Tag Archives: ACA

Legislative Recap on Health: #Health4All; Out-of-Pocket Costs; Medi-Cal, Etc.

The Senate and Assembly adjourned Thursday, one day ahead of the June 5th deadline to pass all bills out of the first legislative chamber. The good news is that most key bills of interest to health care consumers have passed out of the house of origin, while one bill, opposed by public health groups, was defeated. Bills moving forward deal with limits and protections against unfair out-of-pocket costs; efforts at improving Medi-Cal; and most notably a significant expansion of access to coverage for all regardless of immigration status.

These bills now head to the second half of the legislative process. For details on each bill, see our weekly bill matrix:

http://www.health-access.org/i…

Below the fold, full reports on:

* SB 4 To Take Historic Steps to #Health4All & Cover the Remaining Uninsured

* Patient Protection Bills To Limit Out-of-Pocket Costs

* Additional legislation on transparency, Medi-Cal, tobacco control, and more

SB4, THE FRAMEWORK FOR #HEALTH4ALL REGARDLESS OF IMMIGRATION STATUS

The most-watched health bill was SB4, the first bill to pass a state legislative body that would explicitly expand coverage regardless of immigration status. The California Senate passed SB4 on a historic and bipartisan vote, 28-11, with all Democratic senators and 2 Republican senators voting in support. This bill, which continues California’s path to #Health4All, moves on to the Assembly Health Committee for consideration.

With last week’s amendments in the Senate Appropriations Committee, SB 4 would:

* Expand Medi-Cal eligibility to all children regardless of immigration status, as an entitlement;

* Expand coverage for undocumented adults as budget allocations will allow (to be decided each year in the budget, and that enrollment will be capped if funding runs out).

* By way of a Section 1332 waiver (a formal request to the federal government), SB 4 would allow all Californians to purchase coverage through Covered California using their own money.

Senator Ricardo Lara, author of SB 4, called the vote “historic” and one that Senators will remember long after their term is over. “We are talking about our friends, our families, our neighbors. Illness doesn’t care about our immigration status,” said Lara, describing the bill as still “realistic, balanced, and fiscally prudent.”

Several Senators rose to speak during the floor debate. From the opposing side, GOP Senators Jeff Stone, Janet Nguyen, and Bob Huff raised concerns about cost, arguing that expanding Medi-Cal was a “false promise” until the program addresses access issues. Several Democratic Senators responded to that argument, including Senator Richard Pan who stated, “We certainly need to make fixes to Medi-Cal, but certainly being on Medi-Cal is better than being uninsured.” Senator Isadore Hall derided “excuses,” Senator Ben Hueso wanted focus on the issue at hand: “We have a solution on the table, and we should move it forward.” Senator Hernandez rebutted concerns about cost: “The most inefficient way to provide health care is through the emergency room-we all pay for it.”

The most noteworthy speech was by GOP Senator Andy Vidak announcing his support for the bill while also raising the need to address Medi-Cal access issues and federal immigration reform. He and another Central Valley Republican, Senator Anthony Cannella, were the two GOP Senators to vote for the bill. Senator Nguyen abstained, with the rest of the caucus voting no.

This issue is currently pending in Budget Conference Committee as a $40 million item in the Senate’s budget proposal. The next week or two will make a big difference in whether enrollment under SB4 would start in the budget year 2015-16.

BILLS LIMITING OUT-OF-POCKET COSTS

Four Health Access-sponsored consumer protection bills to prevent unfair out-of-pocket costs passed out of their “house of origin” this week and are heading to the second half and second legislative chamber in the weeks ahead. The remaining sponsored bill, AB 248 (Hernandez) on large employer junk insurance is further along in the process, having passed out of the Assembly several weeks ago.

* Requiring Accurate Provider Directories: SB 137 (Hernandez) would set standards for provider directories and establish more oversight on accuracy so people know whether their doctor and hospital are in network when they shop for coverage, change coverage, or try to use their coverage. SB 137 passed out of the Senate with bipartisan support. The final vote was 33-0.

