Tag Archives: Prop 24

The Case for Proposition 24

These last couple months, I’ve been writing on the internet arguing for the passage of California’s Proposition 24. Polls show we have one of the closest races of any California initiative, and nobody can say what the outcome will be on Tuesday. However, I have to say that my colleagues and I on the Yes campaign have been extremely heartened by the outpouring of support we’ve seen, especially from working Californians. These are teachers, healthcare workers, community organizers and civil servants who understand the dire situation California’s budget is in, and know that we need Proposition 24 to avoid things getting even worse.

A brief recap: in 2009, as part of a contentious budget deal, three new corporate tax loopholes were signed into law in California. As they are implemented, these giveaways will cost Californians $1.3 billion a year. The loopholes benefit large multistate corporations, not small business. Corporations can receive the breaks without hiring any new California workers; they can even ship Californians’ jobs overseas and still get a tax cut. Proposition 24 was placed on the November ballot to repeal these loopholes and make sure the corporations pay their fair share.

We’ve had an expensive campaign, and there’s been a lot of misinformation put out there. The main committee opposing Proposition 24, which attempts to mislead you into thinking its donors are small businesses, when in reality they get their money from well-heeled corporate giants like NewsCorp and Pfizer. That committee is on track to spend at least $15 million against us, according to the most recent finance reports. Of course, $15 million is chump change for a group of Fortune 500 companies, many of whom pay their CEOs at least that amount every year.

If they win, their millions of dollars will have earned more pink slips for California teachers. Their millions of dollars will have cost more working families in California their childcare. And their millions of dollars will put every aspect of our safety net back on the chopping board. Perhaps worst of all, their millions of dollars will not put a single Californian back to work.

We don’t expect the upcoming budget processes to be easy. We don’t expect to have the resources we need to provide every service and job that hardworking Californians deserve. But we do know that $1.3 billion will help us, and corporate tax loopholes will not. I want to thank all of you who have read my posts this election season, and I would make one final request: please vote Yes on 24, and please stress to your friends exactly how important winning this one is. We haven’t gotten the same amount of media coverage as some other campaigns, but we’re all going to be affected by the outcome of this race. Thank you, and please cast your ballot on November 2.  

The Happiest Corporation on Earth?

We were all children once, and if there’s one childhood experience in California we’d like to remember fondly, it’s going to Disneyland. After a day in that park, anyone would be justified in thinking that the people who put this place together truly care about all of us.

Sadly, we’ve learned more recently what the Disney Corporation really cares about: tax cuts. So much so, actually, that they’ve put in a million dollars to try and preserve tax giveaways that can be repealed by Proposition 24 in November. These tax breaks, if they aren’t repealed, are going to cost California $1.3 billion dollars annually, money that will be taken away from schools, social services and public safety. So you would think that Disney would have a very good reason to want to keep the tax cuts.

Unfortunately, when you look at the facts, it all just comes down to cash. Disney is not struggling to make ends meet- their net income in FY 2009 was $3.3 billion. They’ve found the money to pay their CEO well over $20 million in total compensation last year.

Maybe you’d argue that with a little more money, Disney will do good things that will in turn improve California’s economy. But that argument doesn’t hold water. Disney can’t seem to find $3 million that would drastically improve quality of life for its underpaid hotel workers in Anaheim. Disney has cuts thousands more jobs than it has created in recent years, according to one study. And just to make matters worse, Disney reported in July 2010 that it was sitting on nearly $3 billion dollars of cash equivalents.

That’s right. Nearly $3 billion. Double what Proposition 24 would restore to California’s budget, hundreds of times what’s needed to improve the lives of working Californians who call Disney their employer. Maybe Disney corporate executives are satisfied with their records and actions. But the rest of us can’t help feeling that Disneyland isn’t the happiest place on Earth, at least not anymore.

Start some real fireworks. Vote Yes on 24.

Learn more: www.paytheirfairshare.com

Restore our Competitive Advantage: Vote Yes on Proposition 24

Disclosure: I proudly work for Yes on 24

California has a proud history as being the most innovative state in the nation. Historically, we’ve provided top-notch services to our citizens, and our economy has grown stronger for it. Perhaps most importantly, California boasts the nation’s best educated workforce. It should come as little surprise that 5 of our public universities made U.S. News and World Report’s top 10 for best public universities this year (and UC Irvine came in 11th). Our education system, from kindergarten through graduate school, has always ensured that the nation’s most entrepreneurial businesses will arise in California.

