Tag Archives: Deregulation

AT&T, Dependably in Forefront of Consumer Abuse

AT&T

Comedy is funnier when it hits you in the gut. That’s what made a famous skit by Lily Tomlin about the phone company’s abuse of customers so memorable, one tag line being “We are omnipotent.”

AT&T is still at it. As columnist James Temple writes in the San Francisco Chronicle Friday:

In August 2006, the California Public Utilities Commission voted unanimously to allow AT&T and other companies that provided local telephone service to raise prices at will.

Then-Commissioner Rachelle Chong, a Republican, credited as the driving force behind the deregulation plan, argued that growing competition from Internet phone service and cell phones would keep prices low.

“By the end of the 2010, these rate caps will no longer be necessary,” Chong said when the new rules were being phased in. “The market will be so competitive it will discipline prices.””Price discipline?” That should have ’em rolling in the aisles. Temple goes on to report that AT&T’s flat-rate plan for local calls is up 118 percent and services such as call waiting up nearly 180% since 2006. U.S. median household income is down 8.1% since 2007.

Tomlin’s original crack about omnipotence wasn’t much exaggerated. AT&T’s stranglehold on the California Legislature and the state Public Utilities Commission is near-legendary.

Chong, the AT&T cheerleader on the commission, took  a luxurious junket to Tokyo, funded and run by the telecom industry. Other commissioners and legislators went as well, as reported by Consumer Watchdog, without an ethical qualm.

Judy Dugan

Also on that 2007 Tokyo trip was the state Assembly’s Utilities and Commerce committee chair Lloyd Levine, who co-authored 2006 legislation sponsored by AT&T and Verizon in 2006 that allowed the telecom companies to to get into the cable and video business with one unregulated statewide franchise, while eliminating local control and consumer protection of all cable services.


Consumer Watchdog fought the legislation, predicting that prices would rise, not fall, customer service would degrade, companies would cherry-pick the richest markets for their much-touted new services and local public-access TV, previously funded by the cable companies, would disappear.

The other co-sponsor of the cable deregulation was then-Speaker of the Assembly Fabian Nunez, who received the language of the proposed bill directly from a corporate/right-wing think tank called the American Legislative Exchange Council, or ALEC, described thusly by SourceWatch:

ALEC is a corporate bill mill. It is not just a lobby or a front group; it is much more powerful than that. Through ALEC, corporations hand state legislators their wishlists to benefit their bottom line. Corporations fund almost all of ALEC’s operations. They pay for a seat on ALEC task forces where corporate lobbyists and special interest reps vote with elected officials to approve “model” bills. Learn more at the Center for Media and Democracy’s ALECexposed.org

After the cable deregulation passed, AT&T partner Verizon took out full-page ads to thank Nunez personally. Nunez kept on benefiting from telecom donations and sponsorships, even as our predictions about price, service and public access came true.

AT&T is also the sponsor of the legislative Democrats’ chief yearly fund-raising event, the Pebble Beach Speakers Cup, and was a major donor to former Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger. Every penny of that lavish spending has gone to legislation and deregulation that boost AT&T’s bottom line at the expense of consumers. And neither the 2013 Legislature nor the governor’s office seems moved to undo the wreckage of AT&T’s deregulatory spree.

No wonder we’re not laughing.

_______________________________________________________________

Posted by Judy Dugan, former research director for Consumer Watchdog, a nonpartisan, nonprofit organization dedicated to providing an effective voice for taxpayers and consumers in an era when special interests dominate public discourse, government and politics. Visit us on Facebook and Twitter.

A former PUC Commissioner’s take on smart meters

As a former California Public Utilities Commissioner (1999-2004), I would like to offer a few thoughts about smart meters.

“Smart” meters are devices that can remotely report electricity and gas usage readings as often as hourly to utilities without the need for human meter readers.  The justifications offered by proponents are twofold.  First, it is claimed that utilities can control electricity usage by sharply raising rates during hours of high system demand, thus discouraging consumption and reducing the need for additional generation capacity.  Second, customers can supposedly benefit by moving their usage to hours when demand and prices are low.

