Tag Archives: California Legislature

California Governor Jerry Brown Wants to Steal My Home

Due to the expansion of Medi-Cal under ObamaCare, my wife and I am now covered by that program.  But because both of us are over 55, Jerry can steal our house after we die to cover Medi-Cal’s expense of paying for our healthcare.  A 1993 law gives states the option to take back all the money spent by Medi-Cal for the healthcare of recipients over 55 by billing the estate after the recipient (and spouse) die.  Because California is taking advantage of this option, Medi-Cal for older people is effectively a long term loan.  

SB 1124, a bill to fix the problem, has made its way through most of the legislature.  If it passes, which is expected this week, Jerry has threatened to veto it to protect the state from the financial ruin of losing the $15 million it expects to collect by stealing the homes of other older Medi-Cal recipients who die over the next year.  That $15 million is 1/100 of 1% of the state’s budget!  At the end of this diary, I will ask you to contact Jerry Brown’s office and tell him to sign, not veto, SB 1124.  But first, a few important details.

My wife and I signed up for Medi-Cal late last year with coverage to start on January 1 of this year.  It was not until several months later that I read online that in California Medi-Cal is a long term loan program.  Even if we remain healthy, the state will deduct the monthly fee for the managed care program that administers Medi-Cal.  I even found a PDF of a brochure produced by the California Department of Healthcare Services (DHCS) that explained the details of how “estate recovery” works.  I prefer the term legal theft to the Orwellian “estate recovery.”

At no point in the process of signing up were we notified that it was perfectly legal to steal our home from our children after we both die.  When I called the Medi-Cal customer service line to ask about how to resign from Medi-Cal, they told me I was wrong and that the state could not and would not bill my estate.  Mentioning the DHCS brochure I had in my possession made no difference in that assertion by the customer service rep and his supervisor.

In April, California Senator Ed Hernandez, chair of the Senate Health Committee, introduced SB 1124, which limits so-called “estate recovery” to that which is mandated by Federal law, which is long-term care.  The bill also prohibits collection from the estate of a surviving spouse of a Medi-Cal beneficiary. I started an on-line petition in support of the bill and, with the help of Moveon and the Courage Campaign, have gotten almost 1500 people to sign the petition.  

Nearly every person I have ever talked to about Medi-Cal “estate recovery” is just as shocked as I am.  Some of the things they have said and/or written to me about “estate recovery” include “unconscionable,” “unfair,” “appalling,” and an “ill-conceived asset-stripping scheme.”  

Some of the people who signed the petition have told me their stories.  Here are some:

One woman is delaying gall bladder surgery rather than sign up for Medi-Cal.  She turned 55 earlier this year, is on disability and cannot work, and will pay off her home mortgage later this year.  Because her income is too low for the subsidies for private insurance that middle income people get, she is hoping to pay full price for health insurance when the open enrollment period for Obamacare begins in November.  

Others tell me that the process of signing up takes a long time, is cumbersome, and, like me, that nobody told them about “estate recovery” when they did sign up.  And, like me, they found out about it later through their own research.  There have even been cases where the family and beneficiaries first find out about Medi-Cal “estate recovery” after the recipient dies.

Another woman explained that she had chosen to move back into her father’s home when he became very ill so she could take care of him.  His healthcare was covered by Medi-Cal.  She was able to work in addition to caring for him but put all her extra money into paying taxes, maintenance, and upkeep for the house.  She has no money saved, but had assumed that she would be able to continue to live in the house after he dies.  There is a hardship exemption, but it will not apply because she can work.  Thousands of her dollars will be lost when he dies and the state steals his home that she will no longer inherit.  

Most ridiculous of all, a 62 year old man, who is an unemployed librarian with an MA in library science, broke his finger.  It is all discolored from the injury.  Rather than sign up for Medi-Cal so his finger could be taken care of by a doctor, he splinted it with a popsicle stick.  He does not want to lose his house.

So far, SB 1124 has gotten overwhelming support in the California legislature.  In the Senate, it passed the Health Committee 7-1, Senate Appropriations 6-1, and the full Senate 30-5.  It has also passed the Assembly Health Committee 18-0 and Assembly Appropriations 12-0.  The next step is a vote by the entire Assembly which is also expected to approve the bill as well.  As I said previously, the governor’s staff have said that they are recommending that SB 1124 be vetoed.