Unfortunately, the current economic climate and years of budget crises have endangered California’s education system, and with it our way of life. To make matters worse, special interests pushed through a set of brand new tax loopholes during a budget deadlock in 2009. These giveaways are set to cost California $1.3 billion dollars a year, money that will be cut from education and the other vital programs that make California great.

Thankfully, there is a chance to remedy this situation and ensure tax fairness. Proposition 24 on the November 2 ballot would repeal the giveaways and restore the money we desperately need. In a time when regular Californians across the state are being forced to tighten their belts, Prop 24 ensures that wealthy corporations also pay their fair share. The savings we recover will also secure California’s status as the best-educated workforce for years to come.

Opponents of Prop 24 claim that repealing the giveaways will make California a bad place to do business, and businesses would rather have jobs go out of California than live without these loopholes. As Steven Maviglio pointed out at http://www.camajorityreport.co… the claim that businesses are moving jobs out of California is bogus. What’s more, the opponents base their claims on the equally bogus argument that Prop 24 affects small businesses. In reality, it is big corporations (many based outside of California) who are fully funding the smear campaign against Prop 24, and it is big corporations who would line their pockets with the giveaways.

Please support tax fairness and preserve our state’s greatest assets. Vote Yes on 24.

Learn more: http://yesprop24.org/

The Voices We Must Hear

(Disclosure: I proudly work for Yes on 24)

I wrote earlier about some of the horrific cuts we’ve seen to public education in California. Passage of Proposition 24 could alleviate at least some of the pain by restoring $1.3 billion that’s set to be gift-wrapped to multistate corporations that aren’t creating California jobs. After I finished talking to the teachers who I featured in the linked post, I spoke with other community activists who are seeing lives affected by draconian budget cuts. Their stories should stay with us as we cast our ballots in this election, and inspire us to vote for the change we deserve.

Karla Salazar, who works for AFSCME, told me the saddest story I’ve heard so far. One of her union members is a woman named Pamela Garcia, who works as a rec assistant at state parks. She’s the mother of 2 children. During the budget crises, she’s had her hours cut time and again, and now she’s down to 5 a week. On 5 hours a week, she couldn’t come close to paying the rent, and she and her children don’t have a home.

In case you want things to get worse, Astrid Campos of the California Partnership has more bad news. California Partnership is a coalition of community-based organizations that fight poverty, and they lobby Sacramento to try and protect the safety net for families like the Garcias. Despite their best efforts, the safety net is being ripped to shreds. If Prop 24 fails, she told me, we’ll lose childcare for families that are transitioning out of Cal-Works, the state welfare program. The adults in these families must work at least 32 hours a week, but they make less than $25,000 a year. Ironically, these cuts won’t even save the state money in the long run, as most of the 80,000 families affected will be driven back to welfare.

One bright spot I see is that the effort to stop these cuts has united communities. For instance, the Reverend Lewis Logan is working to extend these efforts to faith-based communities. Rev. Logan told me that faith communities are fundamentally concerned with justice, and Prop 24 is in the cause of justice. He speaks articulately about the distorted politics that created the need for Prop 24, pointing out that taxes are an investment in the skilled labor that corporations need. Essentially, he says, we’re playing a shell game.

Karla Salazar, Astrid Campos and Rev. Lewis Logan were blindsided by the corporate tax giveaways handed out in the 2009 budget process. Organizations like theirs, and the Pamela Garcias they represent, didn’t even get a public hearing. Thanks to Proposition 24, they have that public hearing now. We should hear them loud and clear, and vote Yes on 24.

Talking Budget Cuts with California’s Teachers

(Disclosure: I work for Yes on 24)

I had the opportunity to speak this morning with three California teachers about the budget cuts they’ve faced. We also discussed the high stakes of the November election and Proposition 24. All three of the teachers to whom I spoke, Mary Rose Ortego, Sergio Martinez and Tyrone Cabell, are working actively to try and restore the terrible budget cuts in our schools.

Mary Rose Ortega, who teaches third grade, summed up the state of affairs. “30,000 teachers have been laid off in the last 3 years”, she said. With the budget the way it is, she told me, we can expect thousands more pink slips soon.

The numbers became even more shocking when we discussed the effects on individual classrooms. I learned that class sizes have gone up to 40 in most elementary schools, and resources are incredibly scarce. Teachers are rationing paper, textbooks aren’t updated or replaced even when torn, and teacher’s aides have had their hours cut so students are getting even less one on one attention.