* Preventing Surprise Bills: AB 533 (Bonta), which would protect patients from “surprise” bills from out-of-network doctors when they did the right thing by going to an in-network hospital, imaging center, or other facility, passed out of the Assembly with a vote of 74-1.

* Limiting Prescription Drug Cost Sharing: AB 339 (Gordon), which would prevent discrimination against consumers with health conditions by setting standards for cost sharing on prescription drugs passed out of the Assembly with a vote of 48-29.

* Capping Individual Out-of-Pocket Costs: AB 1305 (Bonta) on limitations on cost sharing in family coverage passed out of the Assembly with a vote of 78-0. This bill ensures that the ACA individual out-of-pocket maximum (now $6,600) will apply to individual patients-even if they are in a family plan (which has an overall family out-of-pocket max of $13,200).

* Prohibit Subminimum Coverage: AB 248 (Hernandez), which would prohibit sale of subminimum coverage by insurers to large employers passed out of the Assembly several weeks ago with a vote of 51-27 and will next be heard in Senate Health.

TRANSPARENCY

SB546 (Leno) would advance transparency in our health system by extending rate review to large group health coverage. This bill, which requires justification of above-average rate increases, passed out of the Senate with a vote of 23-16.

Other transparency bills faltered earlier this year, including SB 26 (Hernandez), which sought to create a health care cost and quality database, was held in Senate Appropriations Committee amid questions on how to finance it. Earlier in the process, AB 463 by Assemblyman Chiu to facilitate more disclosure on prescription drug costs was stalled in Assembly Health Committee. These efforts will likely be revisited in future years.

MEDI-CAL

Several bills designed to improve the Medi-Cal program, which now covers almost 12 million Californians, advanced out of their house of origin.

* SB 33 (Hernandez), which would limit estate recovery in Medi-Cal to the federally required minimum of long-term care services and eliminate recovery from the estate of a surviving spouse of a deceased beneficiary, passed out of the Senate with a vote of 33-0.

* AB 1231 (Wood), which would facilitate practical access to Medi-Cal specialty care through coverage of nonmedical transportation, also passed out with a vote of 76-0.

* AB 635 (Atkins), which would require the Department of Health Care Services to seek federal funding to establish a program to provide and reimburse for certified medical interpretation services to Medi-Cal beneficiaries with limited English proficiency, passed out of the Senate with a vote of 72-2.

* AB 366 (Bonta), which would require the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to report to the Legislature on Medi-Cal access passed out of the Assembly with a vote of 77-0.  Originally introduced as a measure to restore Medi-Cal provider reimbursement rates and bring them up to Medicare levels in future years, this bill came out of the Appropriations Committee’s suspense hearing significantly scaled back in scope. A companion measure SB 243 (Hernandez) was held in Appropriations during the suspense hearing and is not moving forward.

TOBACCO CONTROL

A handful of bills aimed at the negative health impacts of tobacco use passed, including SB 151 (Hernandez) to raise the smoking age from 18 to 21. SB 140 (Leno), which would revise the definition of tobacco products to include e-cigarettes, thus subjecting such products to the same regulations as other tobacco products, passed out of the Senate with a vote of 25-12.  Public health groups, including the Heart Association, Lung Association, and Health Access supported that measure and opposed the related bill SB 24 (Hill), which did not classify e-cigarettes as tobacco. Research suggests that e-cigarettes have much the same negative effect as cigarettes. SB 24 (Hill) failed passage.  

OTHER KEY CONSUMER BILLS

A full matrix of the latest on all active bills supported by Health Access and other health and consumer advocates is available online (here). That list includes ACA implementation legislation like SB 43 (Hernandez), which would extend the sunset date on essential health benefits standards from 2016 to 2018 and incorporate recent changes in federal guidance regarding habilitative care (services that help you keep, learn, or improve skills and functioning for daily living); AB 1117 (Garcia) would help bring more resources to Medi-Cal to improve immunization rates for 2-year-olds and AB 1299 (Ridley-Thomas) seeks to improve the delivery of mental health services for foster youth.