While most residential customers are skeptical, this analysis has tremendous appeal to energy producers and market-oriented economists and regulators, the same folks who brought us the electrical deregulation catastrophe in 2000-2001.  What is almost never part of the public discussion is the real motivation of smart meter proponents.

Utilities make their money in two ways: they are reimbursed through rates for their reasonably-incurred costs of providing service, such as paying their workers; and they are fully repaid plus  a “reasonable” rate of return for long-term capital investments in their systems (“rate base”).  Only the second adds to corporate profit, the bottom line.  Replacing functioning existing meters, which have already been partially or fully amortized and have a low rate base, with expensive new ones provides a guaranteed stream of profits for decades to come.  

For example, Southern California Gas Company’s new meters, recently approved by the PUC, add over $1 billion to rate base and will bring the shareholders hundreds of millions of dollars in profits over the next 26 years, even if they don’t work as advertised or become technologically obsolete during that time.  As 1000 union jobs are eliminated in Southern California, customers will lose the safety-related services provided by human meter readers, even though there is no net cost savings from the new technology.

Most residential and small business consumers cannot afford the expensive systems that would enable them to automatically control their consumption in response to hourly price changes.  The winners here will be large industrial and commercial consumers and perhaps some very wealthy homeowners.  Even if non-time-of-use rates are maintained as an option for small consumers, they will go up as large consumers escape regulation that apportions utility system costs among classes of consumers.  In fact, this outcome has always been a central goal of deregulation.

Despite opposition from consumer advocates, Schwarzenegger’s PUC has enthusiastically rubber-stamped every smart meter project that has come before it.  Whoever is elected Governor in November will be able immediately to appoint a majority of this powerful commission.  Progressives need to make sure that the issue becomes part of the election debate.

[Full disclosure: I represent Utility Workers Union of America, Local 132 in its opposition to smart gas meters at the PUC; and I am President of the Board of The Utility Reform Network (TURN), which is leading the campaign to disclose the failings of PG&E’s smart meters.  I am also the Democratic candidate in the 65th Assembly District.]

I’m saying NO to WholeFoods. I will plant my own damn tomatoes.

As a person whose economic life was ruined 23 years ago at age 23, when I got a lupus diagnosis and lost my health insurance, I know I’m only alive thanks to government health care–and charity, which has so far kept me from dying of the poverty I have to stay in to GET the government health care.  

Despite coming from a family with no wealth at all, I had made it to an Ivy League school and looked forward to contributing to my country when my education was completed. Instead I’ve spent my whole adult life fighting, fighting, always fighting to keep health care coverage.  Now I know that despite a painfully hard life I’m actually one of the lucky ones since over 18,000 unsung martyrs die every year in this rich country because they cannot access health care.

There isn’t a food known that will cure lupus.  I can’t go into Whole Foods and buy an avocado and be disease-free.  I need health care and so do others…and so will many who don’t yet know now how much they will need it.  

The CEO of Whole Foods turns out to be a dangerous, heartless, criminally selfish whacko.  He wants to cut the Medicare that is barely keeping a lot of us alive, with its funding always in jeopardy thanks to it being confined to insuring only the elderly and the disabled/chronically ill–the most expensive folks.  The premiums from the healthy ppl go to the privates, who are allowed to ban those of us who actually get sick.  Nice for the taxpayer, isn’t it.  Anyway, genius CEO wants to deregulate these bloodsucking ins companies even further, and cut Medicare as well?

http://www.openleft.com/diary/…

I waited a long time for a Whole Foods to be finally coming to my area of the central coast.  But now I won’t be shopping there.  There are other stores.  There are local stands and farmers’ markets. I can grow my own food.  We have enough sunshine in California. I’m old enough to remember when food was grown rather than imported here anyway.

Boycott the radical far right. On health care reform, they are either falling for the big con job, or they are one of the con men.  There is no third option if you oppose health care reform entirely.