Sergio Martinez, who teaches fifth grade, highlighted the damage to the school infrastructure. “We’ve had nurses, counselors, librarians’ hours cut”, he explained. With the library being closed more hours each school day, kids can’t get to the books or the computers. If they don’t have those resources at home, they just aren’t getting them at all.

Of course, test standards haven’t changed one bit. Students and teachers are simply expected to do more with less, and only they will suffer the consequences.

Finally, Tyrone Cabell, who teaches special education, laid out the most chilling picture. Before the draconian cuts began, special ed classes in California were supposed to hold 8-10 students each. Now it’s 15. I asked him to describe how he does his job, and he simply told me “It’s impossible”.

Impossible. That is a word we should NEVER have to use in reference to educating our children. If California cannot give veteran teachers like Mary Rose Ortega, Sergio Martinez and Tyrone Cabell the resources to make their jobs possible, then California is failing our children. Meanwhile, in 2009 California handed a generous set of tax breaks to multistate corporations. If those corporations don’t pay their fair share, schools suffer. There’s just no way around it.

All three teachers stressed to me that passing Proposition 24 in November to end the corporate tax giveaways is a key first step in restoring the funding schools deserve. The corporations don’t want to give up their tax breaks, and they’re running a vigorous opposition campaign. Please stand with the teachers, not the corporations. Vote Yes on 24.

Yes on 24 Launches New Website

(Originally posted at the Pay Their Fair Share blog)

Disclosure: I proudly work for Yes on 24

Let me begin by saying I’m proud to have helped launched the brand new Pay Their Fair Share website, located at paytheirfairshare.com. If you’re in California, it’s your best resource to find out who’s really opposing Proposition 24 and why. Even if you aren’t in the Golden State, we hope Pay Their Fair Share gives a fresh look into the bad behavior of major corporations during our tough economic times. Below the fold you’ll find the first piece originally posted to the blog over at Pay Their Fair Share, which I authored. Other posts have previously appeared on this website.

New Committee Formed to Oppose 24 is More of the Same

We’ve written extensively on the hypocrisy of the main campaign opposing Proposition 24. Notably, they claim they’re a coalition that includes small businesses, when in reality their funding comes from multistate corporations, none of which could be considered ‘small’. Many of them have laid off workers in California and across the nation, and they aren’t hiring just because they’ve been handed some new tax giveaways.

However, there may be a second show in town. A new committee has formed to smear Prop 24, referring to itself as the “California Healthcare Institute Issues Committee”. Their initial filing, which the state received this week, lists Sandra Pizarro as the person controlling the committee. Pizarro is listed as a Vice President at, yes, the California Healthcare Institute.

According to its own website, the California Healthcare Institute (CHI) exists “to forward the interests of California’s biomedical community”. That’s hardly objectionable on its surface. But who calls the shots at the CHI?

Well, the board of directors includes a lot of corporate executives, some of whom work for very familiar companies. For instance, there are executives from Amgen, Pfizer, Roche (which owns Genentech), Johnson & Johnson, Edwards Lifesciences, Gen-Probe Incorporated, Abbott Laboratories, Allergan and Medtronic Inc. What do these companies have in common? They’ve each given thousands to the main committee against Prop 24, the supposed coalition including small business. Combined, they’ve already poured in over $2.7 million.

While this new committee hasn’t raised money, it clearly has an affluent donor pool to work with. More likely than not, the plan is to use the committee name to trick Californians into thinking Prop 24 would somehow harm their healthcare.

That argument won’t hold water. If anything, many Californians have seen their healthcare harmed by draconian budget cuts, cuts that will only get worse if these corporations succeed in their campaign. If we really care about healthcare issues in California, we’ll vote Yes on 24 and make these giant companies pay their fair share.

Surf Putah’s CA Ballot Initiative Guide

Early voting is already underway (I just got mine in the mail yesterday) so I thought I’d toss this out there in case anyone’s interested. Every election we have to sort through a ton of these initiatives. I encourage everyone to read through the fine print yourself, and to turn off the teevee entirely, given the utter dreck that passes for ads and debate out there. For what it’s worth, this is how I see ’em.