WHAT’S NEXT?

Now that these bills have passed the critical house of origin deadline, they will next be heard in the “other house,” meaning if the bill was introduced in the Assembly, it will be heard in the Senate, and if the bill was introduced in the Senate, it will be heard in the Assembly. Committee hearings will resume on June 8th. Policy committees have until July 17th to meet and report bills out of committee.

This blog entry is cross-posted at http://blog.health-access.org. It was written by Sawait Hezchias-Seyoum, Health Care Policy Advocate, Health Access. Stay tuned for tools and talking points to bring these bills to the finish line.  

Single Payer will come and you can help

First of all, knowledgeable activists believe that the ACA will benefit millions and its success will clear the road to Single Payer, the final destination.  If Obamacare fails, many of us understand that it will set back all healthcare reform back.  Then again the insurance companies are so greedy and the current system so dysfunctional, so expensive (increasingly) and unjust that it may self destruct if the ACA fails. Obviously the success of the Vermont Single Payer implementation is huge and we really look forward to it’s quick implementation.

Healthcare is a human right photo Healthcareisahumanright_zpsf85f378d.jpg

The ACA implementation is not trivial. Here in California, one of the leading ACA states, $1 billion has been budgeted, between federal and foundation contributions,  to enroll about 5.5 million people.  Covered California is enlisting all sorts of organizations to become certified enrollers. And the plan is to pay $58 per enrollee.  This alone comes out to be about $300 million.  Covered California is running a pretty tight organization and I wish them the best.

Once the exchanges are rolling by October 1st and once enrollees become enrolled by January 1st the ACA will gain momentum in California.  I will look forward to all the anecdotal account diaries of the positive impact of Obamacare on people everywhere.

So, paradoxically,  one way you can help Single Payer is to get involved in the implementation of the ACA.

More below the orange croissant.

Once the ACA becomes a reality, the road to Single Payer goes through the state “innovation waiver”  

To qualify for an innovation waiver, the state must establish that its reform plan would provide coverage that:

. Is at least as comprehensive as ACA coverage,

. Is at least as affordable as ACA coverage,

. Covers at least as many residents as the ACA would have covered, and

. Will not increase the federal deficit.

Again, here in California we have certain advantages when it comes to the innovation waiver.

SB 810

First of all California has tried to implement Single Payer for almost 30 years. 4 times a Single Payer bill got to or through the legislation in Sacramento and twice (SB 810) was vetoed by Gov. Schwarzenegger.  But the worst case scenario happened last year when SB 810 was stopped in the Senate for lack of 2 votes when 6 blue dogs voted against or abstained.  So SB 810 was stopped but the Single Payer movement has not and we are putting together a strategy that will cause Sacramento to apply for an “innovation waiver”.  I will cover it in more detail in future diaries.  I expect the launch to be on September 15. More below.  But bottom line, we have a plan that clearly covers (with minor modifications) the first 3 requirements for the “innovation waiver”.

There is one issue with the ACA that is more relevant in California than elsewhere.  I understand that Obamacare is a victory for Obama given the polarization in DC and the destructiveness of the GOP since he was elected in 2009.  I was very disappointed when Obama too Single Payer of the negotiating table and also when we ended up without a Public Option.  But the reality of DC and most red states is that the Tea Party/GOP is bent on sabotaging and/or defunding the ACA.  So the fight at that level goes on and I understand how important it is that Obamacare succeeds enough for the 2014 midterms.  The issue is the over 3 million (that’s a lot of people) undocumented workers.  Single Payer would cover them, the ACA does not.  The racist and xenophobic Tea Party/GOP would include undocumented even less than accept a Public Option, let alone Single Payer.  Heck, they are sabotaging immigration reform.

