Everyone’s diggin’ and groovin’ on my riposte to state senator Tom Harman’s lame attack on SiCKO and SB 840 in June 21’s Huntington Beach Independent, and they’re all like “Blog it, dude.” But tarry a spot, this will require backstory.
(You must flip it………..)
It all started back in the heady days of April 2007 when I wrote this letter to our local progressive paper the Orange Coast Voice encouraging single-payer fans to write and call Senator Tom Harman because, with his reputation as the most “moderate” or “liberal” Sacramento Republican, I thought he could be our opening to get closer to the 2/3 we need for funding this thing. Ah, April. Unicorns. Rainbows. Moderate Sacramento Republicans. We believed in all of these. (Partly I was misled by my paleo-con Dad, who dislikes Harman because he’s “pro-gay and pro-immigrant.”) Little did we know that Harman is in the first leg of a marathon to prove this reputation a slander, hoping to stave off a primary from the right next year.
Anyway between folks who read my letter and my own Healthcare For All California members who live in Harman’s district (stretching along the Orange Coast from Seal Beach to Dana Point) we deluged him with hundreds of phone calls and dozens of letters asking him to support both SB 840 and its funding companion SB 1014. To the degree that he actually contacted my deputy Joe Tyndall asking for a meeting with us.
Turned out, the meeting was not with him but with an aide, a real friendly young Romanian chap named Emmanuel, who unfortunately had no knowledge of the issue and obviously no pull with the senator. We were left with the impression that we would soon be able to meet with the senator himself. (We even had a few suggested amendments to SB 840 prepared, that we thought could get more Republicans and businesses on board while still keeping it single-payer, such as having the agency not be part of the government but a private non-profit agency run by a board elected by doctors, nurses and patients; and changing a little language so that the new single-payer premiums would subsume most workers’ comp expenses.)
All to no avail though, as Harman joined all his Republican friends in voting against SB 840 earlier this month. (And this is one of their new sleazy tricks—they’ll write you back saying “You’ll be glad to know that such-and-such a bill passed, please continue to contact me with your concerns…” without mentioning that they voted against it or why.)
We don’t take such slights sitting down, not here in the OC. My deputy Joe created a brilliant pamphlet (will upload somewhere when I figure out how) extolling the virtues of single-payer and SB 840, specifically in language that Republicans and businesses will understand, but entitled “Does Tom Harman represent YOU?” and detailing all the insurance and pharmaceutical money his campaigns have enjoyed. And we’ve made thousands of these and are walking them door-to-door to all registered voters in his district, especially Republicans, who I must say have been very receptive.
Well, that was last week’s news. This week Tom jumped the shark. In this pathetic piece of drivel printed in last Thursday’s Huntington Beach Independent, he attacks not only SB 840, single-payer, and the entire idea of universal healthcare, but also Michael Moore’s new movie SiCKO, while obviously not even having seen it. I re-read this lump of merde perhaps obsessively before thoroughly demolishing it, but here’s a few choice excerpts:
“Documentary” movie producer Michael Moore descended upon the Capitol last week to promote his new film, “SiCKO,” a cinematic indictment of America’s health-care system……At the well-attended briefing, Moore conveniently discussed his new movie by showcasing “tragedies” of our current healthcare system. Moore demonstrated his wholehearted support for universal health care proposals currently pending in the Legislature; measures that would strip away personal choice, while imposing additional taxes upon small businesses to fund a socialized healthcare scheme for all California residents, regardless of citizenship.Moore is nothing more than a sensationalist who makes money on twisting half-truths and producing factually inaccurate “mockumentaries,” all at the expense of the victims of isolated tragedies… It seems to me that the Senate informational briefing was nothing more than a soapbox — provided at state expense — so that Moore could promote his new film……We all agree that California desperately needs a health care system that is less expensive; increases accountability, access, and coverage; and reduces the burdensome mandates that unnecessarily drive up the cost of health care. However, providing socialized medicine to all, regardless of citizenship, is not the answer.A better alternative is the plan my Senate Republican colleagues and I have proposed. It is called the Cal CARE plan, and it helps remedy our failing health care system while empowering individuals to make choices for themselves…One of the key components of Cal CARE is allowing the establishment of Health Savings Accounts……California does not need some universal healthcare plan like the one being promoted by Moore. Californians deserve better.
All right. So several of us have already started beating up on him online, as you can see if you click on that link, but it just doesn’t feel like enough. I wrote what I thought was a pretty thorough letter identifying not only his falsehoods but also the subtle buzzwords and propaganda sprinkled throughout his piece, I think that’s why everyone’s all “Blog it dude.” But it was necessarily a long letter, which The Independent probably won’t print at all, or if they do it will be only a fragment, so I’m doing two things with it: making a thousand copies to go into each newsstand that carries the free paper (under the title “A Letter The Independent Won’t Print,”) and also saying “Allright then, here you go,” to everyone who says “Blog it.” So all right then, here you go, use these words against your own evil Republican legislator if you have one.
A Letter The Independent Won’t Print
(in response to June 21’s “Community Commentary” entitled
“Moore’s ‘mockumentary’ is misleading,” by state senator Tom Harman).