Every ballot has a collection of themes, this ballot comes down to four: Pot Legalization, Redistricting, Taxes and Budget, and Global Warming:

Legalization

YES on 19

This is a huge opportunity to reverse the decades-long colossal error of marijuana prohibition, and has no credible downside that I can see if you aren’t currently employed growing pot illegally. We need the revenue legalization and regulation would bring, we need the cost savings from not arresting, prosecuting, jailing, and paroling thousands and thousands of otherwise nonviolent people, and we need to cut a major revenue stream out from under organized crime. Right now we already pay any societal cost of drug users, be it stoned driving, teen use or what have you. Prohibition has not ended those things, but is has wasted a colossal amount of budget money and destroyed thousands and thousands of people’s’ lives (and future earning potential, which means future tax revenue) with the knee-jerk incarceration policies of Prohibition v. 2.0. If 19 passes, cops can spend their time focusing on the crimes they’re currently not prosecuting for lack of resources, growers will stop wasting water and electricity and housing growing plants indoors that will thrive outdoors, our national parks won’t have clandestine pot plantations because it can be grown in regular old farms, those who grow pot today will find their profit margins lessened and will pay taxes on what profits they do make, and the international criminal cartels that rely on the drug war-inflated commodity price for what is essentially a weed will have a lot less money to buy guns with. No doubt moral scolds will find something else to get hot and bothered about, they’re pretty resourceful people. No downside.

Redistricting

NO on 20, YES on 27

Redistricting should be done by the majority, not these supposedly nonpartisan panels that end up being populated by well-off, well-connected political types in Sac. If people wanted to really reform, they’d ditch districts entirely and go for proportional representation. Anything short of that will necessarily have weird gerrymanders, just as a function of the uneven distribution of people (and political leanings) in this state, compounded by the Voting Rights Act requirements for minority districts. Secondly, it is a hypocritical and cynical GOP strategy for self-titled reformers to retain GOP partisan control of redistricting in Florida, Texas, Ohio, etc. while demanding CA give the GOP an equal seat at the table. It’s asinine. Somehow the republic survived gerrymandering in the two centuries between Eldridge Gerry and the last election. This is a solution looking for a problem.

Taxes and Budget

YES on 21, NO on 22, YES on 24, YES on 25

All of these props grow out of the constitutional and budgetary wreckage left by Prop 13, and while none is the silver bullet repeal of 13 en toto that I’d like to see, all attempt to patch up a broken system, to varying degrees of effectiveness. Props 21 and 24 plug holes in the deficit created by Schwarzeneggar’s cuts of the vehicle license fee and the yearly budget hostage crisis, while 25 repeals one key part of prop 13, the supermajority requirement to pass a budget, that has enabled a shrinking rump minority GOP to effectively demand whatever crazy shit it wants in exchange for the state government not going into default. Mostly those demands have come in the form of pointless and cruel spending cuts (which prop 21 would restore for state parks), or tax breaks for wealthy corporate donors of theirs (which 24 would repeal). While the greater structural problem will persist until the ability to set tax rates is also decided by majority vote (or the Democrats manage to cross the 2/3 threshold in both chambers), just getting timely simple majority budgets will be a godsend for schools, state workers, and any business that contracts with the state. Keeping everyone hanging all summer as the usual idiots make their demands (“give us corporate tax cuts or the schools get it!”) is terrible for business, is terrible for anyone who relies on any aspect of state government, and is no way to run a state.

Prop 22 means well, in trying to protect local government from the annual Howard Jarvisite antics in Sacramento, but it will unfortunately cause serious problems in a reality where passing a budget and raising sufficient revenue can still be held hostage by a recalcitrant superminority of right-wing legislators. it is bullshit that the state government regularly steals sorely needed funds from municipal governments in such a painful recession, but walling those funds off will end up forcing even more severe cuts at the state level – quite likely in education – that end up coming back to gut local government from a different angle (especially for towns like Davis, where all major employers are connected to the state govt in some way (UCD, State of California, public k-12 schools, etc.). The dependence of local government on state funds is a direct consequence of prop 13’s freezing of property tax revenue, as is the inability of the state govt to raise sufficient funds to help local governments cover that shortfall. The solution isn’t in building more internal firewalls within the shrinking cage of CA state government – the trap is to force us all to fight each other for the scraps while the powerful interests feast – it is in breaking us all out of the cage we’ve been put into.