To overcome the opposition of the governor and his staff, I need you to act NOW by contacting Jerry Brown’s office and state your support for SB 1124.  Here is the contact information (mail, phone, fax, email):

Governor Jerry Brown

c/o State Capitol, Suite 1173

Sacramento, CA 95814

Phone: (916) 445-2841

Fax: (916) 558-3160

Email Jerry Brown

Please act right away.  

And please sign my petition in support of SB1124 at:

Online petition

Originally published in beyondchron.org

California Legislature Calls for Citizens United Repeal

Our campaign finance needs reform, but not fake reform that hurts working Californians

by Brian Leubitz (Note: I work for the Stop Special Exemptions Campaign. Cross-posted to DailyKos)

On Thursday, the California Senate approved AJR 22, a joint resolution from the Assembly and Senate calling for the repeal of the Citizens United decision. It doesn’t change the very real threat from moneyed interests, but it does put a flag down for change in our campaign finance system. Here is a portion of that:

WHEREAS, Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission purports to invalidate state laws and state constitutional provisions separating corporate money from elections; and

WHEREAS, The United States Supreme Court’s ruling in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission represents a serious and direct threat to our democracy; and

WHEREAS, The general public and political leaders in the United States have recognized, since the founding of our country, that the interests of corporations do not always correspond with the public interest and that, and, therefore, the political influence of corporations should be limited; and

*** **** ***

Resolved by the Assembly and the Senate of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the majority opinion and decision of the United States Supreme Court in Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission; and be it further

Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California calls upon the United States Congress to propose and send to the states for ratification a constitutional amendment to overturn Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission and to restore constitutional rights and fair elections to the people;…(Resolution)

But what does that mean?

Under Citizens United and subsequent decisions and FEC regulations, SuperPACs (and their California analog, Independent Expenditures) can raise unlimited, and often anonymous, funds to spend on a candidate or campaign. In theory, SuperPACs are supposed to operate entirely independently of the actual campaigns. However, as we’ve seen over the last few months, that is more theoretical and less factual. In fact, Karl Rove, who runs one of the biggest SuperPACs (Crossroads GPS) was at a “strategy” retreat for GOP nominee Mitt Romney in late June. As was Charles Spies, the man who runs the Romey-backing SuperPAC Restore Our Future.

And the amount of money is simply staggering. Karl Rove wants to raise $600 million to spend to get Mitt Romney and other Republicans elected in November. So far, Republican SuperPACs have raised $158mil and Democratic SuperPACs have raised $47mil. While the Republican balance is notable, any way you look at it, the amount of money has grown exponentially for the 2012 election.  Just this week, Restore Our Future reserved over $7 million of Olympics advertising.

With the balance of money being tilted heavily towards Republicans, the next questions is what do they want? If you look at the big federal SuperPACs, the big names that jump out at you are Sheldon Adelson, a gambling magnate.  Also high on the list? The Koch brothers, who made their money in oil business. Harold Simmons is a banking tycoon, and Bob Perry is a developer in Texas. Both were prominent in the so-call Swift Boat Veterans campaign, and are now two of the largest GOP SuperPAC donors.

In California, independent expenditure committees are also spending millions upon millions of dollars upon candidates and campaigns. And while the Special Exemptions Act looks like “campaign reform,” in reality it just gives these same folks more power.  And guess what, they have ideas on how to use it as well.  Just this week, William Oberndorf, a hedge fund manager, gave $150,000 to the Act. Oh, and he’s prominent in the school privatization movement, in case you are wondering at his angle.  He’s not the only one, of course, with several other prominent right-leaning funders already on board.

Take a look at who is financing the Special Exemptions Act. (links here and here.) You’ll find there is a long list of folks who have an interest in changing California in a way that runs counter to working Californians. The Lincoln Club, the Jarvis group, etc. The Special Exemptions Act is just a step in the wrong direction.

California progressives need to work together to defeat this measure. If you haven’t joined the campaign online yet, please take a moment to get connected now. You can also like the campaign on facebook or follow on twitter.

California Democratic Lawmakers Revive Schwarzenegger Scam To Sell Off Historic State Properties In

Today California’s Democratic state lawmakers announced a budget plan to keep their paychecks coming that included one of the worst ideas Arnold Schwarzenegger had since impregnating his kids’ nanny.