So yes Single Payer would cover more people than the ACA.

As far as the 10 year budget that proves that the new plan does not increase the federal moneys coming to California for the ACA implementation, it will require an economic study similar to the famous Lewin report of 2005.  We need a new one given that the Lewin group was purchased by the insurance companies and given that it’s a bit old.  It will cost about $200K-$300K and again we have a plan to get this new study funded.

AllCare alliance possible logo photo AllcareAlliancepossiblelogo_zpsad29bb4f.jpg

The organization behind the formulation of the strategy to go through this process and its implementation is the AllCare Alliance formed by a growing number of Single Payer organizations, unions and other non-profits in California.  Here is one of the possible logos for the alliance.

Another thing you can do in California to support the Single Payer movement is to join one of the Single Payer organizations.

California OneCare photo CaliforniaOneCarelogo_zps0c09e5c4.jpg

HCA photo HCAsquarelogo_zpsbb1477f9.jpg

 photo 5686b5c8-e165-408e-92b6-781529d9675b_zps2f676c6f.jpg

PNHP photo PNHPlogo_zps8936cadc.jpg

CaHPSA photo CaPSHAlogo_zpsd3245af2.jpg

Public Citizen photo PublicCitizenlogo_zps12ed7515.jpg

This is the beginning of the new Single Payer battle in the pivotal state of California.  The plan and the people are coming together.  Another thing you can do to make Single Payer a reality is to donate a bit of money.  Whatever you donate now, before our September 15th launch, will I will match up to $1000.  This will help us finish our web site and upgrade our software (I’m involved in this.) The California OneCare donation page works (I am on the Board of Directors).

Let’s do it.  For California, for the whole country, to save money and to save lives.



Single Payer System photo SinglePayersmall2-4.gif

UPDATE

Harry Reid agrees with us as LFT NSF noted;

Reid says Obamacare just a step toward eventual single-payer system

“What we’ve done with Obamacare is have a step in the right direction, but we’re far from having something that’s going to work forever,” Reid said.

When then asked by panelist Steve Sebelius whether he meant ultimately the country would have to have a health care system that abandoned insurance as the means of accessing it, Reid said: “Yes, yes. Absolutely, yes.”

The idea of introducing a single-payer national health care system to the United States, or even just a public option, sent lawmakers into a tizzy back in 2009, when Reid was negotiating the health care bill.

“We had a real good run at the public option … don’t think we didn’t have a tremendous number of people who wanted a single-payer system,” Reid said on the PBS program, recalling how then-Sen. Joe Lieberman’s opposition to the idea of a public option made them abandon the notion and start from scratch.

Reposted from DailyKos.com

[poll id=”

494

“]

Report: “Walmart Loophole” Allows Big Employers to Undermine Affordable Care Act

By Rebecca Band, California Labor Federation

We all know that working for Walmart is no picnic. They pay low wages, they slash hours, they offer little or no job security, they exploit and intimidate workers and they use sweatshop labor. That’s why Walmart workers are on strike this week, to protest the corporation’s greedy behavior and shady business practices. Learn more about the strike here.

Many of these striking workers earn so little that they’re eligible for public assistance, like food stamps and Medicaid. And that’s no accident; it’s exactly the way Walmart likes it. We as taxpayers foot the bill for their workers, and the corporate head honchos get even richer.

According to a new report released today by the California Works Foundation:

Walmart workers use 40% more public health care assistance than the retail average. The company’s use of public assistance costs California $86 million per year, including $32 million for health care. The 19% of Wal-mart workers who are uninsured cost the state $10 million and the country $202 million. If other companies followed Wal-mart’s practices, it could cost the state $410 million.