Global Warming

NO on 23, NO on 26

Prop 23 has been written about a fair amount, in essence it’s a Texas oil corporation-funded attempt to repeal a law (AB 32) that might cut a bit into their profit margin, and it deserves to be shot down on the merits. The sneaky one is prop 26, which while pretending to be about the great tax and budget battles, is really just a covert way of trying to gut California’s ability to regulate carbon emissions by making any fees or penalties on polluters subject to the same supermajority requirement that has made our state budget into a basketcase. While 23 is bankrolled by Valero and other texas oil corporations, 26 is funded largely by Chevron, Occidental and the California Chamber of Commerce. Both propositions are an assault on California’s burgeoning green tech industrial sector, and an attempt to bind the state economy inextricably to the carbon economy and the oil corporations that fuel it, so that they can continue bleeding us dry. As such, both threaten California’s future in an existential sense, both in terms of our dependence on a peaking and increasingly expensive energy source, and in terms of locking in a disastrous set of climate consequences as that future carbon goes into the atmosphere. California is at root an ag state and a tourism state, and climate change will exact painful costs from both sectors of our economy. Don’t let the oil corporations steal our future.

originally at surf putah

[poll id=”

407

“]

Robert Reich Endorses Yes on Proposition 24

Disclosure: I proudly work for Yes on 24

Many political disputes are rooted in disagreements over how the economy works. Even for people who are civically engaged, the economic questions can become very difficult to navigate. Luckily, we have some world-class economists in the United States whose careful, reality-based analysis we can rely upon. Robert Reich is one of those people.

Reich’s biography is familiar to most, including his stint as Secretary of Labor in the 1990s. It should not be understated that his experience has made him one of America’s foremost experts in job creation. He has a deft understanding of the subject that easily surpasses the political pundits who will usually shout louder than he.

Now Robert Reich has spoken up regarding California’s Proposition 24 and his words should ring true. I encourage you to read and pass on the full press release with Reich’s comments, located below the fold.  

           For Immediate Release: 10/4/2010     Contact: Richard Stapler, (916) 443-7817

Former Secretary of Labor Reich Endorses Yes on Proposition 24, the Tax Fairness Act

          Says Breaks Don’t Create Jobs, “Regular Taxpayers Get Left Holding the Bag”

SACRAMENTO – Former Secretary of Labor and current U.C. Berkeley Professor Dr. Robert Reich has endorsed Yes on Proposition 24, the Tax Fairness Act:

“The Tax Fairness Act moves California in the right direction. It ends three extraordinarily bad corporate tax giveaways that will not save or create a single job.

As a former US Secretary of Labor, I can state emphatically that these narrow tax breaks for large corporations do not stimulate job creation, nor do they figure significantly in corporate decisions to locate in or relocate out of the state. Education, work force and other factors are much more important.

Rewarding a handful of large corporations – many of which are sitting on billions of dollars in cash – by giving away sorely needed funds absolutely does not create jobs. Claims otherwise are simply not credible. Passing Proposition 24 will level the playing field between regular taxpayers and corporations. Remember, the more corporate taxes get cut, the more likely regular taxpayers get left holding the bag. That’s not fair.”

Dr. Reich is currently a Chancellor’s Professor of Public Policy at U.C. Berkeley’s Goldman School of Public Policy. From his biography: Robert B. Reich has served in three national administrations, most recently as secretary of labor under President Bill Clinton. He also served on President-Elect Obama’s transition advisory board. He has written twelve books, including The Work of Nations, which has been translated into 22 languages; the best-sellers The Future of Success and Locked in the Cabinet; and his most recent book, Supercapitalism.

Proposition 24, the Tax Fairness Act, ends $1.3 billion in special tax loopholes for big corporations that don’t require the creation or protection of one single job in California. Proposition 24 will not raise taxes and prevents more budget cuts to schools, public safety and other important services.

For more information, see: http://yesprop24.org/.  

10 Things You Should Know About Prop 24

(Cross-posted on the Live Wire)  

Five ballot measures on the November ballot could bring great changes to the state budget and the way revenues are raised in California: Propositions 21, 22, 24, 25 and 26. Proposition 24 would repeal $1.3 billion worth of corporate tax breaks enacted under Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.

SEIU California and the California Labor Federation support Prop 24. Meg Whitman is against it.

According to a recent analysis by the non-partisan California Budget Project, the tax breaks that Proposition 24 would repeal, if

fully implemented, will cost the state $1.3 billion or more per year. … These tax breaks are distinguished by their cost, by the fact that they were approved at a time when the state faced enormous and ongoing budget shortfalls, and by the fact the [sic] most of the benefits would go to a tiny handful of corporations that will receive large tax breaks.

These tax breaks are the price exacted for passing a state budget under Schwarzenegger, the ransom for not massacring a roomful of public services entirely. Now, corporations can pick and choose how they’re taxed each year (“SSF apportionment”), even changing their mind each year depending on what’s most convenient for minimizing their tax bill. They can also transfer tax credits and carry back net operating losses (NOL), and take advantage of all three of these tax breaks at the same time.