We pay more per capita than any other country in the entire world for health care.  And yet we let citizens die from having no insurance.  We let countless others be underinsured and go through hell with their insurance if they develop a health problem.  We also weigh our businesses down like a stone with expectations that they will pay for their employees’ health care…not exactly a plus for competing in the global economy against some nations where food costs two bucks a day and other nations where health care is provided efficiently and cheaper without employers having to do it.  

We are not getting what we are paying for.  We are being ripped off.  This should not be a partisan issue.

But it is a class issue.  There are some people who are getting extremely rich off of the present system, and they are the ones funding all the smoke and mirrors that so many of our conservative citizens have fallen for hook, line, and sinker.

Where could all that missing money be?  Hmm.  http://www.youtube.com/watch?v…

GOP, you have fallen in among thieves.

Everybody with a heart and a brain, please boycott Whole Foods.  We don’t need them in California.

Send a message to the robber barons, to the superrich elite types we thought we overthrew in 1776.  That’s right tea partiers; this time you’re on the wrong side.  Oops.

Oh and health insurers, Big Pharm and the rest…stop ripping us off on health care! Take your con game somewhere else! We former “easy marks” are onto you, now.

[poll id=”

313

“]

They’re Baaaacck: Electricity Auctions Restart Tomorrow

After 9 long years of trying to clean up after the electricity mess that we experienced at the turn of the century, the fearless energy regulators of our state are once again going to proceed with electricity auctions.

Nine years after its state-sanctioned energy auction went bust in the western energy crisis, California is preparing to launch another daily electricity auction on Tuesday that it hopes will be more successful.

The new “day ahead” energy market will line up electricity resources for delivery the next day. The market will have a price cap of $2,500 a megawatt hour, about 50 times the going price of electricity in California today. Even a high price is unlikely to wreck the market this time because the state is being divided into more than 3,000 separate pricing points called “nodes.” So high prices in one place won’t necessarily spill over into another. (Wall Street Journal 3/30/09)

At least they did some more thorough testing of the system this time, and have installed more safeguards. But given our history with electricity on the open market, you would think this would make some news here in California.  Perhaps there will be more stories as the actual auctions commence tomorrow, but you would like to see some advance notice for this kind of thing. (Note to media: I did a Google news search and double checked several sites. If you reported on the story, shoot me an email and I will highlight it.)

In theory, there are some decent reasons to believe a market based system would help. It points out flaws in the transmission system, and where we need more generation.  That being said, this project needs to be monitored like a hawk. The regulators have said that they will be vigilant in pursuing anybody who violates the rules to game our electricity prices. The fact that they did simulations is great, but computers have a way of underestimating the human capacity to stretch and outright break the rules in the name of greed.

If there are any developments surrounding these auctions, I’ll be sure to keep you updated.

The Myth of Free Markets: Even Greenspan Sees the Light

Not unexpectedly, it required a major disaster to awaken former Federal Chairman, Alan Greenspan, to the long overdue reality that the free-market, free enterprise economic model fails to trickle down wealth to the poor and near poor but concentrates wealth at the top.

The free market model or Neoliberalism was developed by Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman at the Chicago School of Economics Chicago where it became an axiom that the private sector was the key to long-term economic stability.  Neoliberalism has gradually become the prevailing economic conventional wisdom in the United States and has been foisted on most countries through pressure from the United States or through the IMF and World Bank, America’s secret instrument of exploitation.

Simply stated, free-markets, a system with as little government interference as possible in the operation of market mechanisms, have been allowed to operate with increasing privatization and deregulation and a minimum of government transfers.  In theory, when free-market economics operates at peak efficiency, the so-called fabled “invisible hand”, coined by Adam Smith, was empowered to distribute wealth to all deserving citizens.  The theory of the “invisible hand” must be one of the most distorted ideas in the history of economics.  Adam Smith did not mean nor imply that people should be deserted by the government to fend for themselves but rather that all peoples’ needs must be met.

The deregulation of the banking system and the privatization of the Federal Reserve in 1913 are at the root of the current financial crisis and have paved the way for unfettered greed  to trigger the virtual collapse of that system.  The collapse spells the end of any credibility for the notion that by investing wealth at the top it will automatically reach the bottom.