If lawmakers don’t pass a budget today, they lose their pay tomorrow. So Assembly Democrats have included in their hastily-assembled budget plan Schwarzenegger’s political love child, selling off treasured state properties to a group of politically-connected investors.

Schwarzenegger tried to sell off 24 historic state buildings — including the San Francisco Civic Center and the California Supreme Court – to his big campaign contributors. The Los Angeles Times reported the investors behind the so-called “California First” group contributed hundreds of thousands of dollars to Schwarzenegger’s political campaigns (Maria L. La Ganga, “$500,000 `Success Fee` Revealed In Proposed Sale of State Buildings,  Los Angeles Times, December 7, 2010)   The shady deal also included a half million dollar ‘finders fee’ to a local official.

Schwarzenegger’s fire sale was stopped in the courts by legendary attorney Joe Cotchett. My group Consumer Watchdog recently feted Cotchett at our Rage for Justice Awards for the lawsuit and his lifetime of legal achievement.

This short video from the dinner about Cotchett’s role and his acceptance speech of the Phillip Burton Lifetime Legal Achievement Award expose the corruption, stupidity and infidelity to the state’s constitution behind the ploy to sell off state buildings only to pay investors to lease them back.

So what gives with the Assembly Democrats’ plan?   Is it just about passing any budget to get paid? Are the investors behind California First putting up more finder fees and political contributions?

Whatever the reason for this misstep, legislators should realize by now that following Schwarzenegger’s lead is a recipe for disaster.

—————

Posted by Jamie Court, author of The Progressive’s Guide to Raising Hell and President of Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to providing an effective voice for taxpayers and consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Visit us on Facebook and Twitter.

Bumpy Road ahead, Holy Trinity rejected

Buckle your seat belts; we are in for a bumpy ride, whether or not a bailout is passed.  Congressional leaders promised a quick and dirty fix, but the screaming public and the Congressional rank and file rebelled.

First, Bush and the insiders told us that we must invade Iraq immediately to avoid a nuclear attack. We would be welcomed as liberators; Iraq oil would pay for the war. Congressional lemmings fell in line. Only 6 Senators (Biden was one) bothered to read the classified NIE. That vote was a disaster.

Next, we needed strong government surveillance, the USA Patriot Act. The establishment said “Nothing to fear if you are a law abiding citizen”. This bolstered the idea of the unitary executive, torture and the notion that DOJ lawyer = Federalist society membership. A big mistake.

Given Bernanke and Paulson’s incompetent words and deeds in the last 18 months, why trust them with anything? Can those who created the problem fix it? Who says that $700 billion is enough? Have those ideologues considered future FDIC costs and the cost of aiding GM, GE and Ford (financials in drag)? We’re in trouble without car loans. I’m willing to loan them money or take an equity position in those companies. I’m not willing to let Bernanke buy assets at “close to hold to maturity” prices instead of the fire-sale price, to quote his words, without prior authorization, because this is guesswork. Greenspan and Bernanke have a bad record. Even Brad DeLong has soured on Greenspan, http://delong.typepad.com/sdj/…

As head of the Social Security Commission, Greenspan urged bigger social security taxes to build up a trust fund but said nothing when Reagan cut top level taxes and appropriated the trust fund (Clinton was also silent). Greenspan and Bernanke have increased liquidity year after year, creating bubbles. Jack Welch and GE rode the money spigot to riches. Yes, we need more liquidity but I want prior control of the money- Congressional oversight after the fact is meaningless. I want an equity stake in the essential corporations; I’m sure that $700 billion is inadequate to bail out everybody

This complex problem needs time and analysis, a focused bailout. Dodd and Schumer have learned nothing from the Iraq War and Patriot Act. I’d like to see Brad Sherman replace Nancy Pelosi as speaker. My bank (WaMu) crashed, I can still withdraw funds. The FDIC works. The Holy Trinity of Bush, Bernanke and Paulson has crashed.

What about the State of California? It’s actually in worse shape than the federal government. We need a restart, a Constitutional convention. MediCal, unlike FDIC, is unsustainable. High school dropout rates are much too high and concealed from the public. The legislature represent only themselves. Buckle your seat belts…

[poll id=”

227

“]

Don Perata: Thinking Small on Health Care

California’s Senate President Pro Tem Don Perata released a health care plan yesterday that he will propose in the coming year.  It creates a state-run pool of money, provided by employers and employees, that would be funneled into existing private insurance plans.  Essentially everyone in the state who works would eventually be covered.  There aren’t many details beyond that.