And these figures could skyrocket next year when the Affordable Care Act goes into full effect. The law is intended to ensure shared responsibility between workers, employers and the government. But thanks to the “Walmart loophole” in the ACA, big corporations can easily skirt their responsibility by forcing workers onto Medi-Cal. From the report:

Under the ACA, there is no penalty for employers whose employees receive coverage through Medi-Cal or responsibility to offer coverage to part-time workers. When employers fail to share the responsibility for health care, they shift the burden to the individuals who are least able to pay for their own care or insurance, and taxpayers, who pay the costs of insurance through Medicaid and safety net health services at the county level.

According to the report, it’s the biggest and most profitable corporations that are the worst offenders when it comes to slashing wages and hours to dump workers onto Medi-Cal. Walmart isn’t the only one — Papa John’s, Regal Entertainment Group, Krispy Kreme, Darden Restaurants (the owner of Red Lobster and Olive Garden), Burger King, McDonald’s, KFC, Dunkin’ Donuts, Taco Bell and Wendy’s have all publicly announced plans to cut hours and reduce employment in order to skirt their responsibility under the ACA.

And since the ACA also includes a major expansion of Medi-Cal for working families up to 138% of the Federal Poverty Line (which translates to $15,856 for a single individual and $32,499 for a family of four in 2013), even more low-wage workers at huge corporations will be eligible for Medi-Cal, and we as taxpayers will be footing an even bigger bill.

The report concludes:

If large employers add their employees to the Medi-Cal program, the costs can quickly add up for the state and federal government. On average, a non-disabled adults on Medicaid spent $4,362 in 2011. Under the ACA, they would be able to shift their costs to the government program without penalty.

Employers’ conversion of jobs from full-time to part-time has been a driving force behind the increase in the uninsured population over the last two decades. Now with the ACA about to take effect, they stand to benefit even further from the expansion of Medi-Cal and the state’s outreach and education to inform low-income Californians of their health options.  

Most employers and individuals will fulfill their responsibilities to provide or obtain coverage, but some large employers-those who are most able to contribute to health care coverage-are seeking an advantage at the expense of taxpayers and low income residents-those who are least able to afford the cost of health care-by pushing even more of their employees onto the Medi-Cal system.  This will only add to the challenges facing the state in successfully implementing the new health care law.

Read the full report here.

Learn more and take action at www.CloseTheWalmartLoophole.com

Medi-Cal, California Budget Woes, and the ACA

The unfortunate facts are what they are: California’s fiscal hardships are just as bad as you thought, possibly worse. According to a new report released this week, the cost of Medi-Cal in particular has put a real strain on California’s budget.

From coverage of the report this week:

Tops on the list of concerns in the report is the high cost of Medicaid, the federal program providing health care for the poor or disabled and administered here in California via the state program Medi-Cal. Funding for the health care services, and rules about eligibility and spending, are shared between states and the feds.

“The rapid growth in Medicaid spending has pushed aside other types of state spending,” says the report.  “Both the states and the federal government need to find ways to contain and control Medicaid costs.”

Regarding Medi-Cal, the question remains what will happen to the program–and how it will impact the budge–under the new Affordable Care Act, which a Daily News report indicates will provide health care (in part through Medi-Cal) to over 2 million residents in Los Angeles alone.

One pharmacist argues this week that the ACA will provide more competition to insurance companies, which could benefit health care providers and provide incentives for offering better care–competition could mean higher reimbursements.

From the article:

As a local pharmacy owner, […]the cash price of prescription drugs is not “stunningly less” than the insurance price. Insurance companies have been squeezing reimbursements to ALL healthcare providers (including pharmacies) over many years now, and have funneled money away from providers (who take care of patients) in order to boost corporate profits. […] those who have health insurance are ALREADY paying for the uninsured through the outrageous and ever increasing premiums that we pay. Being a business owner who provides generous benefits to my employees, I can attest to this fact first-hand. And the insurance companies, unchecked by real competition (that a government supported exchange would otherwise provide) keep raising their premiums at will.