Managing the money supply, interest rates, and exchange rates, or the monetary system, is a vital function in the economy and should serve the public interest in a democratic society.  Since it is privately owned, the Federal Reserve is almost entirely independent of the government consisting of twelve regional Federal Reserve Banks located in major U.S. cities in twelve regions and organized in a similar fashion to private banks whose shareholders consist of private banks in each district.

As well, funding for the Federal Reserve System is independent of the government and depends on interest earnings on its portfolio of investments.  Its decisions do not need to be ratified by either the president or Congress.

Instead of protecting consumers in recent years, the Federal Reserve has adopted policies that have supported large financial institutions in their frenzied, greedy pursuit of wealth ultimately pulling the rug out from under the economy.  While deregulated financial institutions were offering mortgages at initially low interest rates to high risk borrowers, the Federal Reserve was expanding the money supply and lowering interest rates to facilitate this feeding frenzy.  Eager homebuyers flocked to their nearest bank to borrow money at the ostensibly bargain basement interest rates and without the need to meet stiff credit requirements.  Mortgage-debt in 2000 was $4.8 trillion while in 2006 it rose to $9.3 trillion.  When borrowers began defaulting on their mortgages, banks that had used the mortgages as collateral to borrow for investments in other risky instruments were suddenly unable to meet their obligations.  The downward spiral into total collapse was well underway.

If the Federal Reserve had been a public institution, it might have implemented a different set of policies to avert the disastrous bubble that has now burst.

Another way in which the Federal Reserve has become complicit in the financial crisis is through its non-interventionist approach to the proliferation of very risky financial instruments known as derivatives.  With risky mortgages backing further risky, highly-leveraged investment in derivatives, the calamitous outcome was inevitable.

In addition, deregulating the financial system created the conditions which engendered the financial crisis by transforming commercial banks, whose primary purpose was to serve as a safe place for consumers to deposit their money, into investment institutions where risk-taking for profits was the central objective.  Now, consumers hard-earned money was now being deposited into apparently safe institutions when, in fact, it had indirectly become the source of funds for greedy investors who were willing to take risks to earn large profits.

Regulation of the banking system was solidified in the Glass-Steagall Act of 1933 which prohibited a commercial bank from owning speculative financial institutions.  It imposed restrictions on the integration of banking, insurance and stock-trading companies to protect the consumer from losing their money through risky investments.

Since the 1980s, the banking and investment sector has been pressuring Congress to repeal the Glass-Steagall Act to afford them the opportunity to increase their profits by using depositor’s money to back risky investments.  Their efforts succeeded when Congress passed the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act in 1999 which repealed Glass-Steagall and allowed commercial bankers to underwrite and trade instruments of a highly risky nature.  It also lifted most restraints on the monopolization of the institutions in the financial sector of the economy.

To compound the problem of deregulating banks, Congress passed an amendment to an appropriations bill which deregulated derivatives.  Derivatives are an extremely risky investment which is highly leveraged.  Banks would now be free through their investment arm to risk depositors’ money in an investment that should be reserved for those who want to gamble large profits at the risk of large losses.

By deregulating the banking system, freeing derivatives from regulation, and creating a privately owned Federal Reserve System paved the way for the financial crisis which is not only destabilizing the American financial system but the global one as well.  Deregulation and privatization are two of the main pillars in the free market economic system and their failure is proof that the non-wealthy members of society are adversely affected.  In this case, it is clear that privatization and deregulation were not intended to benefit the non-oligarchical members of society but to create opportunities for large accumulations of wealth.  The only hope of ending the financial crisis and avoiding another one is to reform the system to protect all the people.

State of Darkness: US Genocides since 1945.

http://www.stateofdarkness.com

Arnold Is Free To Choose

This past week, Naomi Klein bravely stepped into the lion’s den this week and addressed the University of Chicago, protesting their bid to name an economic research center after Milton Friedman.  It was a bravura speech where she made the argument that the current financial crisis is the final repudiation of Friedman’s twisted theories of unregulated capitalism.