So this is our state senator—the kind of man who will accuse his opponent Michael Moore of “half-truths” and “factual inaccuracies” without being able to provide a single example. Well I won’t be like that—space (and the editors) permitting, I will detail most of the falsehoods and distortions Senator Harman squeezed into his little diatribe against healthcare reform.
If he had actually seen the film, I doubt he would use ironic quotes around “tragedies” to describe the deaths and bankruptcies due to insurance company behavior which Moore documents. And surely it’s an abuse of language to refer to 18,000 American deaths a year due to denial of service, and two million bankruptcies a year due to medical bills, as “isolated tragedies.” Harman further accuses Moore of making his movie “at the expense of the victims” who had eagerly volunteered their stories to him—well, what about those victims who were finally, reluctantly offered treatment once they THREATENED their insurers that they were going to be in this film?
Harman twice refers to SB 840 and single-payer as “socialized” medicine. Harman knows better and is lying, because we have been over this with him repeatedly, but then this entire column is just a lazy rehash of rightwing talking points. Under SB 840, healthcare providers—doctors, hospitals, drug manufacturers—will remain free capitalist agents subject to market discipline. It is only the function of insurance that we are proposing to replace with an accountable, “socialized” agency, because corporations, whose main responsibility is to make a profit, have proven themselves spectacularly unsuited to the essential task of insuring Americans’ health. We think nothing of having a socialized fire department, police department, and military—well, insuring our health is equally important to our national security as those services.
Another focus-group-tested lie from the insurance industry which Senator Harman parrots is that the healthcare reforms on the table will “strip away personal choice.” Like all the greatest lies, this is the exact opposite of the truth. Right now it is the insurance companies that tell us what doctors and hospitals we can and can’t go to, what procedures they will or won’t cover. SB 840—more than all the other alternatives—will give us much more free choice than we have now. The only choice we’ll be missing is one that most of us don’t want: which one of thousands of insurance plans to be ripped off by.
Continuing with the right-wing buzzwords which drip predictably from Harman’s pen, we get “accountability” as a feature which any reform should include. That sounds nice, but what does he mean by accountability in the context of healthcare? He means that if you’re poor you probably deserve your poverty, and that if you’re unhealthy you’d better damn well be able to pay for your own treatment. I don’t think most Americans agree with that.
In the interests of time and space I’ll have to leave some of the low-lying fruit here for others to pick (for example, the supposed financial burden of single-payer on small businesses, and “burdensome mandates” being the cause of high healthcare costs.) But I do want to point out something that probably escaped most of you, if you don’t keep up with these folks’ propaganda, in which case it probably didn’t have the effect Harman intended. You’ll notice that he uses the term “universal healthcare” four times, in sentences and paragraphs that seem to be otherwise lacking punch. Well, the decision has been made in corporate circles to use “universal healthcare” as a sort of expletive. I’m not sure exactly how effective a tactic that will be, given that most Americans, and most Californians, tell pollsters that they do want universal healthcare (the only question being how best to achieve it.) Tom Harman now inhabits such an insular and selfish world among the Sacramento Republicans that he assumes all his readers will hear “universal” as a bad thing. So you’re forgiven, readers, if you didn’t realize that each time he used that phrase you were supposed to cringe with disgust and horror…especially when he follows it with “regardless of citizenship.”
Okay, illegal immigration, his final trump card; may as well grab that toro by the horns. None of us condones illegal immigration or the hiring of cheap undocumented labor, but public health policy should not be a tool for enforcing laws that are the province of the INS and other federal agencies. There are very good reasons that everybody residing and working in this state would be covered by SB 840 or any of the other serious healthcare reforms—preventive care would control outbreaks and epidemics, and also relieve the pressure on emergency rooms, where the uninsured go when they become seriously ill. As long as corporations continue to use cheap immigrant labor to pick and process our food, it’s in our best interest to keep these people healthy. But as Election Day 2008 gets closer, you will hear Senator Harman talking tougher and tougher about Mexicans: he does NOT want to be primaried from the right, and get called a Mexican-loving “RINO.”
So Harman’s solution to the crisis is the laughable SB 236, aka “Cal CARE,” which does not address a single real problem any more than it has a chance of passing; it exists solely for anti-reform politicians like Harman to pretend that they TRIED to do something about the crisis. Its main feature is tax breaks for folks who can afford to stash away their extra cash in “Health Savings Accounts” while still paying extortion to an approved insurance company—that is, more tax breaks for the wealthy! No wonder this is also George Bush’s one and only idea on healthcare. Well, birds of a feather, eh Tom.
Finally it should be pointed out that Senator Harman has received $249,955 in contributions from insurance, pharmaceutical, and other health-related special interests, and they're certainly getting their money's worth between his votes and columns like this. Go and see “SiCKO” however you feel about Moore’s previous statements and works, think about your own experience with health insurance, and ask yourself who is telling the truth, Michael Moore or Senator Harman? And next year when the Senator is up for re-election, let’s look for a candidate who will vote in our interest, not the interests of his corporate backers.
Vern P. Nelson, Huntington Beach
[poll id=”
135
“]