Health Reform: One Year Old and Good for Kids

by Wendy Lazarus

In the year since President Obama signed the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) into law on March 23, 2010, a sea of ink and digital bits have been spilled on every possible angle of commentary and advocacy about the law.  But a year later, one simple conclusion deserves its share of sunshine:  Health Reform is good for America’s 74 million children.

The Good News:

Insurance companies are no longer able to deny any child health coverage for chronic conditions.  Common conditions such as asthma or diabetes were previously excuses for refusing coverage, even though these are the conditions that most often require health care for children.  These diagnoses are grim enough to receive anyway. You can imagine the relief, now, for families who no longer have to fear whether they can get basic health insurance for their child.  In California, alone, 1.1 million children and youth under age 25 have pre-existing conditions that previously would have resulted in health coverage denials.

Take, for example, this story from Celina, a MomsRising member from California. Her story demonstrates why moving forward with health care reform is critical for ensuring all kids have the chance to grow up healthy:


My child is adopted and was born with reflux and was later diagnosed with asthma. I cannot imagine what I would have done if his health was further compromised, because health insurance was denied due to a pre-existing condition. Thanks to our ability to secure ongoing health check-ups and keep his asthma under control, we have never experienced a full flare up nor have had to visit the emergency room. Which translates to many dollars saved!

Another relief to many families is that young adults can stay on their parent’s insurance through the age of 26. With a struggling economy, this option can be essential for young adults who are just getting started, and especially for those for whom a gap in health coverage would be life-threatening. Here’s an example from our colleagues at Young Invincibles: Sara, a 22-year-old with Type I Diabetes.  After she began working a part-time job, she no longer qualified for Medicaid, and, without insurance, she would have to pay over $850 a month to control her condition.  Her options are woefully limited without health reform.

When Sara found out about the cancellation of her health insurance, she tried to purchase insurance from her college campus, San Diego State University. However, after speaking with the school social worker, she found out that the plan would not work for her. It would only cover a maximum of $500 a year for over-the-counter prescriptions, nowhere near enough to meet her needs.

Looking to the private market has also not been an option. Although she works part-time while in school to help pay the rent, she does not earn nearly enough to pay the premium of a private market plan. As a result, Sara has stayed uninsured,

cobbling together various ways to maintain her health.

And it’s not just these individual stories that show how the law is making a difference.  After the first year, the impact of the expanded coverage can be seen in a rise in enrollment.  In California alone, Health Access estimates the number of newly eligible enrollees to be 200,000. And the California Public Employee Retirement System (CalPERS) reports to have enrolled 28,000 new older children.

For children and young people, especially, the focus needs to be on wellness and prevention-and it is under the Affordable Care Act.  The good news is that families cannot be required to pay co-payments for preventive screenings, a provision that will protect nearly 6 million children under age 19 in California alone.  By ensuring that children receive the right vaccinations and diagnoses, more expensive health care costs down the road can be avoided.  More good news: insurance companies can’t just drop children when they are sick or limit the lifetime value of coverage.

And, families will finally have more control over their own lives. Without being restricted to employer-based coverage, if a child has a condition that would have been previously denied, a parent can make employment decisions that are in the best interest of their family, without risking their child’s coverage.

The Challenge Ahead:

If we are to reach our goal of making sure all of America’s 74 million children are insured by 2014, we cannot sit back now and jeopardize these tremendous gains. We must encourage political leaders to ensure that federal funding and guidance are available for full and effective implementation of ACA.  

Making health reform work for families depends on states taking thoughtful and swift action, too. At this time when states across the country are struggling with serious budget deficits, we urge elected officials along with employers and philanthropic leaders to support states as they leverage the available federal funding for implementation as soon as possible.

As debate about the law continues in Congress and in the courts, we must remind ourselves that quality healthcare is good for our kids-and every child should have the opportunity to grow up healthy.

Wendy Lazarus is the Founder and Co-President of The Children’s Partnership, which advocates for improvements in child health care. Ms. Lazarus has been involved in advocacy for health coverage for all children for more than 35 years.