More than that, what we are seeing with the crash on Wall Street, I believe, should be for Friedmanism what the fall of the Berlin Wall was for authoritarian communism: an indictment of ideology. It cannot simply be written off as corruption or greed, because what we have been living, since Reagan, is a policy of liberating the forces of greed to discard the idea of the government as regulator, of protecting citizens and consumers from the detrimental impact of greed, ideas that, of course, gained great currency after the market crash of 1929, but that really what we have been living is a liberation movement, indeed the most successful liberation movement of our time, which is the movement by capital to liberate itself from all constraints on its accumulation.

So, as we say that this ideology is failing, I beg to differ. I actually believe it has been enormously successful, enormously successful, just not on the terms that we learn about in University of Chicago textbooks, that I don’t think the project actually has been the development of the world and the elimination of poverty. I think this has been a class war waged by the rich against the poor, and I think that they won. And I think the poor are fighting back. This should be an indictment of an ideology. Ideas have consequences.

Now, people are enormously loyal to Milton Friedman, for a variety of reasons and from a variety of sectors. You know, in my cynical moments, I say Milton Friedman had a knack for thinking profitable thoughts. He did. His thoughts were enormously profitable. And he was rewarded. His work was rewarded. I don’t mean personally greedy. I mean that his work was supported at the university, at think tanks, in the production of a ten-part documentary series called Freedom to Choose, sponsored by FedEx and Pepsi; that the corporate world has been good to Milton Friedman, because his ideas were good for them.

But he also was clearly a tremendously inspiring teacher, and he had a gift, like all great teachers do, to help his students fall in love with the material. But he also had a gift that many ideologues have, many staunch ideologues have-and I would even use the word “fundamentalists” have-which is the ability to help people fall in love with a perfect imagined system, a system that seems perfect, utopian, in the classroom, in the basement workshop, when all the numbers work out. And he was, of course, a brilliant mathematician, which made that all the more seductive, which made those models all the more seductive, this perfect, elegant, all-encompassing system, the dream of the perfect utopian market.

Klein mentions the Free To Choose series, and later on she highlights something I forgot – the man who introduced one of those series on PBS:

“Being free to choose means being free to make your own decisions.  Free to live your own life, pursue your own goals, chase your own rainbow without the government breathing down your neck or standing on your shoes.  For me it meant coming to America, because I came from a socialistic country where the government controls the economy.”

That was Arnold Schwarzenegger in 1990, spouting free market fundamentalism in a corporate-sponsored documentary which mainstreamed ideas that today have brought us to the brink of economic failure.  It’s important to know what altar at which Schwarzenegger worships.  It’s important to know how he was, for a long time, the glitzy front man for Friedmanism, the showy snake oil salesman that got Joe Six-Pack to think that corporate behemoths eliminating rules for themselves was in the best interests of the common man.  If Friedman was P.T. Barnum, then Arnold was the star attraction in the center ring of the circus.  And he clearly believes, or at least is willing to front, that these ideas, about “free enterprise and free people,” are immutable, hard science, incapable of being wrong.  

Except we are now at a moment when, as governor, Schwarzenegger is bearing the brunt of the worst effects of unbridled capitalism.  His state is caught up in the credit market freeze, with no money to pay the bills.  He is begging the state’s citizens to buy bonds and bail the government out, an approach taken so clumsily that he got Wall Street shaken at the precise time when he has to go into the market to borrow money.  The state’s public infrastructure is crumbling on his watch and even that won’t be enough to make up the revenue shortfall.

A lot of people would let Schwarzenegger off the hook for this.  The national economy went bad, and the financial markets failed as a result of the housing bubble bursting, and surely the governor of California can’t be held responsible for that.  Except he is such a devotee of Friedmanism, and in fact one of its key pitchmen, that of course he is guilty.  Guilty of the same faith in capitalists not to be driven by greed.  Guilty of stripping regulation and empowering corporate America to live in a tax-free and restraint-free bubble.  And as the current cesspool of deregulation, where market forces run wild and greed becomes virtue, gets a reckoning due to the carnage it has caused, so too must the man who introduced Free To Choose all those years ago.  He was wrong then, and he’s doubly wrong now.  To quote Naomi Klein:

Ideas have consequences. And when you leave the safety of academia and start actually issuing policy prescriptions, which was Milton Friedman’s other life-he wasn’t just an academic. He was a popular writer. He met with world leaders around the world-China, Chile, everywhere, the United States. His memoirs are a “who’s who.” So, when you leave that safety and you start issuing policy prescriptions, when you start advising heads of state, you no longer have the luxury of only being judged on how you think your ideas will affect the world. You begin having to contend with how they actually affect the world, even when that reality contradicts all of your utopian theories. So, to quote Friedman’s great intellectual nemesis, John Kenneth Galbraith, “Milton Friedman’s misfortune is that his policies have been tried.”

It’s the ideological blinders that caused this crisis that must be taken off if we’re ever going to get out.  Schwarzenegger is somehow seen as the “good cop” Republican in the mix of California, wanting ever so to do the right thing.  But the one area of jurisdiction, the one part of this crisis where the California governor could have had a hand in stopping the bleeding, when he could have imposed regulations to help stop predatory lending and rein in the runaway mortgage market in one of the biggest bubble states in the country, Arnold not only decided to do nothing then, but has continued to do so.  Laissez-faire remains his core philosophy, the failed philosophy of conservative economics.

I guess the banks and the lenders need to be free to choose.

It would be irresponsible for state Democrats not to remind the public that the pain and anxiety they are seeing today is a cause of the insane embrace of Friedmanism, and that the man at least in large part responsible is the muscle-bound Governator who was willing to put a smiley face on the shock doctrine.

Speak Out California Is Back Up And Running!

Dave Johnson, Speak Out California

One day your website is yours, and the next day it is someone else’s.  Organizations, businesses and regular people are at the mercy of a confusing deregulated system.

A little over a week ago the Speak Out California website suddenly disappeared, and viewers instead saw a website full of advertisements.  

We had no way of even knowing what had happened.  It was just a surprise.  One day typing “speakoutca.org” into a web browser took viewers to our website, the next day it took viewers to an ad site that someone else managed.

Some of us are more sophisticated and internet-savvy than most citizens so we were eventually able to track down some information.  I’m not going into details here, except to say that no one at Speak Out California received any notice that this was going to happen.  It took several days to even track down where the domain name (this is what internet addresses like speakoutca.org are called) had been registered, who had registered it, and contact info for the registrar.  Then it took several more days to restore the domain name to us and get it working again.

Here’s the thing: the only way we were able to get this name back and get the site operating again is because some of us are much more internet-connected than most people.  Most people would have no idea where to even start to look for information and help solving a problem like this.

This is certainly not an uncommon problem.  My wife had a business named Dancing Woman Designs with a website at dancingwomandesigns.com, and then one day she didn’t.  She received no notice, nothing.  It was just there one day and gone the next and if she wanted it back it was going to cost her.  It was going to cost her a lot.  And so she doesn’t have dancingwomandesigns.com anymore and that address takes you to an ad site.  A whole business that took years to get going and build is history now.  It was wiped out in a minute because someone was able to get the web name.

A larger business is more likely to have the resources to hire the necessary experts to fight something like this.  But it can be an expensive proposition and it can take time.

This is the difference between regulation and deregulation.  Regulations protect regular people.  Deregulation enables and protects scammers, schemers, and cons.  The Internet is largely unregulated and is full of scammers, schemers and cons.  Most of the businesses and organizations on the internet are good, honest, credible and legitimate but regular people are also left completely at the mercy of numerous cons, scams, schemes and rip-offs and the burden is on us to find a way to tell the difference.

We got Speak Out California back up and running.  It only took us a week and a little money.  But we are sophisticated, internet-savvy and connected — and lucky.  Hmm … maybe some new legislation is warranted.

Click through to Speak Out California

Another Corporate Gimmick – Arbitration

Dave Johnson, Speak Out California.

