenses appear to be membership fees or other organizational costs. Over the six full years I examined, Orange County spent an average of $560,000 annually on fees to a total of more than 150 organizations. Only about $1.5 million went to direct lobbying.

$3.5 MILLION?! Is there really a $3.5 million discrepancy between what the county might have actually spent on lobbying and what the county has to report to the state on lobbying expenses? Is this for real?

Moreover, some organizations charge different dues depending on the size of the member. In 2005 and 2006, for example, Orange County paid a total of $333,051 to the California State Association of Counties while Contra Costa County, a third of Orange County’s size, paid the organization $110,496.
Then there’s over-reporting. Governments, not surprisingly, might not know whether an organization meets the $15,000 or 10 percent lobbying threshold. So in the interest of full disclosure, I’m told some agencies report dues to all organizations – regardless of whether they qualify.
All of which makes the state’s publicly available numbers grossly misleading.
You can compare expenses for businesses and other groups, but you can’t accurately compare them to governments or even compare one government to another. You could, I suppose, read the fine print and subtract membership dues, but that also could eliminate costs for indirect lobbying.

So then, what good are these numbers? What good are these numbers if they can’t give us an accurate representation of how much our local governments are actually spending on lobbying Sacramento? What good are these numbers if we can’t compare how much my local governments is spending to how much your local government is spending?

Now I guess disclosure is good. It’s good for us to know how much money our local government is spending on lobbying expenses. But then again, what good are these numbers if they don’t give us an accurate portrayal of what’s actually happening?

Maybe Shirley Grindle is right…

“In my book, `disclosure’ … is just another word for confusing the public. Just give `em a bunch of numbers that don’t make any sense.”

Is Shirley Grindle right? Is disclosure just meant to confuse us? Is there a better way to disclose? What do you think?