This is thinking small.  Working within an already broken system will not produce a positive result.  The money is already spent on health care to create a universal, single-payer system, and it’s time to have that conversation.  In the past I’ve been somewhat happy with these Massachusetts-style forced-health insurance plans, because they at least set covering everyone as the end goal.  But using the same private insurance structure keeps in place the same inefficiencies that have made the American health care system the costliest in the world, without being the most effective.  And as long as you have for-profit companies in the system, as long as you make the tacit argument that health care is a privilege and not a right, those inefficiencies will remain.

I am much more heartened by Oregon Senator Ron Wyden’s bid for universal health care for all.  On the flip…

Wyden understands that forcing employers to provide health care makes them less competitive in a global economy, and has led to them cutting back as far as they can, so that the coverage they do provide is insufficient to prevent illness and disease before it occurs.  But he also understands the difficulty with government bureaucracy (and particularly the perception of it).  So he threads the needle with a hybrid idea that is both smart and good for the economy:

Wyden said his new plan would allow workers to carry their health insurance from job to job without penalty. More efficient administration and more promotion of competition for health care plans, he said, would allow greater coverage while costing no more than the government is paying today for health insurance coverage.

Called the “Healthy Americans Act,” the plan would cover all Americans except those on Medicare or those who receive health care through the military.

It would require that employers “cash out” their existing health plans by terminating coverage and paying the amount saved directly to workers as increased wages. Workers then would be required to buy health insurance from a large pool of private plans.

After two years, companies would no longer have to pay the higher wages. Instead, Wyden said, they would pay into an insurance pool, based on annual revenues and the number of full-time workers.

At Wyden’s request, the Lewin Group, a Virginia-based health care consulting firm, reviewed the plan. The consultant said the plan would reduce health spending by private employers by nearly three-quarters and would save $1.4 trillion in total national health care spending over the next decade.

Taking health care out of the grip of employers will allow workers to be more flexible and more entreprenurial.  I can’t tell you how many people I know who won’t quit their job because of the health insurance they’re getting.  They don’t want to slip into the trap the other 46 million Americans without insurance have.

The full legislation is here and I hope Don Perata and everyone in California concerned with the current crisis in health care read it.  It’s time to think big, not small.

California Blog Roundup, 6/2/06

Today’s California Blog Roundup is on the flip. I’m having a hard time keeping up: more people are writing as the election approaches. Teasers: Angelides, Westly, Schwarzenegger, Bowen, Paid-For Pombo, Francine Busby, Winograd v. Harman, Props 81 and 82, Jerry Lewis / CA-41, discussion of various reforms,immigration, and recent legislative actions.

Statewide Races

Paid-For Pombo / CA-11

Busby / CA-50

Winograd / Harman / CA-36

  • This Paul Rosenberg diary at MyDD re Marcy Winograd’s endorsement by another Democratic Club and the ensuing discussion are interesting. I’ll keep pressing Paul to crosspost his stuff.
  • The BradBlog interviews Marcy Winograd. Unsurprisingly, there’s a lot of stuff in there about election reform and voting machines, but also a lot of other topics, so don’t be afraid to go read it.
  • Alicia of Last Left Before Hooterville spent a night phone-banking for Marcy Winograd, and feels really good about it.

Other Electoral

Propositions

  • Tom Hilton of If I Ran the Zoo says yes to both Prop 81 and Prop 82.
  • Hannah-Beth Jackson at Speak Out CA runs through some of the groups opposing Prop 82. There are a startling number of pro-big-bidness groups involved. Why would they care? Prop 82 levies a tax on the personal income of very few people. Oh, wait. That’s right — those people are likely to be big-bidness executives. Funny that.
  • Beep takes the Next Ten state budget challenge and finds that she probably can’t support Prop 82, because she’d rather use the tax imposed for other things. Well, fair enough, but Beep, there is nothing else on offer today, nor is there likely to be in the foreseeable future. The anti-government groups who prevent any kind of sensible fiscal policy have seen to that.

Reform

Immigration

Legislative Action

Miscellany