Does your credit card or bank loan agreement have an “arbitration clause?”  More and more consumer-oriented contracts and “agreements” have clauses specifying that disputes must go to arbitration rather than our civil justice system.  The justification for this is that arbitration saves the time and expense of working within our legal system.  But here’s the thing: the corporations choose the arbitrators and every arbitrator knows they will never, ever, ever, ever (ever) get another job if they rule against the corporations.  Never.

And guess what: 98.8% of arbitrations end up in favor of the corporations.  This is not a surprise.

The Progressive States Network’s newsletter has a story about this today, Arbitration: “Set up to squeeze small sums of money out of desperately poor people”,

The headline above is a quote from former West Virginia Supreme Court Justice Richard Neely, describing what his role was as an arbitrator at the National Arbitration Forum (NAF), a for-profit company hired to enforce mandatory arbitration clauses for credit card consumer loans.  “NAF is nothing more than an arm of the collection industry hiding behind a veneer of impartiality,” says Richard Neely.

In a devastating expose by BusinessWeek, Neely and other former arbitrators describe an arbitration system stacked completely against consumers– a system where creditors win 99.8% of all disputes involving companies ranging from Bank of America to Sears to Citgroup. Arbitration clauses buried in the fine print of credit card offers means consumers lose the right to have disputes decided in an independent court and instead are forced into corporation-selected arbitration firms.

The BusinessWeek story mentioned in the Progressive States Network story is titled, Banks vs. Consumers (Guess Who Wins)

This story about credit card companies taking unfair advantage of consumers is one more attack on citizen rights to access our own legal system (one more of so many attacks). Think about what is happening here.  First the big corporations fought against “regulations” which are the rules that We, the People set up requiring safe workplaces or environmental standards, or products that do not injure people, etc.  Then when fewer regulations of course resulted in worker or consumer injuries or toxic spills or other harms the inured parties filed more lawsuits asking the companies to make good.  So in response to these lawsuits the corporate-financed “tort reform” movement came along, working to limit the ability of citizens to be compensated for the results of corporate bad behavior.  The result has been fewer regulations preventing harms and more restrictions on citizen access to courts where we can seek damages after we are harmed.  

I didn’t even bring up the corporate-conservative movement efforts to install their own business-friendly judges in the courts.

But even those erosions of our access to justice has not been enough for the greedy corporations.  Now there is arbitration: clauses that show up in contracts and agreements that remove your ability to take a dispute to the courts at all!  And the judges in these courts are dependent on the corporations for their livelihood!

Deregulation, tort reform and now arbitration that is rigged against the consumer.  Drip, drip, drip.  One after another the big corporations are eroding the rights of citizens.  

Click through to Speak Out California.

Flood Protection, Health Care, Deregulation and Big Money

(The Money Comes in, The Favors Go Out. It’s time to stop this cycle. So many issues would get a better crack at the apple if we didn’t have all this money flowing into Sacramento. Think about recommending this on Daily Kos. – promoted by SFBrianCL)

Cross-posted at Daily Kos

With the Katrina anniversary, there has been lots of talk about what government needs to do to protect citizens from another disaster. The other day, California Assemblymember John Laird told the Capitol Weekly, “We have less flood protection than they had in New Orleans. Sacramento is really not protected and the thousands of people who live here are at risk.” But this wasn’t a story about the anniversary, this was a report on how flood protection in California died a suspicious death in the legislature:

This week, just as Senate President Pro Tem Don Perata put on hold an eight-bill package of flood-protection legislation, one of his political committees received a $500,000 donation from the California Building Industry Association (CBIA), one of the package’s biggest opponents.

The donation is the single largest that a Perata committee has received since he became Senate leader in 2004.

In response, the California Majority Report noted, “As is the case with many policy areas that the legislature deals with, especially this time of year, eyebrows were raised about the timing of all of this.” In addition being a policy disaster that risks lives, these scandals harm people’s faith in government, decreasing participation in a vicious cycle that gives even more power to the special interests who run Sacramento.

In May, the Public Policy Institute of California polled on the issue (May 14-21, 2000 adult residents, +/- 2% MOE):

 

Do you think that campaign contributions are currently having a good effect or a bad effect on the public policy decisions made by state elected officials in Sacramento, or are campaign contributions making no difference?”