The CBP report runs 12 pages (14 with footnotes), but here are a few highlights of what will happen under the Schwarzenegger corporate tax breaks unless Prop 24 is passed by voters. Read this, then get out your own 1040 for last year and see how well yours compares:

1) Nine corporations (yes, just 9, or 0.001 percent of all the corporations in California) will get tax cuts of more than $20 million each. 28 utility corporations (including San Bruno firebug PG&E) will receive tax cuts averaging $1.5 million each.

2) One-third of the total revenue loss — $420 million — would go to 210 “double dippers” (corporations claiming both SSF and NOL). Ten corporations (0.001  of the total) would get combined tax breaks exceeding $20 million, the average tax cut being $24.8 million per year.

3) More than one-quarter (28%) of NOL benefits would go to firms claiming more than $100 million in deductions, offsetting the tax on $1.1 billion in profits.

4) 80 percent of the benefits of SSF apportionment will go to corporations making more than $1 billion per year, or 0.1 percent of all California corporations.

5) 95 percent of the benefits of double-dipping ($399 million) would go to just 79 corporations grossing more than $1 billion a year.

6) “Most of the corporations that have advocated for California to adopt SSF apportionment have also supported efforts at the federal level … [so that] the profits of particular corporations would no longer be subject to tax in particular states. … Taken together, SSF and [federal law] would significant increase the share of corporate profits that are not subject to tax in any state.”

7) “The interaction between NOL carrybacks and the state’s school spending guarantee is particularly perverse. NOL carrybacks would reduce revenues that supported a level of school spending used to calculate the spending guarantee for the next fiscal year. … The magnitude of the revenue loss attributable to carrybacks — over $500 million at full implementation — is significant.”

8) While “profits reported for state tax purposes have increased significantly, … corporate tax payments as a percentage of corporate profits have fallen by nearly half since 1981.”

9) Despite claims by corporate advocates,

“state and local tax cuts and incentives are not effective for stimulating economic activity or creating jobs in a cost-efficient manner. On the contrary, by forcing reductions in public services, tax cuts and incentives may retard economic and employment growth.”

10) When your kids’ schools can’t afford to buy books or repair crumbling classrooms, when you can’t get decent health care because the clinics and hospitals you could afford have died of budget cuts, when you don’t feel safe walking down the street because your city can no longer afford police or animal control officers, when you wait hours/days/weeks for appointments at the DMV or any other public office …

… remember that this is the California that Meg Whitman wants for you: where we will literally pay with our lives so that the state’s richest corporations can grown even richer.

Download the full report from the California Budget Project.

Rupert Murdoch Uses his Money to Promote Regressive Agenda- Again

Disclosure: I proudly work for Yes on 24

       Rupert Murdoch is a powerful man. The Australian billionaire owns News Corporation, which is the world’s third-largest media conglomerate. In American politics, he’s perhaps best known as the man in charge of Fox News, the self-proclaimed ‘fair and balanced’ media source that often serves as little more than a mouthpiece for right-wing agendas. The one advantage we have is that we can judge Fox News with full knowledge of what it is.

Murdoch’s use of his company to promote a political agenda extends further though. News Corp is one of several huge media corporations to shell out 6 figures to smear Proposition 24, which will be on the California ballot in November. Proposition 24 would repeal an absurd set of tax giveaways that were gift-wrapped in 2009 to large corporations during California’s budget negotiations. They are set to cost California billions of dollars desperately needed for education and other vital social services. And they have many defenders who would like nothing more than to defeat Proposition 24.

Of course, you won’t see Rupert Murdoch’s name on advertising that attacks Prop 24. Instead you’ll see a committee name that undoubtedly includes the word “jobs”, and talks about small businesses. They won’t mention that all their funding comes from large corporations like Murdoch’s, and that the money would go to them, not to small business.  

       Rupert Murdoch wants to keep that money. If he succeeds, it might get lost in a pile. Forbes Magazine estimates that Murdoch himself is worth well over $6 billion. He has not suffered the way ordinary Californians have from the economy and ongoing budget crises, and it would be ludicrous to say that he and his company need more tax giveaways.

      The share of California’s money that Murdoch wants his company to keep is the difference between keeping good teachers in their classrooms, or distributing pink slips. It is the difference between retaining the in-home care that disabled and elderly Californians rely upon, or leaving the helpless to fend for themselves.

The urgency of Proposition 24 is real, and greedy billionaires like Rupert Murdoch cannot be allowed to deny Californians what we need. Vote Yes on 24.