Good Effect 12%
Bad Effect 56%

The big money that controls Sacramento is so excessive, that it is easy to see why the polls show people realize how it is harming policy. If you check out yesterday’s San Francisco Chronicle, you’ll see an editorial blasting the “nasty moves” that special interests used to kill flood control. It is easy to see why people who pay attention are disgusted by the way Sacramento operates like an auction.

Special Interests Killing Universal Health Care Legislation

Yesterday, the California Assembly passed historic Universal Health Care legislation. This bill would save $8 billion a year and at the same time provide insurance for 6 million Californians. Sounds too good to be true? Well here comes the but…

Insurers have spent $3.7 million in campaign contributions in California since 2005.  Governor Schwarzenegger, who alone has received $765,000 from health insurers, has said he will veto the bill.

The big money has a proven ability to stop sound policy, and so California will waste $8 billion a year so that 6 million less people will have health insurance.

Special Interests New Deregulation

Public safety and health care aren’t the only areas where big money dominates in Sacramento. While lawmakers are holding dozens of fundraisers as they wrap up the legislative session, AT&T lobbyists are hitting the jackpot:

The Public Utilities Commission (PUC) gave AT&T and smaller Verizon permission to raise telephone rates at will, even as a telecommunications deregulation bill — a bonanza for AT&T and a bane to consumers — sped toward passage in the state Senate, jammed with last-minute amendments. […]

AT&T, while publicly billing the deregulation as beneficial competition in the video market, has not promised any rate reductions or other specific consumer benefits. It has poured nearly $18 million into lobbying efforts over the last few months, and $500,000 into direct political contributions during this election cycle, noted FTCR. That does not include contribution pledges made during legislators’ mad dash of fund-raising during the last three weeks of the legislative session, which ends next Thursday. These contributions will not be known until after the hundreds of measures still coming to a vote are passed or killed.

Yes, it sounds exactly like what went on during electrical deregulation, but as with flood protection, government can’t learn from past mistakes when special interests are running the show.

Solution: Proposition 89

Proposition 89 is the Clean Money and Fair Elections initiative that California will vote on this November. Put on the ballot by the California Nurses Association of anti-Arnold fame, the proposal addresses that systematic problems that are holding back good policy on a wide array of issues. Here are the details of Proposition 89.

Strict contribution and expenditure limits
Prop. 89 ends the fundraising madness with constitutional limits so regular voters aren’t drowned out by big money.
* Proposition 89 bans contributions from lobbyists and state contractors
* Proposition 89 limits contributions from corporations, unions, and individuals to state candidates
* Proposition 89 limits corporation donations to initiatives to $10,000

Clean Money public financing of political campaigns
Prop. 89 levels the playing field so new candidates can win on their ideas, not
because of the money they raise.
* With Proposition 89, candidates who agree to spending limits and to take no private contributions qualify for public funding
* Under Proposition 89, $5 contributions from voters required to prove viability
* With Proposition 89, lean candidates receive enough to run competitive campaigns. They can’t raise money beyond public funds

Tough disclosure and enforcement for politicians
Prop. 89 stops candidates from hiding behind negative ads and punishes politicians who violate the law.
* Proposition 89 makes wealthy self-funded candidates disclose the amount of personal funds they will spend
* Under Proposition 89, publicly financed candidates must engage in debates
* Proposition 89 imposes mandatory jail time and provides for removal from office of candidates who break the law.

The Challenge

Of course, the special interests who dominate Sacramento are spending at least as much money to stop Proposition 89 as they spend for each issue where they want to dominate the debate. While we won’t have as much money as the opposition, what we do have is a great initiative, a reality-based argument, lots of supporters, and trusted organizations like the League of Women Voters, Common Cause, California Nurses, the Consumer Federation of California and the Foundation for Taxpayer and Consumer Rights all aggressively and creatively working to pass the initiative.

We would also like to have your support. We have started a campaign blog to keep supporters up-to-date and would appreciate it if supporters would sign up for email updates. Thanks for reading all the way down.